Opinion: Taiwan should become an independent country recognized by mainland China

[Yongpeng Sun-Tastaufen]

Taiwan island is historically not part of China. In Ming dynasty, Chinese did not inhabit Taiwan island. The place was inhabited by aboriginals. It wasn't until Manchus conquered China that Ming remnants took Taiwan island from Dutch and escaped there. IMO, Taiwan could become another Han country. But, before that happen, Taiwan must give Kinmen to mainland China because these islands are closer to mainland China than to Taiwan island.

Ming dynasty - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Kinmen - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

@White and Green with M/S @mike2000 is back @nahtanbob @aziqbal @Mohsin A @KAL-EL @khansaheeb @Ich @Abdul Rehman Majeed @zectech

 

[ThunderCat]

In that case every country should give independence to separatists in each region.

 

[S10]

Your opinion is wrong.

 

[casual]

it's the opinion of 1.4 billion Chinese that Taiwan must return to China's rule. If it takes war with Taiwan and the US, so be it.

 

[S10]

it's the opinion of 1.4 billion Chinese that Taiwan must return to China's rule. If it takes war with Taiwan and the US, so be it.

Actually I'm fine with "Taiwanese" having their own country by carving out a piece of land in US. If they want to take a Chinese province, they can eat shit.

 

[Rusty2]

In that case every country should give independence to separatists in each region.

How do you separate from something you were never a part of?
It's like saying Azad Kashmir wants to separate from India.

it's the opinion of 1.4 billion Chinese that Taiwan must return to China's rule. If it takes war with Taiwan and the US, so be it.

lol
Any ways, your glorious leader has seen the affect Russian invasion of Ukraine has had on Russia. Pooh won't be seriously beating war drums for a while.

 

[casual]

People should not think China will give up on Taiwan. It is unrealistic. The Chinese people would overthrow the CCP if it dared to allow Taiwan to become independent. Instead, it's more productive to figure out how to negotiate for more autonomy in exchange for peaceful transition to Chinese rule.

How do you separate from something you were never a part of?
It's like saying Azad Kashmir wants to separate from India.


lol
Any ways, your glorious leader has seen the affect Russian invasion of Ukraine has had on Russia. Pooh won't be seriously beating war drums for a while.

It's not up to Xi or the CCP, they would be overthrown if they dared to allow Taiwan become independant.

 

[ThunderCat]

How do you separate from something you were never a part of?
It's like saying Azad Kashmir wants to separate from India.

It would be the same for many countries. I could state the same for Balochistan in Pakistan. It is what it is.

 

[beijingwalker]

Percentage of ethnic Han Chinese population
Taiwan : 98%
Hong kong : 92%
Mainland China : 91.59％
Singapore : 74.3%

 

[Yongpeng Sun-Tastaufen]

Percentage of ethnic Han Chinese population
Taiwan : 98%
Hong kong : 92%
Mainland China : 91.59％
Singapore : 74.3%

So? Austria and Luxemburg speak German.

 

[Rusty2]

It would be the same for many countries. I could state the same for Balochistan in Pakistan. It is what it is.

Baluchistan is physically part of Pakistan. Pakistan state has writ over it.
Taiwan is never in human history been part of the CCP and the CCP has never in human history had its writ over it.
So once again, how do you sperate from something you are not a part of?

 

[etylo]

A you a fool of Chinese descent to even propose such stupid idea as in many cases in your posts ？Are you a fk Indian in disguise try to discredit Chinese ?

 

[beijingwalker]

Baluchistan is physically part of Pakistan. Pakistan state has writ over it.
Taiwan is never in human history been part of the CCP and the CCP has never in human history had its writ over it.
So once again, how do you sperate from something you are not a part of?

Mainland China is not always CCP , why are you always so obsessed with CCP, China is countries with thousands of years history.

 

[Rusty2]

Mainland China is not always CCP , why are you always so obsessed with CCP, China is countries with thousands of years history.

Did I say anything that was factually incorrect?
(You will never answer this question with a straight answer)

 

[beijingwalker]

Did I say anything that was factually incorrect?
(You will never answer this question with a straight answer)

Did anyone mention CCP before you in this thread?