National Anthem 'Sacrilege' for Kolkata Madrasa

[ranjeet]

and what seems to be the problem with my post??

Ask the one who is palm facing your post.

 

[bongbang]

Its okay West Bengalis can start singing Amar Sonar Bangla in their own language in Tagore's real tune lyrics. Or they are interested to be blessed in the sacred land.

 

[Gibbs]

Welcome to the shitty politics in India
Except NDA all others will try maximum for votebank politics .Especially Mamata Banerjee and TC in WB.

I'm afraid thats common in any multi party electorate, Especially at ground level in developing world.. But there should be national policies on sovereignty of a nation, This seems to be a criminal case as well with threats of bodily harm to a Indian citizen.. Why can't the police take action against the perpetrators ?

 

[SrNair]

meanwhile in the rss shakhas, india's national flag is not raised[1]...

why were they arrested by nagpur police in the first place?? is nagpur police the local state side of rss??





okay, that differs a just a little bit from this[2] article from 2014...

so rss only raised the national flag at its national headquarters in nagpur in 2014 only after the precedent of those three activists forcibly raising it at a rss office in 2001 in nagpur itself, yet rss and other groups of the sangh ( old and new ) created the "idgah maidan controvery" ( coercion and riots really ) in hubli city in karnataka in 1994 when they forcibly wanted to raise the national flag in the central idgah ( muslim festival prayer structure and ground ) there... this was just the sangh's attempt to put fear into muslims soon after the babri masjid demolition and the subsequent rampage of the sangh throughout india... here[3] are some details of the hubli incidents and here[4] is the statement on that issue by noted writer, playwright, film actor and director, girish karnad, who belongs to that region.


offences?? when that muslim/otherwise group in the bombay cinema hall chose not to stand for the national anthem, sanghi goons in the cinema hall and their vile nationalist supporters there almost lynched that group yet here is the sangh's primary group, rss, getting the nagpur police to arrest three activists who raised the national flag at rss headquarters where it had been raised only twice.

now i, a socialist, am not the one to quibble about someone not standing for india's current national anthem or not saluting india's current flag but surely when rss accuses others being "anti national" ( whatever that means ), some technical points can be raised against rss too.


-----

[1] Activists, who forcibly hoisted tri-colour at RSS premises, freed - Firstpost

[2] Tri-colour hoisted at RSS HQ after 52 yrs | Kractivism

[3] The Idgah Controversy

[4] SAHMAT Statement on The Idgah Maidan controversy in Karnataka

RSS is not a govt funded organisation .It is self financed cultural organisation .
You cant raise tricolour flag for a private organization.It is a crime .
RSS is just one small part of a big India.


But this Madrasa is a govt funded school

 

[jamahir]

Welcome to the shitty politics in India
Except NDA all others will try maximum for votebank politics .Especially Mamata Banerjee and TC in WB.

yellow yellow dirty phellow.

bjp ( within the nda alliance ) is the biggest vote bank party in india.

Ask the one who is palm facing your post.

sometimes your posts have such deep meanings of which i am yet to attain mastery.

 

[SrNair]

I'm afraid thats common in any multi party electorate, Especially at ground level in developing world.. But there should be national policies on sovereignty of a nation, This seems to be a criminal case as well with threats of bodily harm to a Indian citizen.. Why can't the police take action against the perpetrators ?

First of all Mamta Banerjee silently support those extremists especially for her own political benefit .She cant provoke them .It will danger her political future .Indian politics is a dirty stuff with zero morality.
Akhtar is just a modern Indian and he is alone, but conservatives is a majority .Majority is always matters for political parties .Hindu organisation cant support him it will flame communal tension .

What I want to see is those writers who returned all those awards because of 'intolerance ',including half bengali Arundathi Roy .Of Course they wont ,all of them are just shouts for fame thats all.

Even in our so called highly HDI Kerala ,situation is not that different .

yellow yellow dirty phellow.

bjp ( within the nda alliance ) is the biggest vote bank party in india.



sometimes your posts have such deep meanings of which i am yet to attain mastery.

Gaddafi is already dead .So your opinion dont have any worthiness

 

[Brahmaputra Mail]

First commies destroyed Poschim Banga, and now Didi and her goons will destroy Poschim Banga. West Bengal needs to be painted gerua now,else there will be irreversible change.

 

[ranjeet]

yellow yellow dirty phellow.

bjp ( within the nda alliance ) is the biggest vote bank party in india.



sometimes your posts have such deep meanings of which i am yet to attain mastery.

I am glad you take my jibes in a friendly manner. I have no ill intentions but it's fun to indulge at times

First commies destroyed Poschim Banga, and now Didi and her goons will destroy Poschim Banga. West Bengal needs to be painted gerua now,else there will be irreversible change.

Well instead of gerua ... secular dhimmis would prefer guevara !!!

 

[TejasMk3]

Yeah performance of Modi sarkar has been disappointing on this regard.

Thats kinda the sad part, if you think about it, congis actually deliver promises to their votebanks, either be it xtians or muslims, BJP on the other hand is actually too scared to deliver at times even what is right, forget about core votebank issues.

 

[ranjeet]

Thats kinda the sad part, if you think about it, congis actually deliver promises to their votebanks, either be it xtians or muslims, BJP on the other hand is actually too scared to deliver at times even what is right, forget about core votebank issues.

In politics no party delivers to their core constituency, once what was promised is delivered constituency moves to another demand.

 

[LaBong]

@LaBong claimed this in the other thread .. I think he will stick to his stand.

Off course I will, jamat needs to be shown its place. Bangladesh dealing with Jamat in a far better way than what Mamata is doing.

He agreed yesterday here Secular West Bengal on fire again | Page 6 that its quite deep

Dude people like you voted for Mamata, now enjoy the spectacle. For all their vices commies would never have formed an alliance with Jamat for votebank.

LOL. That is no stand. That's a surrender. So typically secular. They have courage against Hindus. But against Mullahs...

Sorry, but our current Govt. is also behaving in a similar way wrt to Islamism. Better than the previous one, but not what's required.

Lol what's with all teenager like passive aggressiveness? if you want to say something to me quote me directly.

Yes I know you are internet tough guy but for all the 56 inch you have, that can only be used against harmless writers, social activists or to make a pack and lynch an innocent person.

 

[surya kiran]

There is a solution to this. And it is called, the Uniform Civil Code. Implement it. And if people do not agree. Impose it. Anybody does not agree, either disagrees and stays or gives up his citizenship and leaves. Enough of this nonsense.

As for the present scenario @Gibbs as per the Constitution of India respect for the national symbols, of which the National Anthem is one, is a Fundamental duty of every Indian. But, this is not enforceable in law. Now, if a citizen does not wish to sing the Anthem he or she is welcome to not do so. This can be seen as an act of dissent against a particular cause or can be seen as a requirement of their religion to not do so.

But, if a person stops somebody else from doing so, that is a serious violation of that person's right. You cannot force another person to follow your line of thought.

 

[MilSpec]

Welcome to the shitty politics in India
Except NDA all others will try maximum for votebank politics .Especially Mamata Banerjee and TC in WB.

You know that is not true wrt NDA, hamaam me sab nange hai.

 

[Gibbs]

There is a solution to this. And it is called, the Uniform Civil Code. Implement it. And if people do not agree. Impose it. Anybody does not agree, either disagrees and stays or gives up his citizenship and leaves. Enough of this nonsense.

Exactly

 

[Grevion]

And that is happening in the land of Rabindranath Tagore.
What can you expect from didi's govt. Seems like she is ready to give up Tagore's legacy in exchange for a few more secular votes.