Indian P-17A frigates superior to Pakistan's Type-054A frigates: Senior Indian Navy officer

[Tejas Spokesman]

Rear Admiral TK Sen (retired) was in-charge of operations of Western Naval Command in 2005-07.

 

[Murgah]

Ok suppa puwa

 

[war&peace]

P-17 and P-15 are good ducks for PNS to practice firing.... what about Kukri? that was also far superior to anything PNS had ..Has Indian navy been able bring it out of the bottom of the ocean?

 

[AUSTERLITZ]

P-17 and P-15 are good ducks for PNS to practice firing.... what about Kukri? that was also far superior to anything PNS had ..Has Indian navy been able bring it out of the bottom of the ocean?

Do you know how many PN ships we sunk in 1971 as against 1 kukri?
Each P15 Kolkata has 16 brahmos,enough for whole PN surface fleet.4 chinese frigates which are talwar class equivalents are going to change nothing.PN is still equal of our coast guard.

 

[vijayjha]

U r an elite

P-17 and P-15 are good ducks for PNS to practice firing.... what about Kukri? that was also far superior to anything PNS had ..Has Indian navy been able bring it out of the bottom of the ocean?[/QUOT

P-17 and P-15 are good ducks for PNS to practice firing.... what about Kukri? that was also far superior to anything PNS had ..Has Indian navy been able bring it out of the bottom of the ocean?

U are an elite member still ur post is childish.
U take pride in sinking one indian ship.
But forget that it was indian navy who imposed bloclade on karanchi port and sank many ships before bombing karanchi port that burned for a week.
Ur best submarine was also put to rest forever.
Remaining sub ran towards saudi to seek safety.
Yes you did sink one indian ship.
It was same war when a new nation was born with biggest miLitary surrender post WW2

U r an elite

P-17 and P-15 are good ducks for PNS to practice firing.... what about Kukri? that was also far superior to anything PNS had ..Has Indian navy been able bring it out of the bottom of the ocean?[/QUOT

P-17 and P-15 are good ducks for PNS to practice firing.... what about Kukri? that was also far superior to anything PNS had ..Has Indian navy been able bring it out of the bottom of the ocean?

U are an elite member still ur post is childish.
U take pride in sinking one indian ship.
But forget that it was indian navy who imposed bloclade on karanchi port and sank many ships before bombing karanchi port that burned for a week.
Ur best submarine was also put to rest forever.
Remaining sub ran towards saudi to seek safety.
Yes you did sink one indian ship.
It was same war when a new nation was born with biggest miLitary surrender post WW2

 

[HttpError]

Do you know how many PN ships we sunk in 1971 as against 1 kukri?
Each P15 Kolkata has 16 brahmos,enough for whole PN surface fleet.4 chinese frigates which are talwar class equivalents are going to change nothing.PN is still equal of our coast guard.

Claim your tities down.

 

[LKJ86]

Do you know how many PN ships we sunk in 1971 as against 1 kukri?
Each P15 Kolkata has 16 brahmos,enough for whole PN surface fleet.4 chinese frigates which are talwar class equivalents are going to change nothing.PN is still equal of our coast guard.

I have a question: Why does India choose to build P-17A frigate that is so close to P-15B destroyer?

 

[YeBeWarned]

PN is still equal of our coast guard.

relax bunny, IN is not PLAAN or USN

 

[Rafi]

This Indian is getting too big for his boots.

 

[hussain0216]

Indians are real whiners!

 

[war&peace]

Do you know how many PN ships we sunk in 1971 as against 1 kukri?
Each P15 Kolkata has 16 brahmos,enough for whole PN surface fleet.4 chinese frigates which are talwar class equivalents are going to change nothing.PN is still equal of our coast guard.

How convenient that you forgot about Dwarka and Kukri was not the only ship PNS sank...just call some to INS officer to tell you the hair raising stories of 1965 and 71 and now Dwarka was destroyed

 

[Imran Khan]

Do you know how many PN ships we sunk in 1971 as against 1 kukri?
Each P15 Kolkata has 16 brahmos,enough for whole PN surface fleet.4 chinese frigates which are talwar class equivalents are going to change nothing.PN is still equal of our coast guard.

barhmos my arse .you guys overrated that russian p serirs

 

[randomradio]

I have a question: Why does India choose to build P-17A frigate that is so close to P-15B destroyer?

IN is sanctioned to operate 15 destroyers and 24 frigates. But IN has no actual need for that many smaller sized frigates, hence the P-17 and 17A are actually destroyer-equivalent. But with the frigate designation, IN can place more orders for it compared to destroyers.

The only reason we ordered Talwar class from Russia is because we urgently needed ships back in the late 90s. Since the ship was pretty good, and demand was greater than supply, follow on orders of the Talwar class have continued.

 

[Arsalan 345]

if india is thinking about another blockade of karachi,than it's impossible.if you have brahmos than we have land based missiles with larger range than before so india should better stay away.if india enters in pakistani coast,it will be hit without having any pakistani ship in the water.this is a big advantage for pakistan.

 

[aman_rai]

None of the trolls equated them on the basis of quality...
It's just like if it's Pakistani then is superior to the things India have

barhmos my arse .you guys overrated that russian p serirs

What does Pakistan have which can be compared to brahmos other then your arse