What's new

Pakistan’s botched reaction after Sehwan carnage

imadul

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Dec 7, 2007
Messages
3,600
Reaction score
0
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Since Pakistan always takes action in reaction, and that could end in self damage because of lack of deep thinking and holistic approach, the opportunity to eliminate terror sanctuaries in Afghanistan after the “Sehwan Carnage” has been botched, even after paying a heavy price.

Enemy using terror as a strategic weapon to strangulate Pakistan economically, politically and internationally. So what has been Pakistan’s response?

1. Handing over a list to Afghanistan officials
2. Request to General John Nicholson to cooperate
3. Artillery fire in Pak-Afghanistan border areas

Going into any kind of negotiation at this time was a huge silly mistake. It gave Afghanistan puppet Govt the chance to attack Pakistan back diplomatically as they have backing and guidance from India. Now real issue of terrorism in Pakistan from TTP and its affiliates and from BLA and like outfits could go under some fog and Pakistan will be asked to go after Afghani Taliban and stop supporting Kashmir struggle or at least provide a quid pro quo.

General Raheel had also spoken in the past with General John Nicholson to bomb TTP hideouts. Some action was taken but now bigger troubles like Daesh have taken roots in Afghanistan.

Pakistan again lost the opportunity to go after terror sanctuaries in Afghanistan operated by RAW and NDS by just resorting to some artillery fire and closing Torkham Border.

A sustained strike from air could have eliminated the training centers which would have sent a strong signal to all that Pakistan is not a country at the level of Afghanistan and can take appropriate actions to defend its interests. After that Pakistan could have engaged Afghan Govt to resolve issues from a position of strength.
 
Strikes are sustained...
More.troops are moving in and border areas being vaccated... it will continue for a while... they will push them back deeper in afghanistan
 
Read about border areas vacated which means a long haul!
Is Pak going to make a buffer between Khyber-Mohmand agencies and nangarhar-kunar?
A ground invaion is a bad idea. It should only be air strikes. Lots is govt seemed scared of air strikes but bold actions are requied. Air strikes would have sent a loud political signal far and wide. Now all Afg based terrorists would haved run away and situation is becoming complex. Afganistan is a very dirty blanket to go under. All ground incusrions should be avoided except quick expeditionary types.
 
Ana should be treated same as ttp ... if they show up... which they may..

Aim should be to inflict damage and push the camps back 50 km... so making logistically difficult to cross border with ease... this may require random sudden strikes when ever they re populate the border areas

They shud keep anti tank missies handy for all the humvees ana has
 
Last edited:
I get the impression that ground forces will only secure the border rather than doing incursion. The majority of strikes will likely be artillery and helicopter strikes. Already Afghanistan reported over 200 rockets /missiles fired from Pakistan. I doubt all of those were mrl style artillery.
 
Instead of lightning strikes on terrorist camps Pak has closed borders which will create more resentments amongst afghans.
Pak wont be able to close borders for long. It will cease trade for both Pakistani and Afghan tribes.
Soon negotiation will start and Pak will have to open borders and attention will be diverted from action against afg terror groups to opening he borders.
Many people are just happy to close border. It is like FCR Law where collective punishments meted out for crime of one. India will exploit it later against Pakistan.

Ana should be treated same as ttp ... if they show up... which they may..

Aim should be to inflict damage and push the camps back 50 km... so making logistically difficult to cross border with ease... this may require random sudden strikes when ever they re populate the border areas

They shud keep anti tank missies handy for all the humvees ana has
You need to destroy terror camps not to push them back.
 

Back
Top Bottom