Happen to come across this vlog: Malaysian Malay student's travelling vlog in Xinjiang

[PeacefulWar]

@Indos @fisher1 Like I mentioned weeks back, if you really interested know to what's the situation in Xinjiang and it's people, other than just want to hate.
You can always find clues in the face expressions from people on street and have your own conclusion.

These Malay students apparently are free to travel and record in Xinjiang.
Do it look like the atmosphere you can find in region that "3 million" people are locked up and " ethnic cleansing"?

 

[fisher1]

Nice propaganda video.

1. Hides her sub count. Totally legit
2. No mosques.
3. Nothing Muslim like in the video, feels like an atheist city.
4. She admits to getting asked to remove hijab by the police because they thought she was Uighur but OK because she's not Chinese. Imagine where she would have end up if she was Uighur in hijab

5. Atiqah Henderson Hahahaaa

It's proven. Every Islamic scholar is a liar because an unknown pathetic who hides her subs filmed a street in China

 

[PeacefulWar]

4. She admits to getting asked to remove hijab by the police because they thought she was Uighur but OK because she's not Chinese. Imagine where she would have end up if she was Uighur in hijab

View attachment 665519

She said the police tot her friend is Han Chinese but she explained she is Malaysian Chinese.

3. Nothing Muslim like in the video, feels like an atheist city.

Good to know what's your true thought and motivation.

I'm done here.

 

[Indos]

4. She admits to getting asked to remove hijab by the police because they thought she was Uighur but OK because she's not Chinese. Imagine where she would have end up if she was Uighur in hijab

View attachment 665519

It's proven. Every Islamic scholar is a liar because an unknown pathetic who hides her subs filmed a street in China

Yup, look like Uigyur women is not allowed to wear hijab.

 

[PeacefulWar]

Yup, look like Uigyur women is not allowed to wear hijab.

Not just Uigyur women, Arabic style hajib are banned in China I believe.
If I remember correctly China Gov started a compaign a few years ago to encourage Muslim women to were their transitional headscarf instead of the Arabic style hajib which is introduced along with Arab's religion push in 90s and early 2000s.
To counter Arabic religion influence obviously.

You should be familiar with this Arab's religion transformation as I read news before regards how they transformed Malay's transitional dressing to Arab dressing in past few decades.
I assume same thing happened in Indonesia?

 

[Indos]

Not just Uigyur women, Arabic style hajib are banned in China I believe.
If I remember correctly China Gov started a compaign a few years ago to encourage Muslim women to were their transitional headscarf instead of the Arabic style hajib which is introduced along with Arab's religion push in 90s and early 2000s.
To counter Arabic religion influence obviously.

You should be familiar with this Arab's religion transformation as I read news before regards how they transformed Malay's transitional dressing to Arab dressing in past few decades.
I assume same thing happened in Indonesia?

I dont think it is fair to say it as an Arab dressing since hijab obligation for women is stated in Quran. Even you can see Christian nun also wear hijab, it is part of Abrahamic religion (Jews, Christian, Islam).

Yup, majority of Indonesian women wear hijab and even some minority wear niqab where only eyes that can be seen.

Despite so Indonesian are relatively moderate and the hijab they wear are in color, not just black like being seen in Saudi and several Arab states.

MRT Jakarta, Lebak Bulus station

Wearing hijab also dont make women less beautiful

 

[beijingwalker]

Hijabs are banned in central Asian countries like Kazakhstan, but not China. In Beijing, many Mulsim women working in Halal restaurants wear Hijabs.

 

[S10]

Hijabs are not banned in China. The halal restaurants in Guangzhou often have Hui women working as waitresses.

 

[PeacefulWar]

I dont think it is fair to say it as an Arab dressing since hijab obligation for women is stated in Quran. Even you can see Christian nun also wear hijab, it is part of Abrahamic religion (Jews, Christian, Islam).

We are talking different things.
I won't discuss Quran as I don't know much.
But wearing hijab world wide is the result of the Arab's push from mid 90s.

And obviously your country man don't agree with you.

Kebaya vs hijab: Questioning Indonesian identity

ON Thursday, Yogyakarta, Indonesia, hosted a Kebaya Festival, reportedly involving 2,000 women. It followed limited displays of women deliberately wearing kebaya in their daily activities, to assert their Indonesian identity including that of many who voluntarily wear the hijab.

www.thestar.com.my

"Kebaya vs hijab: Questioning Indonesian identity"


Marina Mahathir: Malaysia undergoing ‘Arab colonialism’

Marina Mahathir: Malaysia undergoing ‘Arab colonialism’

KUALA LUMPUR, May 23 — Datin Paduka Marina Mahathir has criticised the “Arabisation” of Islam in Malaysia amid the institutionalisation and growing conservatism of the...

www.malaymail.com

 

[Indos]

We are talking different things.
I won't discuss Quran as I don't know much.
But wearing hijab world wide is the result of the Arab's push from mid 90s.

And obviously your country man don't agree with you.

Kebaya vs hijab: Questioning Indonesian identity

ON Thursday, Yogyakarta, Indonesia, hosted a Kebaya Festival, reportedly involving 2,000 women. It followed limited displays of women deliberately wearing kebaya in their daily activities, to assert their Indonesian identity including that of many who voluntarily wear the hijab.

www.thestar.com.my

"Kebaya vs hijab: Questioning Indonesian identity"


Marina Mahathir: Malaysia undergoing ‘Arab colonialism’

Marina Mahathir: Malaysia undergoing ‘Arab colonialism’

KUALA LUMPUR, May 23 — Datin Paduka Marina Mahathir has criticised the “Arabisation” of Islam in Malaysia amid the institutionalisation and growing conservatism of the...

www.malaymail.com

That publication is from Malaysia and probably own by Chinese Malaysian and the writer is Chinese ethnic and definately not Indonesian (very rare Chinese Indonesian use Chinese name).

There is no clash between Hijab and Kebaya, traditional Melayu and Javanese dress, in Indonesia. People in here just combine it.

Hijab Kebaya

Majority women in Indonesia are working, including 2 of my sisters, and they can actually choose whether to use modern Hijab or more traditional Hijab. Many people say Indonesia has become one of the trendsetter in hijab, so people cannot say we are just following Arab country.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Just see how my own relative use hijab in different situation

It is when she was in Japan.

 

[PeacefulWar]

That publication is from Malaysia and probably own by Chinese Malaysian and the writer is Chinese ethnic and definately not Indonesian (very rare Chinese Indonesian use Chinese name).

There is no clash between Hijab and Kebaya, traditional Melayu and Javanese dress, in Indonesia. People in here just combine it.

Hijab Kebaya

The author is Indonesian and the name is not Chinese name.
The second link is from Malay people. Chinese ethics obviously don't have opinion on these. Why they care?

But that's doesn't matter and you are talking different things again.
I have not opinion what your woman want to wear.

I just pointed out wearing Hijab is a recent thing - started from 90s with Arab's religion push globally.
No one/many wear hijab outside of Arab before.
Traditional Uyghur headscarf is like this:

Traditional Hui Muslim headscarf:

Whether you prefer traditional headscarf or Hijab is out of context.


Also as point out by @S10 and @beijingwalker , seems hijab is not banned in whole China, only banned in Xinjiang due to extremist/separatist movement(I'm not sure about this as well, as I last saw the news is "new law" ban hijab in public service org and government in Xinjiang).

 

[Nan Yang]

Love Indonesia. Love Malaysia.

Hate China.

Dr Mahathir forbade me from wearing hijab, says Dr Siti Hasmah

Dr Mahathir forbade me from wearing hijab, says Dr Siti Hasmah | The Malaysian Insight

She says she wanted to wear it after returning from Mecca, but the former prime minister did not like it.

www.themalaysianinsight.com

 

[Shehr Abbasi]

Dr Mahathir forbade me from wearing hijab, says Dr Siti Hasmah

Dr Mahathir forbade me from wearing hijab, says Dr Siti Hasmah | The Malaysian Insight

She says she wanted to wear it after returning from Mecca, but the former prime minister did not like it.

www.themalaysianinsight.com

And your point?

 

[Nan Yang]

And your point?

Not scoring points. Just sharing an news article. That is all. Have a nice day

 

[Shehr Abbasi]

Not scoring points. Just sharing an news article. That is all. Have a nice day

I dont want your news articles.