What's new

Chinese army faces flak over swift Nepal evacuation by Indian military

thesolar65

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jul 3, 2012
Messages
4,922
Reaction score
-12
Country
India
Location
India
The Indian military's swift evacuation of thousands of Indians from quake-hit Nepal has put China's PLA on the defensive with questions raised as to why its efforts to rescue stranded Chinese nationals did not match that of India.

The media here has questioned why air force planes were not deployed to airlift over 8,000 Chinese many of whom are still stranded in Nepal.

In a rare comparison of India's military with the People's Liberation Army (PLA), the world's largest, Chinese defence spokesman Geng Yansheng was on Thursday confronted with the question at a briefing as to why the military did not use planes to airlift stranded Chinese when India had done so to ferry its nationals. There is considerable annoyance in China over the slow process of airlifting of Chinese tourists as well as workers employed in various Beijing-funded projects in Nepal as the task was given to a number of civilian airlines. There were also reports of some of the airline companies demanding heavy fare which was subsequently denied.

Besides airlifting thousands of its citizens, the Indian Air Force also transported about 170 foreign nationals from 15 countries to India. Several others were also transported through special buses from across the border to Bihar.

Defending the move to use civilian aircraft, Geng said "Whether to use military aircraft to transport people from a disaster area this is to be decided by various factors".

He said after the earthquake, the Chinese government had organised a number of civilian commercial flights to evacuate Chinese citizens stranded in Nepal. He said soon after the quake, three helicopters from Tibet flew food and water to a number of Chinese employees working on a hydro project and some of them were even airlifted.

India's quick response to send search and rescue teams besides relief supplies has been reported by sections of the Chinese media while China too dispatched rescue teams and planes with supplies by which time the Indian presence on the ground had swelled.

Earlier, the Chinese foreign ministry played down reports of competition with India to assist quake-hit Nepal and offered to work with New Delhi "positively" in the relief efforts to help the Himalayan nation overcome the crisis.

"China and India are neighbours to Nepal. We would like to work together and coordinate positively with India in our assistance efforts in Nepal to help it to overcome the difficulties and rebuild its homeland," Chinese foreign ministry spokesman Hong Lei said on Tuesday.

Chinese army faces flak over swift Nepal evacuation by Indian military | Latest News & Updates at Daily News & Analysis
 
.
India's proximity to Nepal made the evacuation possible. India also helped Chinese nationals who are stranded in Nepal.

There is no competition in rescue efforts, if a nation is better poised for relief efforts because of proximity and quick response it is better to take the help of that nation.
 
.
I don't think China cares for Nepal as much as India does. they have barely given any substantial aid compared to smaller poorer countries :o:

you would think this would be a good PR opportunity to flex it's muscles and show how charitable they can be :agree:

just like with the Philippine Typhoon China just shows how much it cares....not much
 
.
I don't think China cares for Nepal as much as India does. they have barely given any substantial aid compared to smaller poorer countries :o:

you would think this would be a good PR opportunity to flex it's muscles and show how charitable they can be :agree:

just like with the Philippine Typhoon China just shows how much it cares....not much



Chinese are pure businessman.

On topic :India has geographical advantage compared to China.
This is a humanitarian issue not a competition.
Even US will face issues in situations like this.
 
.
Chinese are pure businessman.

On topic :India has geographical advantage compared to China.
This is a humanitarian issue not a competition.
Even US will face issues in situations like this.


true, but I just can't see how a country that wants to be the big guy on the block can give so little.


will the AIIB and other banks from China lend to Nepal so they can rebuild?? though I doubt they could pay them back anytime soon.
 
.
true, but I just can't see how a country that wants to be the big guy on the block can give so little.


will the AIIB and other banks from China lend to Nepal so they can rebuild?? though I doubt they could pay them back anytime soon.


Chinese will only invest in businesses that having profit.Humanitarian is not a dept of China.Look at the pattern of their investment in Pakistan and response in Nepal .For them humanitarian effort is a loss.
AIIB will take time.
 
.
China never donates much to any country. They are very shrewd and money minded people.
 
.
China never donates much to any country. They are very shrewd and money minded people.

China donates far more than any Western country did at the same period of development.

Chinese will only invest in businesses that having profit.Humanitarian is not a dept of China.Look at the pattern of their investment in Pakistan and response in Nepal .For them humanitarian effort is a loss.
AIIB will take time.

Clueless. This is on top of grant aid exceeding $100 million a year to Nepal. Indians are internationally maligned as being miserly, so you'd best not talk. Especially not at a time like this.
 
.
Actually, the earthquake disrupted roads in Tibetan region. The Chinese troops can only reach Nepal through Tibet after the repairs are done. Of course, the alternative is marching the Chinese army through India to reach Nepal, I don't need to explain why that is not happening.
 
.
I don't think China cares for Nepal as much as India does. they have barely given any substantial aid compared to smaller poorer countries :o:

you would think this would be a good PR opportunity to flex it's muscles and show how charitable they can be :agree:

just like with the Philippine Typhoon China just shows how much it cares....not much
china has donated 20millionRMB,how much usa did?

Chinese will only invest in businesses that having profit.Humanitarian is not a dept of China.Look at the pattern of their investment in Pakistan and response in Nepal .For them humanitarian effort is a loss.
AIIB will take time.
you indian blabla, since when you indian have taken the high moral ground?show some mercies for you countrymen who are suffering the most miseries on the planet.
 
.
China donates far more than any Western country did at the same period of development.



Clueless. This is on top of grant aid exceeding $100 million a year to Nepal. Indians are internationally maligned as being miserly, so you'd best not talk. Especially not at a time like this.



Dont measure us with your boasting stupidity which is only successful in intimidating poor small SCS nation.
Your image is very good internationally and your allies Pakistan and NK has more reputation than that .:sarcastic:

So you should nt talk about it.

china has donated 20millionRMB,how much usa did?


you indian blabla, since when you indian have taken the high moral ground?show some mercies for you countrymen who are suffering the most miseries on the planet.



US donated 10 million $.

Of Course we have high moral ground.We will give food to the poors and refugees even if dont have any thing to eat.

Shall I post the links of the contribution of the great China to Philipines when they suffered a great natural calamity ?
 
.
Indians sure are tasteless to make the plight of some people into some sort of political competition and even undermine, dismiss or deny the substantial aid provided even at this moment to the victims by their "sworn enemies".

And all of them react like primitives in the same accord, even the falseflagger. What a worthless country.
 
.
... Of course, the alternative is marching the Chinese army through India to reach Nepal, I don't need to explain why that is not happening.


:raise: is that because India's roads are packed with Indians answering nature's calls, which will slow PLA down?
 
. .
Except your own.

Sometimes, yes. Even poor people gathered money to send aid to Nepal. One doesn't have to be ultra rich with three trillion USD in foreign reserve to lend a helping hand. It's the intent that matters.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom