Karachi slowly turning into lawless tribal area with brutal killings

[Desert Fox]

true, that doesnot mean it should not do its job, its police's job to maintain law and order, even in Rio, they didnt call in army to fix the mafia thugs, they trained and depoliticized their police to do the job... and they did a pretty good job..

Its not army's job, army's job is to secure the border from external threats and help in natural disasters.

Of course, i don't mean to imply that we get army off from borders and deploy them into cities, but rather we should put the police under Army's control and all other civil security institutions under Army control as well. We might see limited troop deployment in areas with sever criminal activity but other areas will need a increase in police and rangers units.

 

[Leader]

Of course, i don't mean to imply that we get army off from borders and deploy them into cities, but rather we should put the police under Army's control and all other civil security institutions under Army control as well. We might see limited troop deployment in areas with sever criminal activity but other areas will need a increase in police and rangers units.

look its not army's job, police and army must remain separate, apart from some special units, they are two different forces with two different objectives, its police that must be built to do its job to clean Karachi and establish law and order. in other words, no short cuts.

 

[Bilal.]

Yaar police is under provincial control and they are controlling one of the mafia gangs.

 

[root]

I think Karachi need predator drones........

 

[Desert Fox]

look its not army's job, police and army must remain separate, apart from some special units, they are two different forces with two different objectives, its police that must be built to do its job to clean Karachi and establish law and order. in other words, no short cuts.

So who's going to clean up the police force if not the Army? All civil institutions are corrupt and involved in the same mess!

Police force should be put under control of army and reorganized. Any elements within the police linked with criminals can only be rooted out if the police force is put under a organized and much disciplined institution like the army.

 

[RescueRanger]

Karachi has always been a mess since i was a wee little nipper. Only now it has been amplified with the Anti Chrisitian, Anti Shia, Anti Ahmedhi, Anti Pathan, Anti humanity nonsense.

 

[Leader]

So who's going to clean up the police force if not the Army? All civil institutions are corrupt and involved in the same mess!

Police force should be put under control of army and reorganized. Any elements within the police linked with criminals can only be rooted out if the police force is put under a organized and much disciplined institution like the army.

It has to be done by the political leadership...only a woman can give birth to a child, only police can solve law and order problems, army is not built to do these kind of things in its own lands, I surely dont wish to see Army getting involved and creating another Bangladesh like situation... the stakes are too high, it must be done by police and only police.

lets demand for modernization and de-politicization of police from the govt.

Yaar police is under provincial control and they are controlling one of the mafia gangs.

NS is producing anti-terrorist squad, a sort of federal police which would be under the federal like FBI. the idea is good, i hope that he grows that unit to control such messy situations like the one in Karachi...

 

[W.11]

i agree with army demand though karachi needs army to do the operation

but then again the agencies are the one who are running all the criminal activities from extortion to weapon smuggling to gambling dens to drug trafficking

will army flush out its own agencies?

remains to be seen

but sure as hell rangers and police can't bring peace to the city

 

[RescueRanger]

What Karachi needs is more people like CH. Aslam Khan and Zulfiqar Ahmad Cheema.

 

[M. Sarmad]

I think Karachi need predator drones........

No , It is you who needs "Electroshock" for treatment of his mental-disorders

 

[Bilal.]

@Leader, That just might work, unless PPP starts crying that the centre is interfering in provincial matter, somebody needs to be strong and tell them to stfu.

 

[Ayush]

@Desert Fox but then these guys will ultimately reach gwadar or any other such city and the same thing will happen there.
That is not a solution.
A temporary one at max.

 

[W.11]

i also support army should be deployed in FATA and KPK, entire taliban menace should be wiped out, it is ultimately linked with karachi situation

we will stop drone attacks if operation is launchd in north waziristan and other occupied areas of FATA

 

[Dubious]

I think Karachi need predator drones........

Yup we need to get hold of some to fry your @ss then ask you how it feels

 

[W.11]

karachi first of all need CCTV cameras with exit gates properly guarded, 90% of the menace like drug trafficking, land grabbing, taliban, weapons come from those entry gates

the operation is reaching 3 months and important no go areas have still not been removed

1) sohrab goth(TTP)

2) lyari(BLA/TTP/gangwar)

3) dalmia(BLA/drug makers)

4) GADAP

5) manghopir(TTP)

6) banaras

7) quaidabad(TTP/lyari gangwar)

8) orangi town

‮پاکستان‬ - ‭BBC Urdu‬ - ‮’طالبان کی وجہ سے چھاپے نہیں مار سکتے‘‬

I think Karachi need predator drones........

the population density of karachi is one of biggest in the world, it is more than thousand people per km square

if you deploy missile attack collateral damage is too huge