India & Russia clash over foreign presence in Afghanistan

[roadrunner]

the thread evolves, so does the discussion.

the us cannot provide security to afghanistan, the last 10 years is evidence of it. india would be a failure before it even started. the russians alone won't be able to.

SCO otoh can, but only if the components integrate enough (it won't be through a military SCO force either).

 

[newdelhinsa]

the thread evolves, so does the discussion.

the us cannot provide security to afghanistan, the last 10 years is evidence of it. india would be a failure before it even started. the russians alone won't be able to.

SCO otoh can, but only if the components integrate enough (it won't be through a military SCO force either).

Ok.

If no one is anyone in Afghanistan then you should shut up; when blaming India for anything.
___________________________________

Whosoever sheds his blood for development of Afghanistan should have say in Afghanistan's matters; not just because someone is geographically sitting up, below, right or left. You can not screw Afghanistan for sake of bluff ( already busted ) of being a necessarily neighbor or for non existing regional brotherhood etc.

 

[roadrunner]

don't be daft. hitler would have argued the same for france's development in 1942.

 

[chaturai]

India is now uncle sam's rent boy .completely in bed with usa.

 

[SQ8]

India wants the US in Afghanistan, Russia wants it humiliated and out.
Simple conflict of interest.
India's focus is Pakistan, always has been ,will be.
Russia's focus is the US, and its historical connection to Afghanistan.

India is(for the lack of a better description) currently content being courted by the US as long as it serves India's interest.
At this point it involves getting a foothold in Afghanistan which is only possible if the US stays there.
If the US leaves before India can entrench herself, Indians in Afghanistan will find they have a very small probability of surviving in the streets.

 

[Ambitious449]

India is now uncle sam's rent boy .completely in bed with usa.

Strange. Feel jealous that we stole your violent bed partner? On the topic Russia is matured enough to understand some difference of opinions on some issues.

 

[JayAtl]

[ Scene opens for New AD on TV " Happy Days"]

Voice : "Do you sometimes think you maybe are not that smart?. Do you sometimes feel down in the dumps?"

Voice: "Don't worry come to PDF and read this thread. It will make you feel like a genius after you see posters tripping over who can hold the title of least intelligible.

Ticker flashes! : Read the article ( see that the word " Differ was changed to " Clash")

[ End Scene]