What's new

Profiling Narendra Modi’s Critics

End of oct, do you really want me on this thread?? this seems like a typical rant from an nri who believe he knows everything and others opinion doesn't matter. Hard to convince a closed mind. Plus he hardly has seen what is happening on the ground.

I don't know everything and I have already stated in this thread that my opinion does not matter a bit. ;)
I am not old enough to have a closed mind yet, it's only that the people who are trying to convince
me are doing it while insulting me. That's a poor sales men tactics.

Me being NRI has little bearing to the topic, except that it gives a stick to beat me up. It matters naught in the context of this debate.
 
.
I don't know everything and I have already stated in this thread that my opinion does not matter a bit. ;)
I am not old enough to have a closed mind yet, it's only that the people who are trying to convince
me are doing it while insulting me. That's a poor sales men tactics.

Me being NRI has little bearing to the topic, except that it gives a stick to beat me up. It matters naught in the context of this debate.

Drat! So that's what I was doing wrong!

I have a closed mind, I confess, towards closed minds.

Your being an NRI has little bearing on what I have argued in this thread, except that it evidently saves me a beer or seven.
 
.
Everyone has an opinion, remember? And neither I nor any other critic has to prove anything; we just have to vote. It's those in power who have to prove whatever they think will convince people to vote for them, and for those not in power to prove the opposite.

I am not a BJP spokesperson. From the looks of things they are doing well to convince people of their deeds. That however can be skewed. BJP could be selling snake oil for all we know. Unless we debate with facts on table, it's hard to discern the facts from fiction.

Not really true. There are more than enough Reddys in the BJP; not much difference in numbers. You must know how your own conversations go; you are the ones who 'survived', the weak and poor are simply the ones who didn't, who couldn't, who in some Darwinian sense have lost the battle of natural selection.

My spitting on the PM and the President (but after the PM, the Vice President more than anyone or anything else in ceremonial positions) doesn't mean that I hate their caste. Why should I, being a Shudra myself?

The reason why you are a caste-obsessed bigot, and don't take it personally, if you are free this weekend, I'll buy the beer, is because you automatically saw the matter in terms of which caste is supported or should be supported. Why I hate the BJP is because they are trying to disenfranchise huge masses of our citizenry on the grounds of religion. Not because of their caste, which factor they use to manipulate the electorate just as much as any other.

Nope on Reddy's supporting BJP. The first choice of Reddy's in AP is Jagan and in Telangana is still Congress. In Karnataka though it's a different matter and the fact is BJP has sold their soul in courting the corrupt Reddy brothers from Bellary.
You are right on me surviving and I did it because of my hard work and dumb luck.
Btw, did you know Reddy's were also Sudhras at the time of kakatiya Empire?

Although I appreciate your offer, I don't drink but will take up the offer of a soda when I am India. Still, I didn't bring my caste into the discussion. You should go through our posts again to see who brought in the caste.
My name is an oxymoron - It's combination of geography and caste to show the absurdity of holding on to caste in a place where the actual Reddy's no longer exist. You would only understand this if you can discern what KDP stands for. :)

My knickers remain well-aligned and supportive on all important issues; and I know that you are taking a logical line to prove one side, and that is how it should be. I have tried to show what the difference is between being unable to get away from caste and being hostile to anything that seems to downgrade one type of citizen, one type of identity against others. Or upgrade one over the others.
In principle I don't disagree with you on this.

Progress? Civilisation making its winding way into the future? And since when were Hindus Congress supporters? The party line is that they won elections by cultivating the Muslim vote, and pandered to the orthodox Muslims who are supposed to have dominated the community in order to win votes.

History is brutal. Congress won elections under Indira with their party symbol as COW & CALF. The pandering you refer to is a more recent phenomenon, which started under Rajiv Gandhi. Perhaps why BJP rose in power so quickly.

Of the 41% who voted BJP/NPA last general elections, the hard-core saffron constituency was between 13 to 16%, the economically-disappointed and aspirational lower middle class most of whom represented the flood of the rural aspirant to the cities from 47 onwards was another 20%, and the bitterly hostile to the Congress or to the Communists (for hugely different reasons in the two cases) between 5 to 7%.

I hate all the parties equally, as you seem to do, but I vote for someone other than the party currently in power, the opposite of what you seem to be doing.

I voted for BJP for following reasons.
1. Economy
2. Defence
3. Infrastructure
4. corruption
5. Self-Preservation
6. Nepotism

If I see any party that can show they can do all these 6 things better than BJP, I would vote for that party.

Drat! So that's what I was doing wrong!

I have a closed mind, I confess, towards closed minds.

Your being an NRI has little bearing on what I have argued in this thread, except that it evidently saves me a beer or seven.

It was aimed at the ex-service gentlemen who took some shots at me.
 
. . .
its weird that hindus promote right wing conservatism back home(and completely disregard minority rights), but abroad they go with liberal crowd(they hindu-trump love notwithstanding) ... is it just self preservation that promotes this hypocrisy?
 
.
its weird that hindus promote right wing conservatism back home(and completely disregard minority rights), but abroad they go with liberal crowd(they hindu-trump love notwithstanding) ... is it just self preservation that promotes this hypocrisy?

It's absolutely weird to see liberals not blinking at extermination of Kashmiri Hindus but get their knickers in a twist for Rohigyas.

Can we just stop pretending and deal with reality of what each group represents here please?
 
.
Posted in other thread but it deserve here.

Modi got only 31% vote share in 2014 in 2019 50% is already confirmed.
Sickulars your acchedin will come soon Inshallah Amen. Cry sickulars cry.:chilli:
 
.
A sample of Modi critics, the media, who are being exposed daily by SM.

http://myvoice.opindia.com/2017/10/...85.2099550042.1506746148-948857318.1463739942

(Facebook has set out 10 tools to check Fake News. A few give-aways are headlines, source, evidence and photos. Indian Express, no surprises here, continues to be the leader of Fake News in Mainstream Media –call it Lutyens’ Media).

Indian Express today had a four-deck headline on its front page: “Farmers, small business must not suffer, RSS chief tells govt” (Sub headline: Mixes praise for Modi with caution, seeks “new provisions” in Valley).

On the parameters set out by Facebook, this is clearly a Fake News. RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat never said the “Farmers, small business” are suffering; and even if he thought so, he never addressed it to the government!

Indian Express chose “small business” as the essence of Bhagwat’s speech even though he had some quite explosive opinions on mischief-makers in today’s India: The RSS chief asked for some constitutional provisions of J & K to go; he wanted Rohingyas to be thrown out on security; and he exhorted those involved in cow-protection to keep up their good work and not be dissuaded by sinister coining of word “vigilantism” to make them appear criminal. Pointedly, Bhagwat had said: “Many activists who were peacefully involved in cow protection were attacked and killed. This issue is neither discussed nor being inquired into.” (His entire speech can be watched

Yet, Indian Express found merit in giving a Fake Headline to Bhagwat’s speech. They ignored the sumptuous praise which Bhagwat had reserved for Prime Minister Narendra Modi. The evidence of their foul play is the headline in its web-edition: “RSS chief praises Modi”, some 20 hours earlier before it was fabricated for the print edition!

One can understand this anxiety of a mouthpiece of Left ideology to keep harping on India’s economy in view of the forthcoming Gujarat assembly elections. Such assault on India’s economy also finds expression in running down “Bullet Train,” more so in the wake of recent stampede tragedy in Mumbai.

Thus you have a story running down “Bullet Train” in Lutyens’ Media. Today, Express has given big displays to P. Chidambaram, Raj Thackeray and Uddhav Thackeray, so much so that it almost makes up the entire Page 9. Never mind, such set of people not long ago were worrying that speed of our trains haven’t changed since 1971. This sort of ideology was against metro in cities. Remember the outrage on Mumbai-Pune expressway project? It is this expressway which has made Pune so alluring to corporate and IT sectors. Yojana Bhawan had once declared the Maruti Project as a pipedream. Such ideology couldn’t care less that land prices along the Bullet Train would shoot up and bring a great deal of investment, growth and jobs.

Bullet Train as such is not a Fake News in Indian Express but when politicians and media work in tandem, who are we to disbelieve our politicians and Lutyens’ Media are not part of the same ecosystem which is intent on spreading mischief, a softer version of Fake News?

Another such example of acting in concert is on Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd, director of a centre in the Maulana Azad Urdu University in Hyderabad. The man has gone berserk in claiming his life is under threat for writing books such as : “Post-Hindu India, Buffalo Nationalism, Untouchable God” etc. Among his suggestions are to say prayers in English. For the last four months, this ecosystem of mischief and fake news are fuelling each other on Shepherd. Yesterday it was Indian Express, today it’s Times of India which has splashed his interview in its edit page. No prizes for second guessing that Scroll, Wire etc. have long set the agenda rolling.

Now all those who interview Shepherd, don’t ask him some simple questions: “Sir, why you have nothing ever to say about the discrimination and oppression within Muslim communities?” Or “Sir, why don’t you mention the Reservations which the state grants to your oppressed community of Dalit-Bahujan, depriving many meritorious of the upper castes?” Or, “Sir, any views on why the Leftists, whom you support, have zero representation of Dalit-Bahujans in their top hierarchy?”

Such agenda is visible everywhere. Today, in Indian Express we have a full page interview with a Magsaysay award winner outlining the system’s failure. The less said about Magsaysay awards the better for the CIA-Ford Foundation links in its background are unmistakable. Arvind Kejriwal, or Manish Sisodia, would certainly have something to say on it.

Then there are two pages on the plight of manual scavengers in Indian Express. There are many reasons to sympathize with their plight; but every reason to condemn the attempt to link it with Swachh Bharat mission and by inference show it in poor light. Even as the word is pouring in on Swachh Bharat’s success.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom