Israel is everything the RSS wants India to be, Modi is making it happen

[The_Showstopper]

Not talking about political parties. I am saying that most Indians support better India Israel relations.

Not most Indians it is the right wing/centre-right leaning. Most Indians are ignorant about history of Israeli-Palestine conflict. They just go by the current narrative.

His chapters on the world affairs were released in the late thirties. Then the Holocaust did not even take place. The Holocaust was known with gory detail only after the collapse of the Ost Heer in the 1945 Soviet rush to the Oder (and beyond).

Neither was their a major conflict between Jews and muslims nor a major call for a formation of Jewish state in Palestine before 1940's. So how did he come to support a separate Jewish state?

I don't think its hate. More like both sides want to learn lessons from the past and formulate solutions to meet with a common threat.

It is hate, pure hate(You may not want to agree) but your source clearly speaks about the common enemy(And we know who the common enemy is).

 

[HariVamsha]

It is hate, pure hate(You may not want to agree) but your source clearly speaks about the common enemy(And we know who the common enemy is).

Islam ? or muslims ?

Communism ? or communist ?

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Not most Indians it is the right wing/centre-right leaning. Most Indians are ignorant about history of Israeli-Palestine conflict. They just go by the current narrative.

Again politics? Plus you are underestimating the knowledge of people here. Indians are not ignorant.
Indians by and large know about Israel Palestine conflict and support Israel while having some sympathy for Palestinians. There was more support for Palestine pre 1990s - when the spectre of Islamic violence in India was limited. But then things changed. You can say who started it and so on - but the end result is what we see today. Most Indians find this as a very positive development.

Neither was their a major conflict between Jews and muslims nor a major call for a formation of Jewish state in Palestine before 1940's. So how did he support for seperate Jewish state?

The call for a Jewish state has been far older.
The conflict between Jews and Muslim in the holy land has been since time immemorial. Only the Christian atrocities in Europe made their status in the ME seem better in comparison. But I doubt they want to go back to having the Dhimmi status.

It is hate

Our perspectives here will naturally be mutually opposite. Its okay. What seems as hate to you is a rational understanding of the threats to me.

 

[The_Showstopper]

1. You are contradicting yourself. One one hand you says the sangh inspired textbook have no mention of hitler's ghastly treatment of jews, and on the other hand you are saying that sanhgis love Israel/jews
2. Jews, Christians and Muslims are indeed foreigners. Go sufficiently long back in history and there were no jews & christians in India and the killer cult was not even born
3. Regarding common enemy of "you know whom", this reason is in fact bringing the whole civilized world together nowadays - gang up against the killer cult or die. This preaching of "my god is the only god" (jeopardising the religions who believe otherwise, like hindus) and "my messenger was the best as well as the last (jeopardising the old abrahamic religions as well as stopping any new religion to be born), is the nemesis of humanity.

You should read my post properly or get some comprehension lessons. I clearly stated "ultra right wing Jews."

And for the rest of your garbage, well they don't deserve a reply. Keep trolling and get banned at some point of time. You are itching for it.

Again politics? Plus you are underestimating the knowledge of people here. Indians are not ignorant.
Indians by and large know about Israel Palestine conflict and support Israel while having some sympathy for Palestinians. There was more support for Palestine pre 1990s - when the spectre of Islamic violence in India was limited. But then things changed. You can say who started it and so on - but the end result is what we see today. Most Indians find this as a very positive development.

You can ask any random guy in India about the Palestinian conflict and all they would have to say is "terrorism"(because that is the current narrative). And they won't really scratch through it(which is understandable) since it doesn't concern them. So in that sense they are ignorant about the issue. Sympathy for Palestine wouldn't come from the same individual(Indian) who would support Israel but from Indians who understand the history and the current scenario.

The call for a Jewish state has been far older.
The conflict between Jews and Muslim in the holy land has been since time immemorial. Only the Christian atrocities in Europe made their status in the ME seem better in comparison. But I doubt they want to go back to having the Dhimmi status.

I think I clearly used the term "MAJOR", Since there was no MAJOR conflict between jews and muslims or any MAJOR call for a Jewish state in Palestine back then. So how did Savarkar gave a call out unless he did it during/after the creation of Jewish State in Palestine when they were in conflict with muslims.

 

[footmarks]

Post reported for calling Islam killer cult

@waz @The Eagle @Emmie

Edited my post. Apologies that it hurt you. Please be as touchy feely when pure people take cheap shots on other religions calling them pee drinkers and what not.

 

[salarsikander]

Edited my post. Apologies that it hurt you. Please be as touchy feely when pure people take cheap shots on other religions calling them pee drinkers and what not.

No I won't be. That's my personal choice. If I find anything Insulting about my religion, I will report it. You too follow the same method. But don't influence me.
Cheers