Muslim In Awadh Will Not Do Qurbani On Eid, They Will Cut A Goat Shaped Cake Instead

[hussain0216]

In India they evolved further from omnivores to Vegetarians while the rest of humanity got stuck as barbarians looting and plundering the world.

Indian civilisation values is a result of tens of Thousands of years of civilisation. It has no peers to compare.

Then whats with the flying monkeys, elephant head god, cow piss, lingam

All these are the exact opposite of civilisation

 

[544_delta]

Thank God for Pakistan

 

[VivasvatManu]

Then whats with the flying monkeys, elephant head god, cow piss, lingam

All these are the exact opposite of civilisation

Then stop watching Hollywood movies and cartoons.

 

[untitled]

You are ridiculous. Don't you even know the meaning of "Life"? What Muslims?? Are you people from Mars? When you will stop playing victims?

Apparently your spacefaring advanced civilization Hindu friend @VivasvatManu can't tell whether Muslims are life or not

BTW i was talking about Muslims who had pay the ultimate price for Indian holy cows

 

[Tshering22]

@ Vivasvat Manu - Your open derision of Muslims and Christians is a bit distasteful. Just saying.

Buddy, how long can someone keep tolerating insults after insults to one's community? The fact is, history is evidence to all the reasons for which Vivasvat Manu is angry.

If insults were targeted towards my community, I would also get on the offensive. I think you should face facts and be able to tell the truth from the false.

Secularism and respect is a two way street.

Why the whole guilt when those who do are not guilty?

 

[CBU-105]

Yes and Yes. Otherwise you would have got what I had said the first time itself.

now you're being a fundamentalist, why not just let people do as they please and eat what they want ? and If consuming meat is going to be bad for their health, so be it, that's on them.

 

[kaykay]

By the way what's the percentage of people in India who don't eat meat? near to 90%?

around 30-40%...

 

[VivasvatManu]

Buddy, how long can someone keep tolerating insults after insults to one's community? The fact is, history is evidence to all the reasons for which Vivasvat Manu is angry.

Why the whole guilt when those who do are not guilty?

I am not angry, Its easier to be blunt while speaking the truth. Its less taxing.

 

[hassan zohaib]

Awadh may pride itself on Nawabi culture and biryani, but a few Muslims chose a blood free Eid this year in Lucknow.

The Awadh unit of Muslim Rashtriya Manch, an RSS backed organisation refused to sacrifice cattle for today's Bakr-Eid. A goat will still be cut - a 5 kg goat shaped cake.

BCCL

The 5 kg cake will get a jhatka treatment at the Manch's Awadh office. At home, the Muslim workers have promised to not cook biryani, instead enjoying Eid by offering sewaiyan and dahi vada to their loved ones.

"We can sacrifice our children too for Allah but it is not right to kill a goat without any reason and eat its meat"

oxforddictionaries

Awadh Prant convener Raees Khan told Indian Express that the gesture was a message to society "Bakr-Eid can be celebrated also by cutting a cake just like people celebrate birth anniversaries,". Co-convener Hasan Kausar said, "The Bakr-Eid festival spreads a message of humanity."

100 Years Ago, The Muslims Of Lucknow Voluntarily Gave Up Cow Slaughter For Eid-ul-Zuha

https://twitter.com/x/status/775661895810478080

http://www.indiatimes.com/news/india/no-qurbani-for-awadh-muslim-manch-goats-rss-backed-group-will-cut-a-goat-shaped-cake-instead-261640.html

really i am very surprised to know that we can sacrifice our child on the fiat of God but we cant sacrifice the Goat on the order of God because we dont see any reason in sacrificing this. as far as i know in God`s orders our discretion has been left to none to be employed.

not, it's just a small gesture toward interfaith harmony by a few muslims from one organization, it's not like there was no eid sacrifice in Awadh, so no biggie really.

These Pakistanis here are getting their panties in a bunch over nothing.

why really is it that every minority forced to show interfaith harmony? why does not the majority can do the same?
is it not that to sacrifice cow, goat etc necessary tenet of Islam? so if muslims can show harmomy then why cant Hindus do the same by allowing muslims to practice their religious orders in separte area respecting hindus.

 

[Maira La]

Foreign INVASION did change us since they destroyed our universities and schools

Please don't pretend your universities taught rocket science. They were Buddhist learning centers - as useless to modern world as kindergarten books (actually kindergarten books are a bit more useful for the little ones).

Anyways, Nalanda was set on fire by some angry Tirthikas - not Muslims. Do some research beyond internet forum/blogs hearsay. Ask your own historians.

, our Infrastructure

Lol you had nothing. Muslims gave you real roads, like the Grand Trunk Road - connecting Chittagong to Kabul. Quite ambitious; read about it.

, our Economy

Economy? Which industry? All you had were fertile land - Muslims introduced more sophisticated concepts - like currency (Rupiyah).

, our standards and our methodologies

our values and our behaviour

Want to go back to the days of Sati practice?

If you could turn the clock a 1000 year back, visit the era before Muslims arrived and seen the brutal oppression common Indians endured at the hands of the 1% real unmixed, upper caste - I'm sure you wouldn't be so proud of your religion today!

 

[VivasvatManu]

now you're being a fundamentalist, why not just let people do as they please and eat what they want ? and If consuming meat is going to be bad for their health, so be it, that's on them.

I a not interested in your label or certificate. it just shows intellectual bankruptcy.

Ravan was free to kidnap Sita and Duryodhan was free to cheat, lie and plot.

When Ram and Krishna could not stop that from happening, then who am I ?

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

Is that what you are told about Eid ul Azha?

Then what do you suggest. Before slaughter beat the hell out of the animal rather then treat it affectionately?

The sacrificial meat is supposed to be handed to poor and relatives too. Many of whom can't afford to eat on a regular basis. To you giving fresh meat to friends and relatives is a bad thing too? Think about that next time you gobble down a KFC.

Don't beat the animal. Never suggested that. I would much rather if the Qurbani never happens and Muslim families just release the animal after feeding and treating it lovingly after Eid or if the Qurbani is a must then just get the animal and do the Qurbani without the feeding and loving treatment.

I mean just think about it from the animal's perspective, he/she probably feels that he/she has been adopted by a loving family that will feed and take care of him/her for the rest of his/her life, but suddenly it's killed and eaten. That's just a bit sad to me. But again, if it's a part of your religion then go ahead, no problems. I agree that sharing the meat with the poor is a good thing and all Muslims must do it if they don't already.

The KFC and other non veg food I eat is probably not treated like family before being killed is it ?

 

[Acknowledge]

Wow.

Tons of respect for these Muslims. Goes to show that stereotyping is wrong.

 

[VivasvatManu]

Please don't pretend your universities taught rocket science. They were Buddhist learning centers - as useless to modern world as kindergarten books (actually kindergarten books are a bit more useful for the little ones).

Anyways, Nalanda was set on fire by some angry Tirthikas - not Muslims. Do some research beyond internet forum/blogs hearsay. Ask your own historians.

Lol you had nothing. Muslims gave you real roads, like the Grand Trunk Road - connecting Chittagong to Kabul. Quite ambitious; read about it.

Economy? Which industry? All you had were fertile land - Muslims introduced more sophisticated concepts - like currency (Rupiyah).

Please don't pretend your universities taught rocket science. They were Buddhist learning centers - as useless to modern world as kindergarten books (actually kindergarten books are a bit more useful for the little ones).

Anyways, Nalanda was set on fire by some angry Tirthikas - not Muslims. Do some research beyond internet forum/blogs hearsay. Ask your own historians.

Lol you had nothing. Muslims gave you real roads, like the Grand Trunk Road - connecting Chittagong to Kabul. Quite ambitious; read about it.

Want to go back to the days of Sati practice?

If you could turn the clock a 1000 year back, visit the era before Muslims arrived and seen the brutal oppression common Indians endured at the hands of the 1% real unmixed, upper caste - I'm sure you wouldn't be so proud of your religion today!

I cannot change a lifetime of ignorance over a span of one thread in pdf.

Considering you are not an Indian, I won't even try.

 

[Tshering22]

scoundrel stupid sacrificing cow or goat is gods order . its cannot compare with birthday . ask this moron has he never ate beef burger or chicken burger ?? what is the humanity not fulfilling gods order and ''killing'' animal 364 days a year for consumption ???

From what Muslims in other parts of the country have said, it was one of your leading prophets (I guess it was the prophet Abraham or Ishmael.. don't remember) who was asked by god to sacrifice his son as an example to prove infinite devotion to god. When he passed his test of ultimate devotion to god, god replaced his son with the goat and the goat was sacrificed instead.

Where does that tell you that god would order the killing of a goat?

Just a question because this is what I was told.

BTW I am non-vegetarian.