What's new

Indian officer with UN force caught in peacekeeping row at Golan Heights

IndoCarib

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jul 12, 2011
Messages
10,784
Reaction score
-14
Country
India
Location
Antigua And Barbuda
A top Indian Lt Gen commanding the UN Disengagement Observer Force (UNDOF) -- that is currently engaged in a confrontation with the Al Nusra rebel group of Syria -- at Golan Heights, has broken his silence on major a controversy that erupted this week after the Philippine military sough a formal investigation against him for allegedly endangering the safety of its peacekeeping troops.

After reports from Manila, in which the Philippines armed forces chief alleged that Lt-Gen Iqbal Singh Singha endangered the Filipino troops by ordering them to lay down their weapons to Syrian rebels to ensure the safety of 44 Fijian peacekeepers earlier taken hostage, Singha told the India Today that both the UN and the Indian Army backed his decision that has so far not resulted in any UN casualties.

Speaking over the phone from Golan Heights, Singha said that disregarding his orders of putting down arms, the Filipino troops had endangered the lives of 44 Fijian peacekeepers who have been besieged by the rebels and are in the conflict area. "The non-professional actions of the Filipino troops have endangered the lives of the Fijian soldiers. They have defied orders at a time when we had negotiated a ceasefire with the rebels to ensure that all troops in the conflict area could exit," Singha said. The officer, who has had a vast experience of commanding troops in Kashmir and other conflict zones, added that the UN has supported his call on the issue. "The higher UN echelon as well as the Indian Army agrees with me that the decision was correct. It is an act of cowardice to desert posts especially when a delicate ceasefire was in place," the officer said. "They broke the chain of command and UN orders", he added.

Sources said that the Filipino troops disregarded the orders by the Commander to not fire for effect against the rebels and in the process killed three combatants. This has raised tempers questions against the UN troops in the area.

"We had already moved 212 Filipinos to safety. There was only one post left with 40 soldiers and we were negotiating for them too and had secured a ceasefire for the night. Military action would have resulted in casualties on both sides and that would have also affected the fate of 45 Fijians abducted earlier," the officer said.

Adding that the "UN HQ has backed me up for all decisions." Sources have also alleged that the Philippine side had been facing trouble due to indiscipline and callousness earlier with 22 of them being abducted last year in the same area after they defied orders and moved without weapons. In an incident last year, rebels had even taken two machine guns from a Philippine post.

Incidentally, Singha was appreciated by both the UN and the US State Department for his role earlier this month in securing the release of a US journalist who was kidnapped by Syrian rebels.

Besides, Singha who is commanding the mission, India has 194 soldiers under 1,250-troop UNDOF, which was established to maintain the ceasefire between Israeli and Syrian forces and supervise their disengagement. The mission has seen action lately after the Syrian civil war.
India is one of the largest contributors to the UN peacekeeping missions with 6,865 soldiers deployed in across the world.

Indian officer with UN breaks silence on peacekeeping row : Latest of the Lot, News - India Today
 
.
Fuckin' coward blaming soldiers with courage!!The only thing he should be allowed and is fit to command is a desk

he non-professional actions of the Filipino troops have endangered the lives of the Fijian soldiers
 
.
Good to see that UN is supporting the UNDOF commander Lt.general Singha.

The phillipino troops acted like complete idiots and gravely endagered the lives of Fijian soldiers by fleeing like cowards.
If the rebels suffered any significant casualties due to clashes with UN troops they could have harmed the Fijian hostages.
It was a very delicate situation.
And if the negotiations saved 212 phillipinos then there is no reason the other 40 couldn't wait a little longer.

Actually the fact that Lt.gen Singha was praised a few days back by UN and USDoS for saving lives shows he was an expert in such decisions.
 
.
Good to see that UN is supporting the UNDOF commander Lt.general Singha.

The phillipino troops acted like complete idiots and gravely endagered the lives of Fijian soldiers by fleeing like cowards.
If the rebels suffered any significant casualties due to clashes with UN troops they could have harmed the Fijian hostages.
It was a very delicate situation.
And if the negotiations saved 212 phillipinos then there is no reason the other 40 couldn't wait a little longer.

Actually the fact that Lt.gen Singha was praised a few days back by UN and USDoS for saving lives shows he was an expert in such decisions.

That man is a veteran and well experienced.
It seems, according to that article Phillipino troops are incompetent and unproffessional .
 
Last edited:
.
.
I saw few earlier posts and in other newspapers where people criticized about this action.they said "The General is coward","Spineless" bla bla bla..but they don't even know what a peace keeping mission is.those soldiers were not in Golan Heights to fight ISIS.they were there to stop any conflict between Syria and Israel and there safety is depend on UN.Fillipino Soldiers' action truly endangered the lives of other soldiers as well as their "Firefight" with ISIS means interfering with Syrian Civil War,with which they've no jurisdiction.we've seen this kind of situations time and again,where Peace Keepers got surrounded by terrorists and were told not to get engaged with them and stick to their ground,be it Rwanda,Darfur or elsewhere.

plus,they don't even know that it is Indian Force which took most casualty for UN.read this.........

The long, grim history of U.N. peacekeepers caught in the crossfire - The Washington Post
 
.
Backing the Indian official, the UN mission in a statement said, “Philippines bypassed the chain of command and the permanent representative of Philippines in UN , New York, COAS, Philippines and the erstwhile Force Commander of UNDOF, Maj General (Retired) Natalio Ecarma III (presently deputy minister in Philippines), adversely interfered in the decision making mechanics of UNDOF, jeopardising the safety of own and Fijian troops.”

“The field commander was in constant touch with the Position commanders directly and was appreciating their brave stand and exhorted them to stay calm and not aggravate the situation as efforts were ongoing for their safe passage .It may be recalled that on four occasions in the past the FC had successfully handled similar situations,” it said.

According to the note, the COS of the mission — the Filipino officer who resigned — took orders from “Manila and acted with myopic focus only on the contingent, compromising the mission planning to ensure safety of all peacekeepers irrespective of contingents”.

“These interference further deteriorated the operational capability of the Philippines contingent which after the announcement of their withdrawal from the mission in the third week of August 14, were losing interest and displayed considerable drop in performance,” it stated.

UN body backs Indian officer in stand-off with Philippines | The Indian Express
 
.
Backing the Indian official, the UN mission in a statement said, “Philippines bypassed the chain of command and the permanent representative of Philippines in UN , New York, COAS, Philippines and the erstwhile Force Commander of UNDOF, Maj General (Retired) Natalio Ecarma III (presently deputy minister in Philippines), adversely interfered in the decision making mechanics of UNDOF, jeopardising the safety of own and Fijian troops.”

“The field commander was in constant touch with the Position commanders directly and was appreciating their brave stand and exhorted them to stay calm and not aggravate the situation as efforts were ongoing for their safe passage .It may be recalled that on four occasions in the past the FC had successfully handled similar situations,” it said.

According to the note, the COS of the mission — the Filipino officer who resigned — took orders from “Manila and acted with myopic focus only on the contingent, compromising the mission planning to ensure safety of all peacekeepers irrespective of contingents”.

“These interference further deteriorated the operational capability of the Philippines contingent which after the announcement of their withdrawal from the mission in the third week of August 14, were losing interest and displayed considerable drop in performance,” it stated.

UN body backs Indian officer in stand-off with Philippines | The Indian Express
Nice you r posting that in every thread :lol:
 
.
Nice you r posting that in every thread :lol:

The decision by the Indian commander was correct as verified by UN .

They have opened multiple threads on the same topic vilifying our man , then it's our duty to defend him every single one of them .... ;)
 
.
The decision by the Indian commander was correct as verified by UN .

They have opened multiple threads on the same topic vilifying our man , then it's our duty to defend him every single one of them .... ;)
hahaha....I can see that....MOD also not interested in merging all those threads...mention some active MOD here for merger.

On Topic:- I doubt the faith and loyalty of PH soldiers to the UN mission and it's commander.
 
Last edited:
.
wow looks at the ABSENCE of barking dogs on this thread.
Every story has two sides....immature ppl jump and gun and run for conclusions.
 
.
hahaha....I can see that....MOD also not interested in merging all those threads...mention some active MOD here for merger.

On Topic:- I doubt the faith and loyalty of PH soldiers to the UN mission and it's commander.

No mods active now .
 
. .
Back
Top Bottom