GDP per capita of Kashmir India Comparison With Xinjiang China -

[The BrOkEn HeArT]

GDP per capita in Kashmir in India is 1342 USD
GDP per capita in Xinjiang in China is 7868 USD.
GDP per capita in Indonesia the biggest Muslim country in the world is 4256 USD
GDP per capita in Turkey the most advance Muslim country in the world is 9327 USD

Conclusion Muslim in Xinjiang earns 5.86X of Muslim in Kashmir.
Muslim in Xinjiang earns almost the amount of Turkey , 1132 USD different.
How bad the condition in Xinjiang? China Muslims is 6 times richer than India Muslim.

List of Indian states and union territories by GDP per capita - Wikipedia
List of Chinese administrative divisions by GDP per capita - Wikipedia

They can practice their faith in Xinjiang as they practice in Kashmir?
Freedom is more valuable than money.

 

[beijingwalker]

Xin Jiang is just a province, better compare it to Jakarta which has 10 million population (Jakarta is considered as Province as well with its own Governor)

Xin Jiang GDP percapita 7868 USD
Jakarta GDP percapita is 19030 USD

Jakarta is a city, like Sheznzhen, has over 10 million, GDP percapita 22,845 USD

 

[Indos]

Jakarta is a city, like Sheznzhen, has over 10 million, GDP percapita 22,845 USD

City has Major as their leader but province has Governor as their leader. It is considered as Province in Indonesia.

Governor of Jakarta - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

 

[beijingwalker]

City has Major as their leader but province has Governor as their leader. It is considered as Province in Indonesia.

Governor of Jakarta - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

You can't compare a city with continent size vast region with massive deserts, mountains chains, and uninhabitable barren lands, cities should be compared with cities.

 

[jamahir]

@Goenitz, I am sleepy now. Am logging-off. Will reply tomorrow.

 

[Place Of Space]

They can practice their faith in Xinjiang as they practice in Kashmir?
Freedom is more valuable than money.

Indians from its root have least freedom, the most miserable society in the world.
Brahmin give birth to brahmin, dalit is still dalit since he was born.

 

[The BrOkEn HeArT]

Indians from its root have least freedom, the most miserable society in the world.
Brahmin give birth to brahmin, dalit is still dalit since he was born.

I pity on you the way you have been brainwashed. Get real education.

 

[Globenim]

Khotan prefecture bordering GB/Kashmir, the only prefecture that is > 90% Uyghur, has a GDP of USD 1800 only ... Even Kasghar prefecture has a GDP of 3000 USD

In April 2019, the officially reported stats were 1800 USD (and a 7.5% growth). You are saying that it has grown over 100% in one year. Highly unlikely

The April 2019 report is for data from 2018 not 2019
2018 to 2020 is not one year
The per capita GDP growth from 2017 to 2018 wasnt 7.5% but 13%
The per capita GDP growth rates own growth rate from 2017 to 2018 was 44%
You rounded USD 1868 from RMB 12094 at today exchange rates down to 1800
Going from 1800 to 3361 is not grown over 100%
Going from 1868 to 3361 is not grown over 100%

Wtf are you trying to prove here?

 

[Globenim]

It is considered as Province in Indonesia.

So you know your "better comparision" is actually a bad, worse and just disingenuous apples and oranges comparison and your justification is really just local semantics?

 

[jamahir]

@jamahir
I know, that in caste/class system, you need some socialism, but I fear the same thing as the above post. You can give basic education, food, shelter on income bases, but not jobs, higher education etc. Only merit can result in development afterwards.

Even the middle class in India don't have it good. My family has to pay an annual house tax of about 3500 rupees and also something called road tax.

I agree that merit should be the criteria for promotion in jobs but free high-quality education for all up till all levels will ensure that everyone will have an equal ground to reach a standard base in employment.

I pity on you the way you have been brainwashed. Get real education.

Unfortunately what @Place Of Space said about Indian society is true. Didn't the Dalit student Rohith Vemula commit suicide not too long ago, in 2016, because he was harassed by Upper Caste university officials and further lack of help from the central government ?

The socio-economic culture in India is quite oppressive and this is indicated by things like student suicides, honor killings and farmer suicides.

 

[Goenitz]

I agree that merit should be the criteria for promotion in jobs but free high-quality education for all up till all levels will ensure that everyone will have an equal ground to reach a standard base in employment.

Do you think it is a trap? Bcz to excel in technology, you need merit and expertise.
So let's say, in 30 years, all the caste system is eradicated and all the Indians have basics rights. Then Indian can move towards a highly skilled manufacturing nation.

Or

You think even with quota and social system, India can reach a highly advanced society.

Idk about japan/S.Korea, but none of the western govt is socialist in nature and modern/developed at the same time. Like Italy, advanced in technology but in debt, due to subsidising (education, transport, health, etc)

UK only subsidise health not higher education (HE) nor transport or housing etc. Germany subsidise HE for all but I think they tax the rich heavily. I am sure about NL, that their taxation rate is very high, higher than UK.

Now compared to US, where everything comes with the hefty price. You have to be on your toes, to get education. health, house, etc. So, one cannot get lazy. At the mean time, it is very advanced in innovation, technology, and research.

So my questions is, how to transit from welfare to capitalism. Or a country can progress to a high tech manufacturing society even with a heavy welfare/subsidy/quota system.
@Hamartia Antidote

 

[jamahir]

Do you think it is a trap? Bcz to excel in technology, you need merit and expertise.

Sure but how to judge merit and expertise ? Cannot be through highly competitive exams and here I will bring a favorite example of mine : Every year 160,000+ computer engineers graduate from Indian colleges and this has been so for at least the last 20 years, so there are at least 3 million Indian computer engineers within India and sited outside of India, yet this huge number of computer engineers have not devised even one locally-designed variety of the two fundamental elements in a classic computer : the microprocessor and the operating system. How can this failure be ? In India most people take exams very seriously and college atmosphere is very competitive and some students commit suicide because of this competition. For example, search for suicides in Kota town. Kota is notorious for having coaching centers which "coach" students for sitting in exams in the supposedly prestigious colleges in India, and some of these students commit suicide in Kota even before reaching the steps of an actual college. So again I ask, how does one judge merit and expertise ?

Though in the space business, in recent years there have come up a few private spacecraft development companies in India. I will name three : Skyroot Aerospace, Agnikul Cosmos and Bellatrix Aerospace. At the moment they are developing rockets that can launch small satellites and I hope they will in a decade become capable of launching and transporting humans, even to Mars.

So let's say, in 30 years, all the caste system is eradicated and all the Indians have basics rights. Then Indian can move towards a highly skilled manufacturing nation.

Or

You think even with quota and social system, India can reach a highly advanced society.

1. I don't know if the call for change will come from within India's masses, especially the so-called educated middle class. The quota system for the socially deprived has existed for seven decades yet the Dalits are discriminated against even today. I will make note that a lot the Indian middle class is quite regressive which manifests in things like many Hindus supporting Hindutvad and many Muslims supporting the Tablighi Jamaat and burqa, and this regressiveness has grown with the advancement in the last 20 years of better access to "education" and communication.

2. In 30 years the space industry will cause political, social and economic change in this world including in India.

3. The progressives in India have to use the platform of technology to effect the changes. By hook and crook.

Idk about japan/S.Korea, but none of the western govt is socialist in nature and modern/developed at the same time. Like Italy, advanced in technology but in debt, due to subsidising (education, transport, health, etc)

UK only subsidise health not higher education (HE) nor transport or housing etc. Germany subsidise HE for all but I think they tax the rich heavily. I am sure about NL, that their taxation rate is very high, higher than UK.

The things you mentioned I got to know from you and what I do know about Europe / West is that last year Spain nationalized all private clinics and hospitals and made healthcare free and universal for its citizens.

Now compared to US, where everything comes with the hefty price. You have to be on your toes, to get education. health, house, etc. So, one cannot get lazy.

It is ironical that USA's military budget just for 2020-21 is 934 billion dollars and it has problems in housing, healthcare etc but it has gone around the world destroying progressive / welfare-state countries which provided free healthcare, education, housing etc.

At the mean time, it is very advanced in innovation, technology, and research.

I think that comes out of the USA being a settler society where practical technologies, advancements and collaborations were enabled without the burden of community and family history, and this enabled people like Thomas Alva Edison, Bill Gates, Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk. In India it is difficult for a middle class person to become an entrepreneur or a musician as that person's family will be the first roadblock, citing that "Oh we have no family history in business or music". It is rare, happens but rare, for middle class people to do anything but the traditional middle class careering.

So my questions is, how to transit from welfare to capitalism. Or a country can progress to a high tech manufacturing society even with a heavy welfare/subsidy/quota system.
@Hamartia Antidote

The USSR was a welfare-state system and it was highly advanced and a manufacturing society.

 

[beijingwalker]

Wow good close to Turkey. Love to see my Muslim brother in Xinjiang is having a well off life. Way to go another 3000 USD increment will put them also at par with Malaysia GDP per capita. Insyaallah. - means may GOD permit.

Xinjiang's GDP per capita reached 6,8526 yuan( $10,220) in 2022, it's the same of Turkey's if not more

Turkey's GDP per capita is around $10,000 in 2022

Türkiye sees lower inflation, larger GDP per capita in 2023

Treasury and Finance Minister Nureddin Nebati on Monday said the government would continue to pursue policies that prioritize economic growth and jobs in...

www.dailysabah.com

 

[beijingwalker]

Xinjiang also borders Afghanistan,, GDP per capita in Afghanistann is $368. Xinjiang's GDP per capita is over 27 times of this next door neighbor

 

[retaxis]

In Kashmir you can not speak ill of hindus or the military will shoot you so you have to live in slums with no future instead. India is definitely an apartheid state where the poor minorities have no rights and routinely killed by the majority. NATO should invade India and break it up and free all the minorities/NE India from low IQ indian rule.