Pakistan's P-3C vs. India's P-8I :: India, Pakistan and the Naval Balance

[danish_vij]

P8 While its nice and dandy however P3C is enough for us to Air Craft carriers and Other Ships

P8 is no contest even our F7 can knock it out or heck even a armed K-8

ohhhhh.....one eye close again

P8 is no contest for F7????
but P3C can takeout aircraft carrier withouht any contest ??......
so basically P8 can b shot down by F7 nd jf17....but mighty P3c will cruise passing through mig29


bhaai jang tum hi jeetogee

 

[HAIDER]

well kid you dont have any idea about indian neuks whatsoever and not just you most of the members barring a handfull here trust me there is a reason why.. lets not talk about it

point is P8s of IN or for that matter any of the arms inida gets are bought thru payment in hard cash and every defence supplier wants to sell there merchandise to us and even agreeing on certain TOT so that we dont face a breakdown during santions

now USA cant offord to overlook India if it wants to keep its supremacy intact in asia so its not stupid enof to choose to put santions on us hell they are doing the opposite what many pakistanies dream of and thats becuse of owr hard work over the years

as for your opreations in fata or any other part of pakistan well thats your internal matter and dont worry when (god forbit) if there is any war kind of situation here trust me we indians have a surprise wepon and thats called "jugar" your nation saw its power in 1999 and trust me this time around its potency against your forces will be uncontrlable ... good luck

There is not thing TOT in this world. Don't live in fools world son. And you know it very well. Can give as many example you want...

 

[Lil Mathew]

P8 While its nice and dandy however P3C is enough for us to Air Craft carriers and Other Ships

Its enough for our needs @ Present

P8 is no contest even our F7 can knock it out or heck even a armed K-8

Sure P8 has a slightly improved radar , so what we get the information we need from P3 Orions and that works for us

P3C enough for aircraft carrier??? P8 is no contest against F7??
You really not know the role of a maritime patrol aircraft..

 

[ni8mare]

ohhhhh.....one eye close again

P8 is no contest for F7????
but P3C can takeout aircraft carrier withouht any contest ??......
so basically P8 can b shot down by F7 nd jf17....but mighty P3c will cruise passing through mig29


bhaai jang tum hi jeetogee

exactly.......

theirs logic>>>>
we can shoot down all ASW aircraft using missiles
we can drown all the destroyers and frigate using subs and missiles
we can hunt down all subs using subs and missiles

 

[danish_vij]

exactly.......

theirs logic>>>>
we can shoot down all ASW aircraft using missiles
we can drown all the destroyers and frigate using subs and missiles
we can hunt down all subs using subs and missiles

hahaha
one more logic...........
su30mki.............jf17 enough
vikramaditya......jf17 enough
tejas...................jf17 enough
arjun...................jf17 enough
brahmos.............jf17 enough
but ye kyu bhool jaate hain k sirf 50 jf17 hain 500 nai
and vo b 3/4 gen hai 6th gen nai jo sabko uda denge

 

[GURU DUTT]

There is not thing TOT in this world. Don't live in fools world son. And you know it very well. Can give as many example you want...

well i know there is no such thing as "compleate TOT" and its just another glorified term for screwdriver job but still it gave indians a very good start and we are building on it so dont worry about us

 

[IceCold]

These versus threadsmy dick is bigger than yours when will we southasians ever come out of this mentality. India has more money so naturally they are going with the new advanced version of the plane. Pakistan on the other hand thinks its needs are met with P-3c Orions and does not need to invest more money just for the sake of it. Both are right in their respective choice and if Pakistan had more money, who knows we might too be replacing our Orions with P-8 but for now this is the luxury we cannot afford.

 

[danger007]

Couldnt be farther removed from reality.BY closing your eyes the problem will not vanish.Fact remains the P3 is an old platform on its last legs, that will be stretched to continue well into the future in absence of procurement of other advanced options. Your P3c are at best comparable with our upgraded IL38s with the Sea dragon package.You do not and will have anything in the coming decade to counter the P8I .And what air cover is there for the orions? half a century old Mirage iii/vs? JF-17??With that limited operating radius, we will draw you out to deep sea and voila! Turkey shoot for for our mig29ks. In less than a decade, our naval wing alone(mig29k+naval rafales) will overwhelm your air force. Deal with that.
Coming to your handful of F16s, those will have to contest first with its closets nemesis- the mirage 2000s. And just for fun, we will throw in some mig29smts.And we still have our flankers and rafales, And yes the lcas. Leaving out the FGFAs for now
If paf is so detrimental for us, that myth was blwon to smithereens in 99.It could have protected its men from being pounded by bombs on kargil heights, instead it was a no show- not because of cowardice. SImply because even thinking to fight against a superior force is a bad idea to begin with.

wow you get negative ratings for this? Great... Why are we discussing old platform with new... No body can deny... US will not replace it's orion fleet unless there is superior platform...

 

[gslv mk3]

, that's the reason Pakistan made so much progress in Nuclear technology as compared to India

What kind of Joke is this ?

 

[IND151]

Poseidon are leap ahead of orions... US is replacing orions with p8...

Exactly.....

 

[Basel]

Upgraded P-3C MPA and P-3B AEW models (equipped with Hawkeye 2000 AEW system) are too good
good for PN

When did PN get P-3B AEW??

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

Well if you have 2 swords one is single edge and other is double edge people forget that you can still fight and kill with single edge sword

hahaha
one more logic...........
su30mki.............jf17 enough
vikramaditya......jf17 enough
tejas...................jf17 enough
arjun...................jf17 enough
brahmos.............jf17 enough
but ye kyu bhool jaate hain k sirf 50 jf17 hain 500 nai
and vo b 3/4 gen hai 6th gen nai jo sabko uda denge

su30mki.............We have F16 C/D and BVR and plus JF17 Thunder with its own BVR 4 BLOCK 2 JF17 Thunder not forgeting our stock of 1 Million Stinger Missiles


vikramaditya......Newly imported Anti Aircraft carrier Killers even if you had 500 aircraft carriers same result
tejas...................K-8 armed
arjun...................Khalid 1 was already enough now we have Khalid 2
brahmos.............Have I mentioned our Air De-fences

 

[Alphacharlie]

Well if you have 2 swords one is single edge and other is double edge people forget that you can still fight and kill with single edge sword





su30mki.............We have F16 C/D and BVR and plus JF17 Thunder with its own BVR 4 BLOCK 2 JF17 Thunder not forgeting our stock of 1 Million Stinger Missiles


vikramaditya......Newly imported Anti Aircraft carrier Killers even if you had 500 aircraft carriers same result
tejas...................K-8 armed
arjun...................Khalid 1 was already enough now we have Khalid 2
brahmos.............Have I mentioned our Air De-fences

This is the Biggest BullShit Response I have come across.

 

[FNFAL]

wow you get negative ratings for this? Great... Why are we discussing old platform with new... No body can deny... US will not replace it's orion fleet unless there is superior platform...

Someone didn't like the bitter truth.
Crux of the matter is those who can afford will obviously get the latest and greatest.
Those who cant ,will sulk and behave erratically.

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

This is the Biggest BullShit Response I have come across.

Just stating the obvious just having large size planes do not mean you necessarily have a clean passage to win