India & Russia clash over foreign presence in Afghanistan

[Nelson]

i think it shows who India has decided to ally itself with. It's the odd one out in Asia.

As per that logic, Pak has been odd one out in Asia throughout its existence since it allied itself with US. Pak even brought US in Asia and they are still present here, then they should be odd one out, as per your logic, correct?

 

[roadrunner]

asia wasn't very united in all truth before. Everyone was the odd one out.

the guy with the swasticka.. you can't be comparing a roadrunner with your avatar?

 

[foxbat]

By 'foreign military', India probably meant Indian military.

Nevvaahhh! No point growing a mango tree when you can buy mangoes Rs 50 a kg whenever you want..

 

[Nelson]

asia wasn't very united in all truth before. Everyone was the odd one out.

Okay, I'll take that. So now since everyone was odd one out, then why you wanna blame India for becoming one? Its as simple as everyone looking for its own interests.

 

[Kazhugu]

to the guy with the naked bird,

no im not comparing...just asking the question...

 

[Nelson]

to the guy with the naked bird,


no im not comparing...just asking the question...

LOL on the bold part..

 

[newdelhinsa]

i think it shows who India has decided to ally itself with. It's the odd one out in Asia.

There is no need to ally with anyone for India vis a vis Afghanistan. Russia is a no one here since they are not doing anything till date. What they are going to do in future is just a speculation. Russian objection to USA presence is just typically symbolic super power to super power correspondence nothing else, they are/should be quite happy that medieval Islamic who were assisting Chechen rebels are busy with NATO.

Russia can not do a squat since American are already there.

American presence in Afghanistan is a pyogenic sore for those who want to screw them for strategic depth.What India is trying to say to everyone even directly to USA that they should keep there presence for more longer time to deter cowards who use stateless actors to disturb Indian investments in Afghanistan. Russia has no say in Afghanistan period.

 

[isro2222]

The odd thing is that Russia is always their biggest arm supplier, bite the hand that feeds you is not wise.

Maybe this could turn into a good news for US, since India gonna switch into a Western weapon buyer.

Which country faught a war with Russia? India or china?.... Russians gave u weapons and you chinese used same weapons on russia. Forgot? It was good that russians teached china a lession in that war. About relation between india and russia is like two brothers. They argue but love each other. World knows china a snake and not dragon. China faught war with most of its neighbours. Your country really got some brain problem....

 

[roadrunner]

I think it's a little hypocritical that the Indians want to allow their influence in Afghanistan, but prevent other countries from exerting any influence. Hypocrisy never stopped indian viewpoints on here before however.

seond point is that none of your seem to understand how the relationship with afghanistan could work under sco. the indians seem to be living in a dream world it has to be said.

Security in Afghanistan is important to the Afghan people and the asian region. It won't be achieved by India or anything India can provide. India is irrelevant, the Russians know this.

 

[MUHARIB]

I think it's a little hypocritical that the Indians want to allow their influence in Afghanistan, but prevent other countries from exerting any influence. Hypocrisy never stopped indian viewpoints on here before however.

seond point is that none of your seem to understand how the relationship with afghanistan could work under sco. the indians seem to be living in a dream world it has to be said.

Security in Afghanistan is important to the Afghan people and the asian region. It won't be achieved by India or anything India can provide. India is irrelevant, the Russians know this.

Lol when did the russians say that??All they were saying is about US settling in Afghanistan.

 

[roadrunner]

are indians really this slow?

 

[MUHARIB]

are indians really this slow?

nope we just dont misinterpret.

 

[AADHAAR]

SANA news adds 'differ', Lankan ranger adds 'Clash'. SM Krishna meets Russian leader in Moscow and talk for better cooperation on Afghanistan. Over.


India, Russia to deepen cooperation on Afghanistan, IBN Live News

And then people are busy discussing an untrue "twisted" news. LOL

 

[Ambitious449]

with due respect to great Russia and it's significant contribution in our development ( and support in 1971 war) Russians must accept that India has grown immensely since 1991. There is no more big brother-little brother relationship.There bound to be some disagreement on certain issues in changing global Geo-politics. I hope Russians are smart enough to understand that. Long live Indo-Russian relationship.

 

[Nelson]

I think it's a little hypocritical that the Indians want to allow their influence in Afghanistan, but prevent other countries from exerting any influence. Hypocrisy never stopped indian viewpoints on here before however.

Oh dear god!
when did we stop anyone? There is just a difference of opinion between India and Russia. Did you even read the thread?

seond point is that none of your seem to understand how the relationship with afghanistan could work under sco. the indians seem to be living in a dream world it has to be said.

I don't think it has anything to do with this thread. I'm telling you again, please read the thread.

Security in Afghanistan is important to the Afghan people and the asian region. It won't be achieved by India or anything India can provide. India is irrelevant, the Russians know this.

This is the very reason India want US to stay, i.e. security.