TaiShang
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Apr 30, 2014
- Messages
- 27,848
- Reaction score
- 70
- Country
- Location
Government cannot be market’s babysitter
2015-7-4 0:33:01
Chinese stocks tumbled again on Friday, with the Shanghai Composite Index falling 5.77 percent to below 3,700 points. A-share stocks have plummeted nearly 30 percent in the past three weeks. Huge losses have been inflicted on many individual investors who had recently entered the market.
The government has been sending out strong messages that it will bail out the market over the past few days. But given the ongoing free-fall, the government's power seems to be not as great as previously expected.
It only proves that no one can effectively control the stock market. Too many forces are at work in the gigantic Chinese market, which has resulted in great unpredictability.
Voices that call for government interference have been emerging over the past few days. But a market is a market, and people's emotional cries may not be able to play a decisive role in influencing the course of events.
The fundamental reason behind the market meltdown lies in the bubble caused by its unusual surge. The government may be able to calm people down through strong interventionist measures. But the speculative bubbles are unlikely to be properly digested.
Some investors have insisted that the government is the one who can least tolerate a market stumble, and therefore it will definitely take action before the market gets even worse. Such expectations are one of the reasons the market often goes out of control - its own self-adjustment capability has become sluggish.
We believe the government's management of the stock market should be based on market measures that are consistent with international practices. The government will not be able to babysit the market forever.
The fluctuations of China's stock market are not because it is overly mature, but because it is too rudimentary and unable to cope with excessive speculation. A series of problems have been exposed by the recent sharp price drops, such as some listed companies' executives collectively selling their shares, or investors' illegal use of marginal selling leverages.
Of course, if the market shows signs of getting out of control, the government will have to resolutely step in.
The current plunge has not hurt China's financial system, nor its basic economic operations. Most investors who entered the market before March are able to sustain the losses caused by the recent fluctuations. They have not lost hope, they are still biding their time.
The future of China's stock market lies in further marketization, not a "policy bull." The authorities should crack down on the manipulations that upset the market, and make the market a place for fair play.
2015-7-4 0:33:01
Chinese stocks tumbled again on Friday, with the Shanghai Composite Index falling 5.77 percent to below 3,700 points. A-share stocks have plummeted nearly 30 percent in the past three weeks. Huge losses have been inflicted on many individual investors who had recently entered the market.
The government has been sending out strong messages that it will bail out the market over the past few days. But given the ongoing free-fall, the government's power seems to be not as great as previously expected.
It only proves that no one can effectively control the stock market. Too many forces are at work in the gigantic Chinese market, which has resulted in great unpredictability.
Voices that call for government interference have been emerging over the past few days. But a market is a market, and people's emotional cries may not be able to play a decisive role in influencing the course of events.
The fundamental reason behind the market meltdown lies in the bubble caused by its unusual surge. The government may be able to calm people down through strong interventionist measures. But the speculative bubbles are unlikely to be properly digested.
Some investors have insisted that the government is the one who can least tolerate a market stumble, and therefore it will definitely take action before the market gets even worse. Such expectations are one of the reasons the market often goes out of control - its own self-adjustment capability has become sluggish.
We believe the government's management of the stock market should be based on market measures that are consistent with international practices. The government will not be able to babysit the market forever.
The fluctuations of China's stock market are not because it is overly mature, but because it is too rudimentary and unable to cope with excessive speculation. A series of problems have been exposed by the recent sharp price drops, such as some listed companies' executives collectively selling their shares, or investors' illegal use of marginal selling leverages.
Of course, if the market shows signs of getting out of control, the government will have to resolutely step in.
The current plunge has not hurt China's financial system, nor its basic economic operations. Most investors who entered the market before March are able to sustain the losses caused by the recent fluctuations. They have not lost hope, they are still biding their time.
The future of China's stock market lies in further marketization, not a "policy bull." The authorities should crack down on the manipulations that upset the market, and make the market a place for fair play.
