No Indian writer to take part in Int'l Urdu Conference in Pakistan

[Deadpool]

No harm as Indians can't speak or write Urdu. Urdu only belongs to Pakistanis.

Urdu is majorly derived from Hindi itself.

I wonder what makes you say Indians cannot speak a language that is made in India and has its rooting in other Indian language.

Isn't it the other way? Hindi from Urdu?
Urdu was once known as Hindi/Hindvi (among other names), but current Indian Hindi is derived from Urdu and heavily Sanskritized.

No.
Urdu is derived from Hindi.

 

[Mamluk]

No.
Urdu is derived from Hindi.

No it's not.

Urdu has 800 years of history. Indian Hindi is a new language - an attempt to go back to Sanskrit.

An analogy would be "Old-Germanizing" English and getting rid of all French and non-German influences from it - that would be a new language in its own right.

If Hindi is not new, name one Hindi poet from past! You can't, because there wasn't any.

 

[Deadpool]

No it's not.

Simply parroting a line does not mean anything.

Go through the history of the language. Urdu is majorly a mix of Hindi, Sanskrit and Prakrit.

 

[Mamluk]

Simply parroting a line does not mean anything.

You didn't read the quoted message below that, low IQ.

Ok, if Urdu came from Hindi - then Hindi must be an older language.

You sound like you read more history than me - so name a Hindi poet from the past, at least 1!!

 

[Deadpool]

You didn't read the quoted message, low IQ.

Ok, if Urdu came from Hindi - then Hindi must be an older language.

You sound like you read more history than me - so name a Hindi poet from the past, at least 1!!

Hindi itself is derived from Sanskrit and Prakrit.
Read about how old these two languages are. Urdu uses a heavy mix of the two.

 

[Mamluk]

Hindi itself is derived from Sanskrit and Prakrit.

I knew you couldn't name a single one.

Your argument is Hindi existed before Urdu, which is 800 years old.

How come no famous poet for a language that's older than a 800 year old language? lol.

 

[Sliver]

still i dont get it can pls simplified it for me.
how is it 99% from sanskrit.
pls do use easy language
thanks

please read the link I gave you. its from dawn.com
http://www.dawn.com/news/681263/urdus-origin-its-not-a-camp-language

 

[satvikAcer]

As someone said,nobody speaks urdu in india.pakistan can take care of it.

 

[Hindustani78]

http://saudigazette.com.sa/saudi-ar...ucation-day-poetry-gathering-speech-contests/
Dec 1, 2016
JEDDAH — The Urdu Academy Jeddah organized its 16th annual literary program to promote Urdu language and to mark India’s National Education Day, celebrated every year in the memory of the India’s first education minister, at the Indian Consulate here recently.

Many eminent personalities from the Indian community along with students from various schools attended the event.

Consul General Noor Rehman Shiek was the chief guest at the program while Deputy Consul General Shahad Alam and Zia Nadwi, director DPS International School, were the guests of honor.

 

[CorporateAffairs]

Actually it is an Indian language..

Nope, Sanskrit is the mother of all languages.

It is the national language and lingua franca of Pakistan, and an official language of six states of India. It is also one of the 22 official languages recognized in the Constitution of India.

Constitution of India when formed said India is a HINDU state, so stop quoting the constitutions.

 

[darksider]

please read the link I gave you. its from dawn.com
http://www.dawn.com/news/681263/urdus-origin-its-not-a-camp-language

You claim it but you cannot prove it your self or you just write it here because you saw written some where else and it suits you.
Mate when make claims then you should have skills to verify it.
I still want understand it how is it 99% Sanskrit. Dont give links just write here.
Just write here in simplified way.
Thanks

 

[satvikAcer]

Urdu has nothing to do with sanskrit,it is the language of Central Asians of Turks,Persians,arabs and a mix of all this. It happened to be spoken by mughals and other nawabs whose descendants now live in pakistan,so it is a pakistani language. Pakistan has to and does take care of it very well.

 

[PlugnPlay]

Urdu has nothing to do with sanskrit,it is the language of Central Asians of Turks,Persians,arabs and a mix of all this. It happened to be spoken by mughals and other nawabs whose descendants now live in pakistan,so it is a pakistani language. Pakistan has to and does take care of it very well.

Urdu was born when the Invaders used arabic script to write the local lingo and taught that script in the local schools.

Till 1947 the arabic script and persian was taught in schools all over India. That is how urdu was born.

 

[Sliver]

You claim it but you cannot prove it your self or you just write it here because you saw written some where else and it suits you.
Mate when make claims then you should have skills to verify it.
I still want understand it how is it 99% Sanskrit. Dont give links just write here.
Just write here in simplified way.
Thanks

according to the dawn's report, 99% of the "verbs" are derived from sanskrit. please read the report - I am only learning about the language after I saw the thread here and doing some research. Please dispute and enlighten the people here with your opposition. It will add to the knowledge to everyone here.

what are some basic verbs in urdu? can you give me the verbs for:
eat
blood
water
mother
father

thanks

 

[PlugnPlay]

according to the dawn's report, 99% of the "verbs" are derived from sanskrit. please read the report - I am only learning about the language after I saw the thread here and doing some research. Please dispute and enlighten the people here with your opposition. It will add to the knowledge to everyone here.

what are some basic verbs in urdu? can you give me the verbs for:
eat
blood
water
mother
father

thanks

Eat in Urdu is "Khana", in Sanskirt is "Khana"

Blood in urdu is "Khoon", in Sanskrit is "Balate" (english Blood comes from this sanskrit root), Persian is "xun" (similar to urdu)

Water in urdu is "Pani", in sanskrit is "Paniy"

Mother in urdu is "Maa", in sanskrit its "Maatr"

Father in urdu is "Walid or Abba", in Sanskrit its "Pitr", in Persian its "Pedr" (it has Sanskrit root) (english Father also has sanskrit root), Father in Arabic is "Abb" or abba.