What's new

Narenda Modi at centre of storm over university project

Yo don't need to write him anything - If he desires he would do so - as simple as that.
Still, a reminder helps. Kalam is a brilliant choice, but the man is a gentleman and Nalanda is a political project. Cronies were allocated to the board. Naturally Kalam did not fit in. But now things have been reversed.

How about that other guy who is as big as Sen and shares a pretty equal (often critical) professional relationship with him.

Bhagwati? He's pretty impressive, though I doubt we can lure him back fulltime.
Ashin Wirathu.

If a Britisher can be made the Chief, pretty sure one from the subcontinent will be a better one.
 
.
He is not a world renowned economist. His claim to fame was his Nobel prize. But then even Yasser Arafat and Barack Obama got that. And Gandhi did not. Plus, I have read his papers on the 1943 famine in India. It is best to keep him as far away as possible. Batting for or against Modi is not my concern.

Great..Both Obama and Arafat got it for peace, not for economics..You cant compare both..Anyway, lets see how nalanda turn out to be... For me, it was just a waste we cannot use Indias best minds in that university..
 
.
Why? Just bcoz he criticize Modi? Dont paint everyone as anti nationals just because they do not like Modi.. Its a dangerous situation we are goibg into.. He is a world renown economists.. We should use his expertise..

I do not consider him as anti-national..just plain stupid..Modi has appointed people in his govt who are opposed to his economic policies but here, from what i gather, Amartya Sen has a personal dislike of Modi..and made political comments in order to hurt Modi..why should the govt support a person who has no qualms of using an academic position to make political plays?
 
.
PS: look at the colleges he worked mate..It tells you something..
 
.
Great..Both Obama and Arafat got it for peace, not for economics..You cant compare both..Anyway, lets see how nalanda turn out to be... For me, it was just a waste we cannot use Indias best minds in that university..
Exactly, while both made a mockery of 'peace'. The Nobel prize is a joke. A bad one at that. Take that away, and he is just another jhollawallah British economist.
 
.
I do not consider him as anti-national..just plain stupid..Modi has appointed people in his govt who are opposed to his economic policies but here, from what i gather, Amartya Sen has a personal dislike of Modi..and made political comments in order to hurt Modi..why should the govt support a person who has no qualms of using an academic position to make political plays?


So now from on those who says good things about Modi should be allowed to work in that university? Then why dont guys sigb a petition asking Modi to ban Bengalis and Keralites from attending that college?

Exactly, while both made a mockery of 'peace'. The Nobel prize is a joke. A bad one at that. Take that away, and he is just another jhollawallah British economist.

But his eligibility is not counted by his Nobel only..Look at the colleges he worked..It speaks something..
 
.
ban Bengalis and Keralites from attending that college
Where is this coming from? :azn:

I vote for Ashin Wirathu. Or @Tshering22.

Look at the colleges he worked
All British left wing colleges - check it once. True - it does say something. I would rather have an Indian for the top post of an Indian university. At least a man/woman/etc from the Indian subcontinent.
 
. .
Sure, it will give him a stable platform to spread his hatred against Muslims..
Naaah, he will be busy with administrative duties.

In his spare time, of course - he will try to prevent a repeat of 1193 burning down of Nalanda.

As a Buddhist, he/someone similar should be given a choice. They don't ask for a Buddhist for the Aligarh Muslim University. The Buddhists are also human beings.
 
.
Where is this coming from? :azn:

As far as many concerned here we both are the traitors for not supporting Modi..


All British left wing colleges - check it once. True - it does say something. I would rather have an Indian for the top post of an Indian university. At least a man/woman/etc from the Indian subcontinent
.


All those colleges have good reputation and if you want Nalanda to be a 3rd rate college, then Modi govt can appoint Swamy Adityanath for I care..

Naaah, he will be busy with administrative duties.

In his spare time, of course - he will try to prevent a repeat of 1193 burning down of Nalanda.

As a Buddhist, he/someone similar should be given a choice. They don't ask for a Buddhist for the Aligarh Muslim University. The Buddhists are also human beings.

So the only criteria for being a VC in Nalanda University is that he has to be a human being?
 
.
As far as many concerned here we both are the traitors for not supporting Modi..


.


All those colleges have good reputation and if you want Nalanda to be a 3rd rate college, then Modi govt can appoint Swamy Adityanath for I care..
Modi is a non issue. Modi will stay for 5, may be 10 years. Nalanda will stay. Swamy Adityanath is unsuitable, I doubt he is well versed with the Buddhist heritage. Some Buddhist scholar like Ashin Wirathu suits the post.

only criteria for being a VC in Nalanda University is that he has to be a human being?
Being a human being is very important, I assure you. It will be a scandal if non humans are made the Chancellor etc.

All those colleges have good reputation
Trust me, even bin Laden industries (they are conglomerate) have a very very good reputation. Among their people.
 
.
In letter to Krishna, Kalam slams Amartya Sen - Rediff.com India News


Former President APJ Abdul Kalam's letter, which he sent to Foreign Minister S M Krishna in July last year, has now come into public domain, slamming Nobel Laureate economist Amartya Sen for forcing him out of his brainchild project of the Nalanda University in Bihar as its first visitor.

He chose not to create a public controversy even while writing to Krishna, that he was upset the way the project was being handled and hence he couldn't remain associated with it any longer.

He wrote how sad he was at everything going wrong in his dream of reviving a great seat of learning in the Buddhist philosophy and statecraft, as perhaps the first residential international educational institution from 5th to 12th century off Patna, is besmirched with controversies even before it starts any academic courses.

The paragraph reads, "Having been involved in various academic and administrative proceedings of the Nalanda University since August 2007, I believe that the candidates to be selected/appointed to the post of chancellor and vice chancellor should be of extraordinary intellect with academic and management expertise."

"Both the chancellor and vice chancellor have to personally involve themselves full-time in Bihar, so that a robust and strong international institution is built," it read.

The ministry of external affairs had taken over the project as an international university, involving 16 ASEAN countries such as China, Japan, Australia, Korea and Thailand, even while Kalam kept insisting that it should better be handled by the human resources development ministry, which has experience in the education field.

The government tried to suppress Kalam's damning letter as it was taken on record in the meeting of the governing board of the university, but was not made public until a Patna journalist wrote to him to get the truth out.

Kalam felt frustrated with the people at helm of affairs and his resignation was a rebuff to Sen and his protégé Dr Gopa Sabharwal, 'smuggled' in as the vice chancellor-designate without his knowledge.

Being chairman of the governing board, Sen's position is equivalent to chancellor (the university officially has no one as yet).

Having been at Oxford, Cambridge and Harvard, Sen viewed Nalanda University through that prism, while Dr Kalam felt sad at finding no efforts to re-enact the glory of ancient Nalanda University in which students from all over East Asia came for studies and had Pandits such as Arya Dev, Silabhadra, Dharmapala, Santarakshita and Chandragomin who spent their lives for the sake of the institution.

The academics say the fault lies in the government for entrusting the task of reviving to Nalanda University to Sen as a testimony of India's obsequiousness, despite Kalam repeatedly warning them against it.

Kalam's letter is also an indictment of Sabharwal, who was just a sociology reader from Lady Sri Ram College, Delhi, who was made the rector/vice chancellor-designate despite academics' protest that she had nothing to do with the Buddhist studies for which the university is to be set up, and was running it from Delhi.

Another one.............
Amartya Sen threatens to quit Nalanda univ over funds queries | The Indian Express
 
Last edited:
.
You are an open critic of PM and do not Hesitate to level serious charges against him maligning countries Impression. How can you expect reappointment? After all we do not want communist anywhere on top position to degrade those positions. let mr sen take a rest. We have many Indians much better than him to head this position.
 
Last edited:
. .
So now from on those who says good things about Modi should be allowed to work in that university? Then why dont guys sigb a petition asking Modi to ban Bengalis and Keralites from attending that college?

why does he need to say anything? especially when hot political battles were going on.

The best thing he could have said was I hope whoever becomes PM does this that etc...
Instead he tried to prove his loyalty to Manmohan Singh and made personal comments on Modi..well..there is a reason why govt employees are not supposed to campaign for the govt during the elections, though they can vote for any1..now u may argue, he is not a govt employee but the position is with support of the central govt..

P.S: I am a bengali too. Not all bengalis dislike Modi. many like me want him and my country to succeed..
 
.
Back
Top Bottom