What's new

Pakistan: A slice of China in Islamabad

Clutch

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Aug 3, 2008
Messages
17,023
Reaction score
-3
Pakistan: A slice of China in Islamabad
03 SEPTEMBER 2017
Restaurants, guesthouses and supermarkets are opening to cater for the influx of Chinese fuelled by the CPEC.

77f4b81872254789ae44b97bc5e3e892_18.jpg

Islamabad's Firstop is one of the oldest Chinese specialty grocery stores In Pakistan, established two years ago to take advantage of the influx of Chinese migrants under CPEC [Asad Hashim/Al Jazeera]

by
Asad Hashim


Islamabad, Pakistan - Sitting in his open-air kitchen in the heart of a busy shopping centre in Pakistan's capital Islamabad, Zhang Yan Xu does not seem to have a care in the world.


The tall, broad-shouldered chef seems a genial sort, who exults in his inability to communicate with his customers.

"No English," he says, smiling broadly. "No Urdu."

Behind him, his wife looks up briefly from the chopping board, before getting back to the serious business of rolling and folding fresh dumplings for the customers downstairs.

The Xus work at Hong Du Ramen, the latest in a glut of Chinese restaurants, grocery stores, guesthouses and language centres to open up across Pakistan, aimed mainly at the country's growing population of Chinese citizens.

The influx has been fuelled by the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), a $56bn project that is seeing Chinese companies build roads, power plants and industrial zones across the South Asian country.

Two years after it was announced, CPEC's first "early harvest" infrastructure projects are now coming online, with work under way on dozens more.

87b078cd4bf04562a7774320df0bb88c_18.jpg

Zhang Yan Xu, the chef at Islamabad's Hong Du Ramen, works in an open air kitchen in a busy shopping plaza in Pakistan's capital, blissfully unable to communicate with most Pakistanis [Asad Hashim/Al Jazeera]

"This year is, as we call it, the year of early harvest," says Lijian Zhao, China's deputy ambassador to Pakistan. "The ultimate goal is to help Pakistan to develop the economy … to help to accelerate the industrialisation process."

The 43 projects that directly fall under the CPEC banner have seen a tripling of the number of Chinese nationals resident in Pakistan to more than 30,000, according to the Chinese embassy in Islamabad. In addition, Reuters reported, that more than 71,000 Chinese nationals visited on short-term visas last year.

As more Chinese engineers, managers and workers flood into the country, Pakistan has seen a mushrooming of supermarkets, guesthouses and other businesses catering specifically to Chinese needs.

Zhao, the Chinese deputy ambassador, says he's a regular visitor to the new Chinese grocery stores, stocking up on traditional ingredients that are just not available anywhere else in the South Asian country.

"I go for those markets. [Even the embassy] cannot bring everything from China," he says.

66960ab032b04381bbab16cbdcb99316_18.jpg

Chinese grocery stores appear to have no trouble importing pork products, whose production and import are illegal in Pakistan under Islamic injunctions [Asad Hashim/Al Jazeera]

'Arrived in Beijing'
The aptly named Firstop (a portmanteau of 'First Stop') is one of the largest such stores in Islamabad. The supermarket's shelves are lined with products manufactured in China: everything from noodles to hardhat construction helmets, sea kelp to stationery, spice mixes to industrial meat grinders.

As a Chinese migrant moving to Islamabad, whether you are looking for a quick meal or to procure the equipment and supplies to set up your own restaurant, it looks like Firstop has got you covered. Most of the demand, though, seems to be for food - both ready-made and ingredients - that are not available in typical Pakistani grocery stores, says Zhang Song, a store manager.

"Mostly the food and other seasonings are imported from China," says Song, in broken English. "Only [the cooking] oil is from Pakistan. Others all from China."

Song, a 29-year-old originally from He Bei province in China, says he moved to Pakistan two years ago to take advantage of the boom in businesses aimed at Chinese citizens.

"Most customers are Chinese people," he says.

048ac1e2a3574d4c9188289525866046_18.jpg

Chinese Ramen tends to be an acquired taste for many Pakistanis, but dumplings are always a favourite, say staff at Islamabad's Hong Du Ramen [Asad Hashim/Al Jazeera]

Pakistanis, he says, seem to be fond of making Chinese food, but the South Asian version of Chinese food - heavy on garlic, ginger and tomatoes - does not necessarily fit the bill of actual Chinese fare.

"[Traditional] Chinese food is too much different from Pakistani food," he says, smiling.

At the Ni Hao Cash & Carry, a few kilometres away, the scene is much the same. The small store is crammed with row upon row of products labelled in Chinese, with an array of spices arranged in open containers near the back wall.

"A lot of [Pakistanis] walk in and are shocked … they see everything in Chinese here, and wonder perhaps if they've arrived in Beijing," says Rizwan Hassan, a manager at the store.

Hassan and business partner Eraj Raza have been working with Chinese nationals on infrastructure projects for the last seven years, and set up this store about six months ago.

"We built the store because we saw CPEC, and all the companies coming in," says Raza. "Lots of investors are coming in. People are opening restaurants, guesthouses, or other services."

About 90 percent of their customers, says Raza, are Chinese, with the rest made up mostly of Koreans, Thais and other East Asian visitors. Ni Hao also operates another store in Karachi, Pakistan's largest city and commercial capital, as well as smaller outlets at more than half a dozen CPEC project sites.

The language barrier is a major stumbling block for many Chinese visitors, says Hassan. Most Chinese do not speak Urdu, Pakistan's native language, or English, which is spoken by a smaller subset of Pakistanis.
As such, he says, the Chinese seem to be setting up a parallel world in the South Asian country.

"Right now, there is a whole Chinese life here," says Hassan, who speaks broken Mandarin. "There are thousands of Chinese people in Islamabad, and they have everything they need to live comfortably. Now they even have clubs for them … everything is provided to them."


The Huashang Weekly, launched in early 2017, is Pakistan's first Chinese-language weekly and is aimed at Chinese migrants working on CPEC projects [Asad Hashim/Al Jazeera]

One of those things, somewhat surprisingly in the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, is pork. The import and consumption of pork, which is forbidden in Islam, is illegal in Pakistan.

On Ni Hao's shelves, however, you will find everything from pig snouts to trotters, from sausage to dried ham cuts.

Raza says customs officials at Pakistan's borders are not able to decipher the Chinese labels on most imported food products, and so Ni Hao is able to steer clear of trouble. But more than that, he says, if products are marked in Chinese, customs officials seem less inclined to check them.

"It's already happening, obviously. The products are coming in, so that means they are allowing it."
Pakistani customs officials denied to Al Jazeera that any such policy was in place.

CPEC creating a market
In addition to warping social norms, the $56bn CPEC, seems to be creating a market of its own, too.
"Pakistan will bid farewell to its energy shortage" exclaims the headline of a recent issue of the Huashang Weekly, Pakistan's first Chinese-language newspaper, which distributes 5,000 copies a week to major cities and CPEC project sites across Pakistan.

"It's meant to be like a bridge between Pakistan and China," says Inam ur Rahman, a manager at Infoshare, the company which runs the newspaper. "Chinese people who come here, they don't know much about Pakistan, whether in terms of business or even our culture."

Infoshare, a Shanghai-based company, has already launched a number of Chinese-focused ventures in Pakistan. The newspaper - a glossy tabloid that charges roughly $1,000 for a full page advertisement - is one, but they also run a Chinese-language courier service, and are launching a smartphone app that will allow Chinese-speakers to order food from Pakistani restaurants.

"I think a lot of companies are developing to take advantage of this Chinese influx," says Rehman. "Our company is doing the same."

Security concerns
Security remains a concern for most foreigners visiting Pakistan, which has been battling the Pakistan Taliban (known by the acronym, TTP) armed group and its allies since 2007. In June, the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL, known as ISIS) claimed to have killed a Chinese couple running a language training centre in the southwestern city of Quetta.

The killings prompted the Pakistani interior ministry to announce a tightening of visas for Chinese visitors, to ensure they were kept better track of. Pakistan has also formed a 15,000-strong security force specifically for the protection of Chinese citizens and CPEC projects.

"When some Chinese people are in Pakistan, it is a foreign country for them and they don't know very well [the situation]," says Zhao, the deputy ambassador, adding that the embassy had stepped up its security advisories to citizens in response to the attack.

Questions of security, however, seem far from Zhang Yan Xu's mind, as he and his wife prepare for the afternoon rush at Hong Du Ramen.

At the small hole-in-the-wall restaurant, waiter Ahsan Ibrar tends to the salads lying on the sideboard. Customers are expected to help themselves, he says. There are no frills and no fuss. No menu, either: the restaurant only serves its eponymous noodles. The few signs and the writing on the restaurant's whiteboard are all in Chinese.


"No one speaks English," exclaims Ibrar, who was hired as a cleaner but was quickly promoted to cashier and translator-in-chief (a fact only somewhat hampered by the fact that he does not speak Chinese).
It scarcely seems to matter, though. Business is booming, he says, and there is more than enough money to go around.

Source: Al Jazeera News
 
.
Well pork is Haraam in Islam.
Other than that,
It is good to see that Chinese are making good business in Pakistan
 
.
Im very critical of CPEC!

Chinese are even importing labourers from China... and now even Chinese owned stores..
What about locals? Only good for shyt jobs at such businesses?

The Gilgit Baltistanis are already dismayed... next is islambad, Balochistan (specifically gawadar) and other regions connecting CPEC.
 
.
Im very critical of CPEC!

Chinese are even importing labourers from China... and now even Chinese owned stores..
What about locals? Only good for shyt jobs at such businesses?

The Gilgit Baltistanis are already dismayed... next is islambad, Balochistan (specifically gawadar) and other regions connecting CPEC.
If hiring locals is more profitable, it will be stupid not to hire them. Chinese businessmen may have many prejudices, but they have no prejudice against money. More often than not, Chinese businessmen hire Chinese because it is more profitable in this way. They are more familiar with Chinese way of management, work harder or ask less. But once a business starts in a place, there is always benefit to the local, because trade is always a win-win transaction.

One example. When Taiwanese started investing in China, they also hired a lot from Taiwan for management. Eventually, Chinese learned management skills from them and soon they hire Chinese for management, too.
 
.
Im very critical of CPEC!

Chinese are even importing labourers from China... and now even Chinese owned stores..
What about locals? Only good for shyt jobs at such businesses?

The Gilgit Baltistanis are already dismayed... next is islambad, Balochistan (specifically gawadar) and other regions connecting CPEC.
Why are you critical of CPEC?

Pakistan is getting its fair share out of CPEC.
 
.
If hiring locals is more profitable, it will be stupid not to hire them. Chinese businessmen may have many prejudices, but they have no prejudice against money. More often than not, Chinese businessmen hire Chinese because it is more profitable in this way. They are more familiar with Chinese way of management, work harder or ask less. But once a business starts in a place, there is always benefit to the local, because trade is always a win-win transaction.

One example. When Taiwanese started investing in China, they also hired a lot from Taiwan for management. Eventually, Chinese learned management skills from them and soon they hire Chinese for management, too.
Im not blaming Chinese.. its the responsibility of Pak govt to look after the interests of the country.. which it is failing at!

For example, Chinese companies are for a fact screwing Pak by using loopholes in the system anywhere and everywhere possible..

Pak govt has given em facilities of tax free (zero duty) import of materials and machinery... apart from that chinese goods (cheap) are being dumped in market... all thanks to free trade agreements etc which are screwing Pak businesses.

Do you know, we even have Chinese individuals selling mobiles on roadside.. while a Pak citizen woukd get caught if he ever dared bring a few from abroad?

Pak China, trade imbalance is worrisome... we are importing a hundred times more than exporting!

While FTA & other agreements are effectively ruining local businesses which cant compete with chinese goods... due to various factors..
 
.
The first thing that struck me was the safety of these chinese..Its like walking on a thin rope that is tied between two twenty storeyed buildings..hope everything goes well and they return back to their homes alive.
 
.
Why are you critical of CPEC?

Pakistan is getting its fair share out of CPEC.
In Sandaq and Riko Diq mines.. they are drilling for silver and getting gold as a byproduct.. all at cheap *** rates.. and much more.

Also, do you know Chinese companies are using inmates on projects at cheap costs? Our folk arent even getting labourers jobs.

CPEC if not managed by GoP will become a Chinese exclusive zone than an economic one.

Now even chinese only hotels are being built!

Chinese stores illegally importing pork would look stupid in comparison.
 
.
Im not blaming Chinese.. its the responsibility of Pak govt to look after the interests of the country.. which it is failing at!

For example, Chinese companies are for a fact screwing Pak by using loopholes in the system anywhere and everywhere possible..

Pak govt has given em facilities of tax free (zero duty) import of materials and machinery... apart from that chinese goods (cheap) are being dumped in market... all thanks to free trade agreements etc which are screwing Pak businesses.

Do you know, we even have Chinese individuals selling mobiles on roadside.. while a Pak citizen woukd get caught if he ever dared bring a few from abroad?

Pak China, trade imbalance is worrisome... we are importing a hundred times more than exporting!

While FTA & other agreements are effectively ruining local businesses which cant compete with chinese goods... due to various factors..
Actually, the best a government can do is to leave the capital alone as much as possible. Let it run its own course. Very often, a government chooses to "look after" the interest of its people, which ends up preventing its people to acquire more opportunities and more wealth. Americans are a good example. Many of its people, especially those low skilled ones, have an entitlement attitude towards work, which makes them less desirable to businesses.

The only reason why Western countries are richer is because they have more capital per capita, both human capital and material capital as the means of production. When a government can guarantee security to its people, the people naturally will develop their human capital. Then the only thing left to do is attract external capital, at least don't do anything to drive it away. In this case, the wise way is not to be "smart" in social engineering.
 
. .
Im not blaming Chinese.. its the responsibility of Pak govt to look after the interests of the country.. which it is failing at!

For example, Chinese companies are for a fact screwing Pak by using loopholes in the system anywhere and everywhere possible..

Pak govt has given em facilities of tax free (zero duty) import of materials and machinery... apart from that chinese goods (cheap) are being dumped in market... all thanks to free trade agreements etc which are screwing Pak businesses.

Do you know, we even have Chinese individuals selling mobiles on roadside.. while a Pak citizen woukd get caught if he ever dared bring a few from abroad?

Pak China, trade imbalance is worrisome... we are importing a hundred times more than exporting!

While FTA & other agreements are effectively ruining local businesses which cant compete with chinese goods... due to various factors..
In addition, dumping isn't bad at all. If a country wants to sell you products below cost, they are losing money and you get more. There hasn't been a successful case of earning a fortune by selling below cost first. It is only possible when government steps in to help maintain a monopoly position, otherwise, the moment they raise price for more profit, the battle-harden competitors will kill them.

Language is huge barrier as Chinese in general don't speak english. And neither Pakistani labour class.
it is not without a solution. Chinese have been doing business in Africa for a long time. Language is even a bigger barrier there.
 
.
Im very critical of CPEC!

Chinese are even importing labourers from China... and now even Chinese owned stores..
What about locals? Only good for shyt jobs at such businesses?

The Gilgit Baltistanis are already dismayed... next is islambad, Balochistan (specifically gawadar) and other regions connecting CPEC.

This is exageration

"According to the data of Planning Commission, around 8000 Chinese are working on these projects. Average strength of Chinese workers never crossed the figure of 25 % of the total employees."
https://www.app.com.pk/cpec-projects-create-over-30000-jobs-officials/


This is when not even single economic zone is developed in Pakistan. First economic zone in Gwadar will be completed this year or next. As far as China only hotel, I doubt it even if Pakistani gov allow. People will be up in arms and such adventure will never go anywhere. Remember what happened to restaurant exclusively for foreigners in Islamabad?
 
.
One example. When Taiwanese started investing in China, they also hired a lot from Taiwan for management. Eventually, Chinese learned management skills from them and soon they hire Chinese for management, too.

A lot of countries mandate that any project being done by a foreign company needs to have a domestic partner at X% of the labor force.

Pakistan itself is filled with an educated workforce that doesn't have the experience due to deficiencies of capital to fund projects. MBAs, Engineers, Comp Sci. Some degrees are from diploma mills but even the best from NUST/LUMS/Dow/UP face uncertainty as a basis leave towards the West.

The issue is how soon can Pakistanis take over vs fears of an indentured servitude.
 
.
Well pork is Haraam in Islam.
Other than that,
It is good to see that Chinese are making good business in Pakistan

Nobody is shoving it it any Muslims mouth...

That isn't the point of the article..
 
.
Im very critical of CPEC!

Chinese are even importing labourers from China... and now even Chinese owned stores..
What about locals? Only good for shyt jobs at such businesses?

The Gilgit Baltistanis are already dismayed... next is islambad, Balochistan (specifically gawadar) and other regions connecting CPEC.

Told you so.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom