What's new

India should 'fix its own caste system' before taking the knee against racism

You are assuming you can fix a social and political problem by forcing people to mate like cattle.

That's too idealistic.

If these castes minded their own business no one would have a problem.

But they own a continent-country of 1.4 billion people and oppressing/killing people following the biggest egalitarian religion in the continent because it's a threat to their caste system.

So it's everyone's problem now and we need to do whatever is necessary to liberate minorities, lower castes and Hindu women. Even if that requires authoritarian approach. Punish few for the benefit of the society at large.
 
.
That's too idealistic.

If these castes minded their own business no one would have a problem.

But they own a continent-country of 1.4 billion people and oppressing/killing people following the biggest egalitarian religion in the continent because it's a threat to their caste system.

So it's everyone's problem now and we need to do whatever is necessary to liberate minorities, lower castes and Hindu women. Even if that requires authoritarian approach. Punish few for the benefit of the society at large.
How are you going to force people to mate with each other? Can't fix human rights violation with human rights violation. You seem to think social, political, ethnic, and national problems disappear when people have minimal racial differences. Chinese Han is an example of highly homogenous people. You know how many wars they have had with tens of millions killed over the centuries.
 
. .
Your family is related by blood. How is that unnatural?

What if someone is adopted ? What if someone's family does honor killing to him or her ? Would that be natural ?

The point is to recognize and respect differences, not make everyone robotic clones of each other which is unnatural.

It is Capitalist societies where most are clones. Look at Indian society - finish a non-educating college degree ( ideally engineering ), get a wage slavery job ( ideally in some MNC like Infosys or TCS ), get married in a lavish wedding ( it shouldn't be a simple court wedding, mind you ), bear children, watch cricket, be religious to the point of obscenity, do three pilgrimages every five years, don't contribute to society positively, buy the latest cell phone, a two-wheeler or a car on loan, purchase a house on loan, get on the internet and be a religio-nationalist troll, get on the streets sometimes to "Thaali bajao Corona bhagao", support anti-humans, get your children through the same life cycle as you, die. Rinse and repeat with just the change being in technology. This is the life cycle of the clone Indian middle class and aspiring middle class. And yes, don't bother if 350,000+ Indian farmers commit suicide in just 20 years or people die of hunger and ill health just because they don't have money. And yes, you may honor kill your daughter for the usual reasons, or your daughter or son through the medium of forcing them to go through some stupid college course which neither benefits your child nor the local society nor the world. Don't demand from the government the right of the citizen to free housing, free basic food, free healthcare, free education, free electricity etc. Allow the government to waste massive economic, human and material resources on maintaining an offensive military. I could be describing any Capitalist society.

Communist China takes much pride in the Chinese identity, so nothing natural about communist theory since it is based on the denial of human rights

1. Below is Google result for "Communism" :
Communism is a philosophical, social, political and economic ideology and movement whose ultimate goal is the establishment of a communist society, namely a socioeconomic order structured upon the ideas of common ownership of the means of production and the absence of social classes, money and the state. Wikipedia
How does that deny any human rights ? In fact it brings human rights. And if you read post# 22 the Libyan political system called Jamahiriya it was really a Communist one despite it not being called so by the Libyan leadership, you will see that it was truly a democratic one. Add that with the Socialist welfare-based socio-economic system there. The Libyan system was adapted to Venezuela.

2. China is not a Communist society. What Communist society even after 70+ years of establishment would not move a bit towards abolishing economic classes and the money system, towards abolishing a party-based system and towards bringing rights to workers ? What Communist society would maintain the stock market where people are encouraged to gamble, lose money and are allowed to commit suicide by jumping into steel furnaces and off buildings ? China is a one-party Capitalist society that is as Capitalist as USA or India or Pakistan.
 
. .
Back
Top Bottom