What's new

Muslim personal law 'unjust, barbaric, outdated', Markandey Katju says

I am hardly able to understand, we are talking about laws in India which is going to affect Indian population, why people from other nationalities are interested in discussing it without any basic understanding.

And those lecturing India that it is trying to change Islam, do you really think, Islam is so small that it can be changed by this change? Give some respect to Islam.

Moreover, as a secular country, there should not be any division the way law sees its citizens
 
who want to rush through the UCC without considering the views of the Muslim populace who would be affected by the scrapping of the recognition of Islamic rite marriages.

Who told you so? Do you have any proof for such or are basing it on your prejudice ?

The only right that Muslims would lose in UCC is of polygamy, and casual talaq.

UCC would be closer to Hindu civil code simply because Hindu civil code is not Hindu civil law, but is based on secular liberal principles. In Hinduism, while monogamy is preferred, polygamy is not specifically prohibited; but Hindu civil code bans polygamy. Similarly, Hinduism does not envision equal division of property for females, but Hindu civil code stipulates that daughters would have equal share in inherited property. Hinduism does not have provision for divorce, but Hindu civil code has provision for divorce.I could go on and on about differences between Hindu laws and Hindu civil code.
 
Last edited:
universal civil law is thee call of tthe hour. Time we reached a modern society even by force. the majority has voted for it and it is a promise modiji will fulfill.

No one should be above the law, nor below the law.

What it effectively means is police reforms in India. About 20 years overdue.
 
That joke is getting old. Like the Uniform civil code one. You couldn't even try it when were 8% after partition. Now we are 35%. It's not possible.
but this is India,not any shariah nation...
Anyway..If you want to live in your code,feel free to pack your bags...
 
but this is India,not any shariah nation...
Anyway..If you want to live in your code,feel free to pack your bags...
Pack my bags? According to you I was a false-flagger hindu, right?

No Muslim will ever leave India. Period. It might happen with other communities but not with us. Sharia was there since 1000 years no one had problem then. Why create unnecessary fuss now?

No Indian Muslim whether Sunni(Barelvi or deobandi) or Shia is going to support an uniform civil code. So you better buy a ticket to Nepal.
 
Tell this to @Spring Onion. She was treating his words as gospel truth when that katju said 90% indians were fools....and she was no where to be seen when katju apologized for his remarks.
 
but this is India,not any shariah nation...
Anyway..If you want to live in your code,feel free to pack your bags...

Indian Congress leaders Nehru, Gandhi and future RSS ideologues like Valabhai Patel and others promised Muslim leaders the application of Islamic personal law as a prerequisite for joining the Indian state. If you throw away your promise which you made to great Muslim leaders like Abul Kalam Azad, then you surrender any legitimacy to claiming to represent any Muslim in India.

If you want to future partition India, you are more than welcome. Pakistan won't complain. ;)
 
Indian Congress leaders Nehru, Gandhi and future RSS ideologues like Valabhai Patel and others promised Muslim leaders the application of Islamic personal law as a prerequisite for joining the Indian state. If you throw away your promise which you made to great Muslim leaders like Abul Kalam Azad, then you surrender any legitimacy to claiming to represent any Muslim in India.
If you want to future partition India, you are more than welcome. Pakistan won't complain.
You are right but lets not talk about partition. Partition only harmed Hindustani Muslims. Hope you realize that.
 
Indian Congress leaders Nehru, Gandhi and future RSS ideologues like Valabhai Patel and others promised Muslim leaders the application of Islamic personal law as a prerequisite for joining the Indian state. If you throw away your promise which you made to great Muslim leaders like Abul Kalam Azad, then you surrender any legitimacy to claiming to represent any Muslim in India.

If you want to future partition India, you are more than welcome. Pakistan won't complain. ;)
We are not throwing out anything. we are just applying a new law.
 
60-80 million already escaped from the eastern one. Jokes aside. You know in your heart its never going to happen. Just forget it already.Good for your health.

Even your so-called patriotic Muslims ie Barelvis and Shias oppose it.


I think your are delusional like your friends. You think Gandhi and Nehru let us stay in India. Beleive me no one would have kicked us. We are original owners of this land.
so land lord sir.. How you have become minority here?
 
so land lord sir.. How you have become minority here?
We are always a minority but we created and ruled this country. This is how it was in past and will be in future. We will dictate terms to you not the other way around. Now get over it already.
 
Indian Congress leaders Nehru, Gandhi and future RSS ideologues like Valabhai Patel and others promised Muslim leaders the application of Islamic personal law as a prerequisite for joining the Indian state. If you throw away your promise which you made to great Muslim leaders like Abul Kalam Azad, then you surrender any legitimacy to claiming to represent any Muslim in India.

If you want to future partition India, you are more than welcome. Pakistan won't complain. ;)

Are you out of your fucking mind?

No one promised anything to muslims. Muslims got pakistan, and if they wanted anything like retrograde sharia ,and were not happy in India they were free to go to pakistan. No one wanted to keep muslims in India by appeasing them.Morally they should have packed their bags and left for pure land rather than leeching. It is daryadili of Hindus that muzzies were not hunted down like dogs in India. Sikhs did not left a single muzzie alive in Punjab.
 
Back
Top Bottom