Indian writer Arundhati Roy returns National Award in protest

[AnnoyingOrange]

indeed they should return it afterall hindutva and intellectualism are at odds with each other

They will.. provided any country is ready to accept them ... given their contribution is more in the line of Ball-sucking to a certain family.

 

[Spring Onion]

This is coming from a country where youtube is banned, when minority community are declining and force conversion as a part of policy,no minority never ever come on top most position of that country,always discriminating people based on community,no reservation for minority.

Buddy don't lecture us what we have to do, just look on your own countries track record against minority is a proof that you people are the least one in the world to lecture others on communal harmony.

your frustration shows you have no valid argument to back your support for attacking writers and others in India.

NVM

 

[Mr.Nair]

your frustration shows you have no valid argument to back your support for attacking writers and others in India.

NVM

Ya ya coming from a person when he can't deny what happening in their own country on minority, but looks what happening on neighbour.

 

[Spring Onion]

Have you seen any of the so called Intellectuals getting booked for returning awards.. or for making acquisitions against government doing nothing around so called intolerance... all of them are openly allowed to rant and claim victim...and they are givn an active media as a platform...how else you define freedom of expression....no one is supporting attack on anyone...

\
bwahahahahahahahahahahah well where in the world anyone is booked for returning the award ? lolzzzzzzzzzz. anyway the intolerance is an over all attitude of a society whereas Indian society is no exception

Ya ya coming from a person when he can't deny what happening in their own country on minority, but looks what happening on neighbour.

first of all why should i deny if anything is happening in my country? secondly this thread is about India not Pakistan, so open a thread about Pakistan and i wwill reply every line of your claims there

thirdly i am no he

 

[Mr.Nair]

Oh they are returning the award, india is doomed.

When all of us telling that we indian's don't give a sh**t for returning their award, then why our neighbours crying !

 

[AnnoyingOrange]

\
bwahahahahahahahahahahah well where in the world anyone is booked for returning the award ? lolzzzzzzzzzz. anyway the intolerance is an over all attitude of a society whereas Indian society is no exception

There you go... you yourself said that there is some amount of intolerance in every society...and obviously Indian society is not an exception.... The fact is that these so called Intellectuals could not digest that people rejected their thought process and selected Narendra Modi as Prime Minister.. so returning awards is their way of getting back at society.... just like a child goes belly up when the family does not follow him to the swing that he likes the most in the park.


And stealing your laugh now....bwahahahahahahahahahahah

 

[Spring Onion]

There you go... you yourself said that there is some amount of intolerance in every society...and obviously Indian society is not an exception.... The fact is that these so called Intellectuals could not digest that people rejected their thought process and selected Narendra Modi as Prime Minister.. so returning awards is their way of getting back at society.... just like a child goes belly up when the family does not follow him to the swing that he likes the most in the park.


And stealing your laugh now....bwahahahahahahahahahahah

So Indian public voted for Modi on the basis on Hindutva ideology ?

AND NO returning awards is the most peaceful way of protest against intolerance

as for the red well indeed that is why instead of blaming the writers for the action you should accept the reality and contribute positively to reduce such intolerance

 

[AnnoyingOrange]

So Indian public voted for Modi on the basis on Hindutva ideology ?

No.. Indians voted for Narendra Modi's 12 year development record in State of Gujarat... and Indians voted against Congress party's incompetence...

AND NO returning awards is the most peaceful way of protest against intolerance

Returning awards handed over by previous governments while a different government is in power.. byt people who never wanted current government to come to power is not a protest.. it a political statement.

as for the red well indeed that is why instead of blaming the writers for the action you should accept the reality and contribute positively to reduce such intolerance

As of now the only people showing intolerance are these so called intellectuals ... who wrote public letters trying to influence common man to vote against Narendra Modi.. but alas .. their plans failed... big time. so now we have this drama.

 

[jamahir]

This is coming from a country where youtube is banned, when minority community are declining and force conversion as a part of policy,no minority never ever come on top most position of that country,always discriminating people based on community,no reservation for minority.

Buddy don't lecture us what we have to do, just look on your own countries track record against minority is a proof that you people are the least one in the world to lecture others on communal harmony.

are you supporter of a unbiased socialist/progressive movement to lecture pakistan??

i can lecture pakistan, joe shearer can lecture pakistan, arvind kejriwal can lecture pakistan, but not someone who is aligned with a reactionary right-wing movement.

So Indian public voted for Modi on the basis on Hindutva ideology ?

there is a vast number of indian public which didn't vote for modi... the bjp/nda government rules without the consent of those people, undemocratically.

When all of us telling that we indian's don't give a sh**t for returning their award, then why our neighbours crying !

then you should get modi to declare in the uno general assembly that india is now a fascism-ruled state that doesn't care for opinions of intellectuals and progressive activists.

 

[Mr.Nair]

are you supporter of a unbiased socialist/progressive movement to lecture pakistan??

i can lecture pakistan, joe shearer can lecture pakistan, arvind kejriwal can lecture pakistan, but not someone who is aligned with a reactionary right-wing movement.



there is a vast number of indian public which didn't vote for modi... the bjp/nda government rules without the consent of those people, undemocratically.



then you should get modi to declare in the uno general assembly that india is now a fascism-ruled state that doesn't care for opinions of intellectuals and progressive activists.

Oops undemocratically ! ofcourse no body care about comments from fanatics either

 

[AnnoyingOrange]

are you supporter of a unbiased socialist/progressive movement to lecture pakistan??

i can lecture pakistan, joe shearer can lecture pakistan, arvind kejriwal can lecture pakistan, but not someone who is aligned with a reactionary right-wing movement.

So you are the self proclaimed Thekedar of Secularisim in India... right.

there is a vast number of indian public which didn't vote for modi... the bjp/nda government rules without the consent of those people, undemocratically.

Yes.. the same vast proportion of people who booted your favorite party out of power... and BJP got 300+ seats because majority of India voted against them... right... what fcuked up logic...

then you should get modi to declare in the uno general assembly that india is now a fascism-ruled state that doesn't care for opinions of intellectuals and progressive activists.

India never cared about these so called intellectuals.. only a certain section of society did... and now even they don't care ...about them.. people are more concerned about lives... and not some fake left wing thought process that favors elites only...

 

[bloo]

Well, she sure took her time.

 

[jamahir]

So you are the self proclaimed Thekedar of Secularisim in India... right.

secularism by itself doesn't work, at least indian-style secularism - "i will tolerate your religious nonsense if you tolerate my religious nonsense".

i am the thekedar of socialism.

Yes.. the same vast proportion of people who booted your favorite party out of power

i wasn't aware that i am a congress supporter.

and BJP got 300+ seats because majority of India voted against them... right... what fcuked up logic...

like i said many a time, the western-style "representative democracy" system with its confusing and unnecessary multiple parties and elections is really a system against true democracy... like the "green book" says, it is a fraud.

when i said a number of people, whether one million or just one, didn't give consent to bjp forming government, why did you need to quote how many seats bjp got in the parliament??

the political system in india needs two things replacing the current set up...

1. removal of all parties which operate on basis of religion.
2. direct-democracy guided by socialism/progressivism, without fake representation through either members of parliament or political parties.

i don't see why any self-declared sensible person should object to that.

India never cared about these so called intellectuals.. only a certain section of society did

what is "india"??

i am from india as does shahrukh khan as did late govind pansare as do all the award returnees... we are not from germany or north korea.

people are more concerned about lives

and those same uncaring, fence-sitting, anti-progressive "people" find no one to turn to when they find social/economic troubles in their personal life... why do you think india is "suicide capital of the world"??

and not some fake left wing thought process that favors elites only.

no real left-winger is a faker... the fakers are those neo-rich software/mba idiots who earn off the confused/unnecessary/harmful capitalist system in the west, and spend a thursday hour getting a interest-based loan from a private bank to buy the latesht cell phone and spend their weekends in the alcohol holes of bangalore, poona and gurgaon... these are the parasites.

the left-wingers on the other hand discuss and rant and rage about the 200,000 farmers who suicided in india between 1997 and 2010 and before then and after.

who is removed from india's problems now??

 

[GR!FF!N]

wasn't m..m kalburgi the latest victim ( august 2015 )??

LOL..was BJP/RSS or Central Government behind it??He applied to Congress Govt for protection,special protection" for a few days was provided.Then he requested for removal of those guards and after which Killers attacked.I condemn those attacks and yes,it is State Police's failure to apprehend those criminals.But does this really this has anything to do with Central Government?

I wonder where was her conscience when 2 RSS man got stabbed,where one died??Perhaps thats due to the reason that CPI(M) workers were behind this,right??

One can of course return a reward saying "Govt is not doing enough to stop these attacks on Civilians".but returning reward over some murder is like returning reward over "26/11".

By the way....

RSS pays tribute to MM Kalburgi, says ‘quota must till needed’ | The Indian Express

 

[AnnoyingOrange]

secularism by itself doesn't work, at least indian-style secularism - "i will tolerate your religious nonsense if you tolerate my religious nonsense".

i am the thekedar of socialism.



i wasn't aware that i am a congress supporter.



like i said many a time, the western-style "representative democracy" system with its confusing and unnecessary multiple parties and elections is really a system against true democracy... like the "green book" says, it is a fraud.

when i said a number of people, whether one million or just one, didn't give consent to bjp forming government, why did you need to quote how many seats bjp got in the parliament??

the political system in india needs two things replacing the current set up...

1. removal of all parties which operate on basis of religion.
2. direct-democracy guided by socialism/progressivism, without fake representation through either members of parliament or political parties.

i don't see why any self-declared sensible person should object to that.

what is "india"??

i am from india as does shahrukh khan as did late govind pansare as do all the award returnees... we are not from germany or north korea.

and those same uncaring, fence-sitting, anti-progressive "people" find no one to turn to when they find social/economic troubles in their personal life... why do you think india is "suicide capital of the world"??

no real left-winger is a faker... the fakers are those neo-rich software/mba idiots who earn off the confused/unnecessary/harmful capitalist system in the west, and spend a thursday hour getting a interest-based loan from a private bank to buy the latesht cell phone and spend their weekends in the alcohol holes of bangalore, poona and gurgaon... these are the parasites.

the left-wingers on the other hand discuss and rant and rage about the 200,000 farmers who suicided in india between 1997 and 2010 and before then and after.

who is removed from india's problems now??

Commie alert.. the laal jhande wala babas are irrelevant and out of system now.. so their opinion does not count....to feed people you need money... to make money you need system that can generate money.... byt hte looks of what Commies did in Bengal... I say ..we are very happy being confused...MBA...techies....atleast we are making money to feed out families and we don't depend on state to feed myself.