Muslims must learn to respect Hindu sentiments: Ashok Singhal

[Jobless Jack]

We don't want your Arab culture in India, if you want to slaughter cows than go to Saudi Arabia or other Arab wannabe countries like Pakistan.

your reply shows your ignorance. slaughtering cow is part of our religion not culture. and secondly dont you indians constantly scream to the world how your country is a place for all religion ? comments like yours show otherwise

 

[MauryaWarrior]

your reply shows your ignorance. slaughtering cow is part of our religion not culture. and secondly dont you indians constantly scream to the world how your country is a place for all religion ? comments like yours show otherwise

If slaughtering cows is part of your religion then you don't belong in India.

 

[Biplab Bijay]

your reply shows your ignorance. slaughtering cow is part of our religion not culture. and secondly dont you indians constantly scream to the world how your country is a place for all religion ? comments like yours show otherwise

Its not mandatory in your religion. Dont lie.

 

[Jobless Jack]

It is saying like we can insult your religious symbols as much as we can( by making cartoons, videos, films etc).Its not like hindu houses and force them to watch. If you guys can not stand it, close your eyes or dont look at it. Is not it ?


umm can you tidy up and properly tell me what you are trying to say before i reply . apologies. i just dont understand what you trying to say

Its not mandatory in your religion. Dont lie.

kurbani is mandatory. in the subcontinent the easiest aavailable animal to sacrifice is the cow. as sheep and camel are rarely found (though still used for kurbani ) .

 

[Chronos]

If slaughtering cows is part of your religion then you don't belong in India.

Not this discussion again.

once this came up, there was ramayana of a discussion thread on it.

 

[Biplab Bijay]

kurbani is mandatory. in the subcontinent the easiest aavailable animal to sacrifice is the cow. as sheep and camel are rarely found (though still used for kurbani ) .

Ok let me say again .

You said :we will slaughter as many cows as we want. its not like muslims go around hindu houses force feeding them beef .if you guys cant stand it look the other way or close your eyes simple.




I replied : It is like saying we can insult your religious symbols as much as we can( by making cartoons, videos, films etc).Its not like hindus go around muslim houses and force them to watch. If you guys can not stand it, close your eyes or dont look at it. Is not it ?


And again dont lie. Sheeps are available. And also cheaper than cows. And for your religious rituals you can not spend a little money but you can offend other religions ?

 

[Irfan Baloch]

The 88-year-old went on to add: “Muslims will be treated as common citizens -- nothing more, nothing less. And, they must learn to respect Hindu sentiments. If they keep opposing Hindus, how long can they survive?”

what a selfish git that guy is?
I feel like putting jihad on his fat ***

Muslims need to respect other Muslims first
and then they need to respect all human beings and Hindus as well
?
what?

why did I mentioned Hindus separately from Human Beings?


well think.
maybe same reason as I didnt use the prefix "other" before the word Human beings when mentioning Muslims..


what?

are you implying Muslims and Hindus not human beings?


well

I leave the judgement with you.. whatever i implied

but while you are at it.. do think about my third sentence underlined

 

[Biplab Bijay]

what a selfish git that guy is?
I feel like putting jihad on his fat ***

Muslims need to respect other Muslims first
and then they need to respect all human beings and Hindus as well
?
what?

why did I mentioned Hindus separately from Human Beings?


well think.
maybe same reason as I didnt use the prefix "other" before the word Human beings when mentioning Muslims..


what?

are you implying Muslims and Hindus not human beings?


well

I leave the judgement with you.. whatever i implied

but while you are at it.. do think about my third sentence underlined

Ha ha ha ha. My god. You have a very good writing skill, just like Nadeem F. Pracha, Anwar Iqbal.

 

[Jobless Jack]

Ok let me say again .

You said :we will slaughter as many cows as we want. its not like muslims go around hindu houses force feeding them beef .if you guys cant stand it look the other way or close your eyes simple.




I replied : It is like saying we can insult your religious symbols as much as we can( by making cartoons, videos, films etc).Its not like hindus go around muslim houses and force them to watch. If you guys can not stand it, close your eyes or dont look at it. Is not it ?


And again dont lie. Sheeps are available. And also cheaper than cows. And for your religious rituals you can not spend a little money but you can offend other religions ?

the context is defferent . we slaughter cow because a) we like beef b) cows are more accesible ( sheeps are available yes but not everywhere. and also its becomeing tradition as sacrificing cows as they aree expensive is a symbol of wealth ?( not sure) .) anyway we kill cows because it collides with our religious obligation. ) on the other hand if you guys make an insulting cartoon about our prophet mohammad (pbuh) thats different as no where in your religion does it say that you have to insult the prophet.

what i am saying that its intentional insult vs unintentional insult.

but yes you have raised a good point about spending little money and not offending other religion.

 

[Irfan Baloch]

If slaughtering cows is part of your religion then you don't belong in India.

if taunting, mocking and disturbing someone's faith is part of someone's religion that that person doesnt belong to civilized society anywhere in the world .. let alone India. All i can say is I am sorry

Hakim Muhammad Saeed the founder of Humdard foundation in India and Pakistan once said,

by not slaughtering cows and not eating cow meat... no Muslim will become lesser Muslim, your faith will remain intact and in addition to that you will get some health benefits too. try another meat instead not just out of respect for Hindus (you bigots) but just because its not good for health.

I personally avoided any form of meat when hosting Hindu families and guests.
it was out of respect and decency. something which is in short supply.

this Mutual respect is a must and it wont put even a scratch on our individual faiths. remember what the British Raj did to us.

they made us chew cow and pig fat bullet covers.. was that done out of ignorance and pure innocence? I dont think so.. there are some humbling lessons here

 

[Biplab Bijay]

the context is defferent . we slaughter cow because a) we like beef b) cows are more accesible ( sheeps are available yes but not everywhere. and also its becomeing tradition as sacrificing cows as they aree expensive is a symbol of wealth ?( not sure) .) anyway we kill cows because it collides with our religious obligation. ) on the other hand if you guys make an insulting cartoon about our prophet mohammad (pbuh) thats different as no where in your religion does it say that you have to insult the prophet.

what i am saying that its intentional insult vs unintentional insult.

but yes you have raised a good point about spending little money and not offending other religion.

Now let me put it in this way.
1: You make a tradition which insults others faith. Is not it bad ? And it is not mandatory to your religion.
2: For showing that you have wealth, you are insulting others faith. Is not it bad ? If I say that to show my creativity/Camera technique/ Programming skill, I will make cartoons or videos which will insult your religion, will it be ok ? And if I make it as a tradition then will it be ok ?(Though it is not in our religion).

We are not saying that " Dont follow your rituals.". We are saying make the qurbani but not with cows. Is that very hard demand to fulfil ?

 

[punit]

babri masjid is done and gone. i as a true muslim ( socialist ) don't care about mosques. to do so would be idolatry.

and what are the "hindu sentiments" about honor killing, wage slavery, dogs killing humans...

well!
1. honor killing is not religion specific.
2. Wage slavery .. whats that! u mean low pay jobs! get a btter degree or work harder.
3. dogs killing humans: Dear me ! when , how ?

 

[Jobless Jack]

If slaughtering cows is part of your religion then you don't belong in India.

if a muslim spoke along the same line as you he would be labelled a terrorist

 

[Biplab Bijay]

if taunting, mocking and disturbing someone's faith is part of someone's religion that that person doesnt belong to civilized society anywhere in the world .. let alone India. All i can say is I am sorry

Hakim Muhammad Saeed the founder of Humdard foundation in India and Pakistan once said,

by not slaughtering cows and not eating cow meat... no Muslim will become lesser Muslim, your faith will remain intact and in addition to that you will get some health benefits too. try another meat instead not just out of respect for Hindus (you bigots) but just because its not good for health.

I personally avoided any form of meat when hosting Hindu families and guests.
it was out of respect and decency. something which is in short supply.

this Mutual respect is a must and it wont put even a scratch on our individual faiths. remember what the British Raj did to us.

they made us chew cow and pig fat bullet covers.. was that done out of ignorance and pure innocence? I dont think so.. there are some humbling lessons here

Best comment so far. I dont know your age, but meri umar aap ko lag jaaye.

 

[ChennaiDude]

Can I have some of that beef though

I will Have some tooo!..Medium Rare please!