What's new

India And Japan Cannot Stop China

onebyone

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jul 2, 2014
Messages
7,550
Reaction score
-6
Country
Thailand
Location
Thailand
India And Japan Cannot Stop China





Panos Mourdoukoutas , CONTRIBUTOR

Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are their own.

Photographer: Buddhika Weerasinghe/Bloomberg

India and Japan have been on a new mission lately: to tame China’s ambitions to take control of the trade routes in the Indian Ocean, encircling India in the process.

But they have difficulty in executing this mission—preventing Chinese expansion in the Indian Ocean. It may be too late, and they lack the resources.

The two countries have been holding annual meetings to boost economic and military ties, with one under way this week between Japan’s Prime Minister Shinzō Abe and India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Japan, for instance, has been helping India improve its infrastructure, and boost its nuclear capabilities. And they have been holding joint naval exercises in the Indian Ocean. Like the one in Malabar in the Bay of Bengal last year.

The Indian Ocean has always been a strategic waterway for trade between Africa and the Middle East on the one side, and Asian countries on the other. But it has grown in significance in recent years with the rise of China -- as a major trade competitor of Japan, and a challenger to America’s dominance in both the Indian Ocean and the South China Sea.


In fact, China cannot secure its dominance in the South China Sea without expanding its presence in the Indian Ocean. For a simple reason. A blockade of the Strait of Malacca by the US and its alliance will cut China off from Middle East oil supplies and from its “Second Continent” Africa.

But India and Japan have been too late in executing their mission. China already owns a key sea outpost in the Indian Ocean: Sri Lanka’s Hambantota port, which is officially belongs to China for 99 years, following the landmark agreement, which was signed recently.

And it is working feverishly with Pakistan to build an alternative route to Middle East and Africa—the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), encircling India in the process.

Besides being late, the two countries do not have the economic resources to stop China. While India’s economy grows in tandem with China, its per capita GDP is roughly one-third that of China. Japan’s per capita GDP is five times higher than China’s but its economy barely grows, floundering in the swamp of debt.


Index/Fund 12-month Performance

IShares China (FXI) 16.50%

Global X MSCI Pakistan (PAK) 12.61


iShares S&P India 50 (INDY) -5.30

Source: Finance.yahoo.com 9/14/2017

https://www.forbes.com/sites/panosm...dia-and-japan-cannot-stop-china/#6a216d355540
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
India And Japan Cannot Stop China


960x0.jpg


India and Japan have been on a new mission lately: to tame China’s ambitions to take control of the trade routes in the Indian Ocean, encircling India in the process.

But they have difficulty in executing this mission—preventing Chinese expansion in the Indian Ocean. It may be too late, and they lack the resources.

The two countries have been holding annual meetings to boost economic and military ties, with one under way this week between Japan’s Prime Minister Shinzō Abe and India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Japan, for instance, has been helping India improve its infrastructure, and boost its nuclear capabilities. And they have been holding joint naval exercises in the Indian Ocean. Like the one in Malabar in the Bay of Bengal last year.

The Indian Ocean has always been a strategic waterway for trade between Africa and the Middle East on the one side, and Asian countries on the other. But it has grown in significance in recent years with the rise of China -- as a major trade competitor of Japan, and a challenger to America’s dominance in both the Indian Ocean and the South China Sea.





In fact, China cannot secure its dominance in the South China Sea without expanding its presence in the Indian Ocean. For a simple reason. A blockade of the Strait of Malacca by the US and its alliance will cut China off from Middle East oil supplies and from its “Second Continent” Africa.

But India and Japan have been too late in executing their mission. China already owns a key sea outpost in the Indian Ocean: Sri Lanka’s Hambantota port, which is officially belongs to China for 99 years, following the landmark agreement, which was signed recently.


And it is working feverishly with Pakistan to build an alternative route to Middle East and Africa—the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), encircling India in the process.

Besides being late, the two countries do not have the economic resources to stop China. While India’s economy grows in tandem with China, its per capita GDP is roughly one-third that of China. Japan’s per capita GDP is five times higher than China’s but its economy barely grows, floundering in the swamp of debt.

Unless, they devise a smart strategy to tame China’s expansionary ambitions.

Meanwhile, international investors should pay close attention to these developments, as they place their bets in the financial markets of the region.

Index/Fund 12-month Performance
IShares China (FXI) 16.50%
Global X MSCI Pakistan (PAK) 12.61
iShares S&P India 50 (INDY)
-5.30
Source: Finance.yahoo.com 9/14/2017

https://www.forbes.com/sites/panosm...dia-and-japan-cannot-stop-china/#36e081e25540

Of course India and Japan cannot stop CPEC.

CPEC will define the new politics of Asia.

I see Japan is an enemy of China. I want to see what Chinese members think of Japan

Thanks.
 
. . .
I would like to hear what the Chinese members think of Japan.

Please educate me.

Indeed Japan is not a strong nation as it used to be.
But they can issue some statements against xYz, AbC etc. at a moment's notice!!!!
 
.
I heard that Japan will build high speed train in India. I'm really happy China was not chosen by India. I doubt India can handle such complicated system like high speed train. It's very possible Indians will mess it up. Made in Japan's reputation will be ruined by the failed project.

 
Last edited:
.
I would like to hear what the Chinese members think of Japan.

Please educate me.

Indeed Japan is not a strong nation as it used to be.
Enemy is a strong word, i would not go that far as we are not at war with each other. There are Japanese who prefer closer ties with China while others favors US. Japan has no independent foreign policy as a lapdog so naturally it will follow US orders. But i'm sure Japan also realizes it has no muscle to take on China, it would be very stupid to do so. Many elements are stacked against Japan. As for molding some secret plan with India in containing China, that's not gonna work. With the HSR project in India, Japan is milking the cash cow :D as a true vulture.
 
.
Enemy is a strong word, i would not go that far as we are not at war with each other. There are Japanese who prefer closer ties with China while others favors US. Japan has no independent foreign policy as a lapdog so naturally it will follow US orders. But i'm sure Japan also realizes it has no muscle to take on China, it would be very stupid to do so. Many elements are stacked against Japan. As for molding some secret plan with India in containing China, that's not gonna work. With the HSR project in India, Japan is milking the cash cow :D as a true vulture.
In the term of anti-China acts, Japan is not just US follower. In fact Japan is more active than US. Cause Japan is the one who fears China's rise most. Not just for geopolitics reasons. Also for the historical reasons. Japanese are clearly aware that how brutally they treated Chinese people during Sino-Japan war. They know Chinese have never forgot that.
 
. .
I heard that Japan will build high speed train in India. I'm really happy China was not chosen by India. I doubt India can handle such complicated system like high speed train. It's very possible Indians will mess it up. Made in Japan's reputation will be ruined for the failed project.

You are right India will mess it up just like it messed up its metro rail and space programs.
Japanese should learn from Chinese Rail projects in Pakistan.
 
. . .

A legend of India goes like this:
Back in the British colonial days, an English man traveled to India. Stunned by the utterly disgusting condition of the country and he wrote: God I hate you! We already have hell, why do you still give us India?!

Well, the dude would've been grateful to his mighty god had lived to see the modern day India that has gone even worse!:omghaha:
 
. .
They ( US + Japan + India + UK + Australia + Sweden, ... ) believe that combined, they can STOP and Ruin CHN back to the stone age.
If they can stop a nuclear armed N.Korea, then talk stop China ... U.S today is not the G1 country in 1990s, ppl should accept the truth ... if they really wanna stop China first stop doing business with China, if above alliance still trading with China and can't leave Chinese market ... it can't stop China but help China stronger ... if one day RMB internationalization, Chinese casch become the widely used International Monetary Exchanges between above alliance and China ... N.o2 will replace the N.o1 just like it ever happened in human history, after China into the WTO they can't leave us, BeiJing thanks to Bill Clinton.

Now China is the world N.o2, BeiJing is fighting our war of RMB internationalization to the whole world.
 
Last edited:
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom