Is Azad Kashmir Retrievable? with Dr. Subramanian Swamy and Maj. Gaurav Arya

[Umar Nazir]

There is always a scope of a limited war in kashmir. As Major Arya puts it kashmir valley is a 150 x 140 km strech of land and pakistan will not risk total nuclear annihilation for it. Pakistan wants kashmir for its water security. If India attacks to retake pakistan administered kashmir without opening other fronts the casualties of the IA will significant as pakistani will be ready in well dug positions but in th end it will be India that wins as Pakistan's smaller military and economic resources get exhausted and overwhelmed by the Indians.

Pakistan will be more than happy if fight remain limited to Kashmir sector. In 1965 Pakistan was winning comprehensively in Kashmir sector which forced india to open Sialkot and Lahore front . Otherwise Kashmir chapter could have been closed in 1965 if war remained limited to Kashmir sector

 

[Jackdaws]

Stupid Sanghis. Till 10 years ago, such views were fringe at best. It's ridiculous that people openly advocate war for a few hits on their YouTube channel. And enough idiots in India love this kind of jingoism.

 

[POPEYE-Sailor]

Meanwhile in INDIA

https://www.facebook.com/

 

[Jackdaws]

Pakistan will be more than happy if fight remain limited to Kashmir sector. In 1965 Pakistan was winning comprehensively in Kashmir sector which forced india to open Sialkot and Lahore front . Otherwise Kashmir chapter could have been closed in 1965 if war remained limited to Kashmir sector

That was because of the element of surprise. Also in 1965 Pakistan had far superior weapons. Not that I am advocating war - I think it is stupid to go to war anywhere.

 

[Shah_G]

This guy took over Kashmir from India without using nukes.

 

[Falcon26]

What is India waiting for?

 

[MayaBazar]

What is India waiting for?

Green signal form PM IK & General Bajwa.

 

[Umar Nazir]

That was because of the element of surprise. Also in 1965 Pakistan had far superior weapons. Not that I am advocating war - I think it is stupid to go to war anywhere.

exactly any one who support war is stupid.

 

[925boy]

There is always a scope of a limited war in kashmir. As Major Arya puts it kashmir valley is a 150 x 140 km strech of land and pakistan will not risk total nuclear annihilation for it. Pakistan wants kashmir for its water security. If India attacks to retake pakistan administered kashmir without opening other fronts the casualties of the IA will significant as pakistani will be ready in well dug positions

Ok, good points and commentary.

but in th end it will be India that wins as Pakistan's smaller military and economic resources get exhausted and overwhelmed by the Indians.

Hmmm....couldnt China change/disrupt this??? A Pakistan that is considerably supported by China might be able to drain or exhaust India militarily. Look at what a Pakistan-supported Taliban did to NATO and US military in Afghanistan..

pakistan will never attack india for kashmir , nor india is going to attack pakistan for azad kashmir .

Please first define the word "attack" as you've used here.

 

[Mrc]

What is India waiting for?

Tea supplies to b delivered to pak in coronavirus disrupted supply chain

 

[American Pakistani]

i dont understand tour reply what you mean another can of propaganda.

By that I meant that Bharti terrorists and propagandists will start their propaganda claiming that Pakistan military is forcing innocent Kashmiris to become army slave by forcing them to join military and bla bla.

 

[Hakikat ve Hikmet]

Major Ary was a major for a reason. He was stupid

His performance report was like: not fit for any commands beyond the platoon level....

As for Swamy, first save your own daughter from the "Love Jihat"; facing the Turkic/Afgan style Jihat is way above your pay level....

 

[ziaulislam]

There is always a scope of a limited war in kashmir. As Major Arya puts it kashmir valley is a 150 x 140 km strech of land and pakistan will not risk total nuclear annihilation for it. Pakistan wants kashmir for its water security. If India attacks to retake pakistan administered kashmir without opening other fronts the casualties of the IA will significant as pakistani will be ready in well dug positions but in th end it will be India that wins as Pakistan's smaller military and economic resources get exhausted and overwhelmed by the Indians.

I disagree as pretty sure indians will not be ready for prolonged war..few thousand causalities and they will be back..
Even if india doesnt open further front any party can with their dozens of crusie missles and 400+ airforces..
Few dozens of blastic /cruise missles in bombai and ripple effect will tear indian economy

India is ran by buisness men who want extremism for their benefit but dont war

As extremism is what keep india together ..a hate for common enemey

 

[American Pakistani]

isn't it happening in india already lol

Not at the level where bhart can be finally divided for good.

You cannot give any breathing room to this bhart who have highest number of terrorists under its military uniform and umbrella. 9 lakh Bharti occupier terrorists.

 

[GHALIB]

I disagree as pretty sure indians will not be ready for prolonged war..few thousand causalities and they will be back..
Even if india doesnt open further front any party can with their dozens of crusie missles and 400+ airforces..
Few dozens of blastic /cruise missles in bombai and ripple effect will tear indian economy

India is ran by buisness men who want extremism for their benefit but dont war

As extremism is what keep india together ..a hate for common enemey

nobody wants war , status quo will be maintained .