What's new

Indian PM to visit Afghanistan

india is going to try to save itself in Afghanistan after the recent developments...

Why India need to save itself? Who is saving you? India is in good position in Afghanistan. We have people support. India is going to announce another aid package for Afghanistan. We should always support Afghanistan's development.

the recent developments...
Osama raid? It has minimum affect on Afghanistan and no affect on India .
 
. .
What a moron nation we are, we are allowing different rivals and neighbors to share us between themselves and tear us apart. Truly sad and shameful.

India is not part of that. India has done development only. You know who wants Taliban back and were supporting Taliban.
 
.
What a moron nation we are, we are allowing different rivals and neighbors to share us between themselves and tear us apart. Truly sad and shameful.

I feel sorry, if you dont allow enemy of your neighbour, it is better for your country and mine.
 
.
India is not part of that. India has done development only. You know who wants Taliban back and were supporting Taliban.

Buddy, Afghans in general have much more of favorable opinion towards India, it is a fact, yes, India supported us with great projects which we are hugely thankful to it, likewise we are thankful to Pakistan as well for their projects, also Iran, Japan etc. But when it comes to politics, everybody wants to take a piece of cake which is Afghanistan, yes Pakistan have done more of the things, but it doesn't mean the others are not playing interest based politics. We will only be better off without every single of these countries including former soviets, America etc. But sadly we are not a clever nation and badly divided.
 
.
Buddy, Afghans in general have much more of favorable opinion towards India, it is a fact, yes, India supported us with great projects which we are hugely thankful to it, likewise we are thankful to Pakistan as well for their projects, also Iran, Japan etc. But when it comes to politics, everybody wants to take a piece of cake which is Afghanistan, yes Pakistan have done more of the things, but it doesn't mean the others are not playing interest based politics. We will only be better off without every single of these countries including former soviets, America etc. But sadly we are not a clever nation and badly divided.

Nicely put. everybody is serving own interests.
 
. .
Buddy, Afghans in general have much more of favorable opinion towards India, it is a fact, yes, India supported us with great projects which we are hugely thankful to it, likewise we are thankful to Pakistan as well for their projects, also Iran, Japan etc. But when it comes to politics, everybody wants to take a piece of cake which is Afghanistan, yes Pakistan have done more of the things, but it doesn't mean the others are not playing interest based politics. We will only be better off without every single of these countries including former soviets, America etc. But sadly we are not a clever nation and badly divided.

atleast u know better who made u war zone in past and even now??who settled talib rule in their??and who thinks u as their backyard??
and who wants again talibs to be a part of their game in govt also??
surely u are innocent and exploited by others.
i wish u have a united will army to take care of ur nation from any enemy..
 
.
Everybody is saying the same thing as a pretext to keep their feet in the land.

I dont know about others, but I definitely want Afghanistan to be left alone, on its own people. you are ought to sort out your problems and create no problems for adjoining countries.
 
.
Everybody is saying the same thing as a pretext to keep their feet in the land.

If you are equating India , Russia and Iran with countries like Pakistan in terms of the role they have played in Afghanistan then i must say it is shameful.

There is no comparison , you know it i know it.Pakistan helped Taliban rule your country and even today continues to support it .

No country can survive without friends and allies and investments . It is for the common afghan like you to chose who you want in that role based on your past experience. Rest is upto you .
 
.
Buddy, Afghans in general have much more of favorable opinion towards India, it is a fact, yes, India supported us with great projects which we are hugely thankful to it, likewise we are thankful to Pakistan as well for their projects, also Iran, Japan etc. But when it comes to politics, everybody wants to take a piece of cake which is Afghanistan, yes Pakistan have done more of the things, but it doesn't mean the others are not playing interest based politics. We will only be better off without every single of these countries including former soviets, America etc. But sadly we are not a clever nation and badly divided.

Sorry, did you mean you would be doing better without outsider involvement? If you were united among yourself?
I am not so sure.
Even a united and cohesive afganistan require investment for economic development. You need all those countries for that.
And obviously everybody wants to work for their interest, are not afgans too?
 
.
Sorry, did you mean you would be doing better without outsider involvement? If you were united among yourself?
I am not so sure.

Even a united and cohesive afganistan require investment for economic development. You need all those countries for that.
And obviously everybody wants to work for their interest, are not afgans too?

Yes, i think so. We would do better IF we were not divided. That is a big IF though because of unity factor. If were united, there wouldnt have been any damage to our infrastrcture, economy, no killings and opportunity for development---dont forget that Afghanistan have huge hidden treasure.

If you are equating India , Russia and Iran with countries like Pakistan in terms of the role they have played in Afghanistan then i must say it is shameful.

There is no comparison , you know it i know it.Pakistan helped Taliban rule your country and even today continues to support it .

No country can survive without friends and allies and investments . It is for the common afghan like you to chose who you want in that role based on your past experience. Rest is upto you .

The reason Pakistan is unpopular is because of its prolonged negative policies, Pakistan was in a good position to have a much more positive role which sadly didn't happen. As per India, India is having very very favorable position among Afghans, whatever the reason is I don't know, but it looks you guys have managed to keep your image in the country.
 
.
Yes, i think so. We would do better IF we were not divided. That is a big IF though because of unity factor. If were united, there wouldnt have been any damage to our infrastrcture, economy, no killings and opportunity for development---dont forget that Afghanistan have huge hidden treasure.


The reason Pakistan is unpopular is because of its prolonged negative policies, Pakistan was in a good position to have a much more positive role which sadly didn't happen. As per India, India is having very very favorable position among Afghans, whatever the reason is I don't know, but it looks you guys have managed to keep your image in the country.

I think the social cohesion is not so evident in many big countries, but still they live because of leaders, institutions, systems etc.
There is a lack of cohesion in India, we are a country of countries. But we manage to elect leaders who deliver, and institutions who dont break under pressure.
Even US is not as cohesive socially as you think.

If afgans had good leaders and instituions, defence forces etc, I dont think many would be attacking you. They will still want you on their side, and you can use that clout for your betterment.
Look at pakistan, they are doing exactly that. They are not so united, but by and large their institutions deliver, they play will all the powers to get best benefit. Why not.
 
.
I think the social cohesion is not so evident in many big countries, but still they live because of leaders, institutions, systems etc.
There is a lack of cohesion in India, we are a country of countries. But we manage to elect leaders who deliver, and institutions who dont break under pressure.
Even US is not as cohesive socially as you think.

If afgans had good leaders and instituions, defence forces etc, I dont think many would be attacking you. They will still want you on their side, and you can use that clout for your betterment.
Look at pakistan, they are doing exactly that. They are not so united, but by and large their institutions deliver, they play will all the powers to get best benefit. Why not.

I quite agree with you on the leaders which we have lacked. as a matter of fact it have been the leaders who have founded the basis of disunity. I am not talking about recent years, but the last century or so. As per inida, you cant compare it to Afghanistan and you shouldnt do. You might have diversity, but dont confuse it with disunity.
 
.
It would be naive to argue that India doesn't have any vested interests with regards to Afghanistan. But what exactly are the interests? From what I can see GoI wants a nation bordering Pakistan which is friendly to India (read non-friendly to Pakistan). Ahmad, what do you make of this? I mean is it such a bad thing? Isn't this one of the reasons GoI pursued a relationship with Iran as well... to isolate Pakistan?
 
.
Back
Top Bottom