What's new

China trade sanctions 'failing to cripple Australian economy'

Vanguard One

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Dec 20, 2019
Messages
1,307
Reaction score
-7
Country
Ireland
Location
Ireland
1618282700886.png


While Chinese trade sanctions have cost Australian exporters millions of dollars, the impact on businesses is far from crippling, according to one expert.

Trade to China across the affected commodities, including barley, beef and coal, has dropped by 78 per cent.

Sanctions were imposed on Australian exporters after relations between Beijing and Canberra plummeted over the last year.

1618282399039.png

Chinese trade sanctions against Australian exports have not had the devastating effect many anticipated, a think tank said. (Nine)


They came after Australia called for an international investigation into the origins of the coronavirus pandemic and the Federal Government introduced foreign interference legislation.

But Lowy Institute lead economist Roland Rajah said the tariffs and other sanctions against Australian exports started last year amid the COVID-19 pandemic which "significantly clouds the picture".

His analysis suggests the Australian economy has to date "dodged a bullet".

"It would seem the impact has in fact been quite limited," Mr Rajah said.

"Exports to China have predictably collapsed in the areas hit by sanctions, but most of this lost trade seems to have found other markets."

Industries targeted by Beijing - including beef, seafood, timber, barley, coal, and wine - totalled about $29 billion in 2019.

The total value of these exports to China in the three months to January 2021 was about $5.5 billion a year - a huge decline.

1618282458375.png

The Australian coal industry has been able to find alternative export markets to China. (AP)


But exporters haven't actually lost the almost $20 billion remaining in annual exports, Mr Rajah said.

"First, one must disentangle the effect of the sanctions from many other factors, including the pandemic," he said.

"Second, a fair bit of trade diversion should be expected, with global trade shuffled around as China replaces Australian imports with other sources and Australian exports shift to other markets, with some impact on prices."

Beijing's policy of targeting products that would have limited effects on its own economy - with other suppliers available - also helped Australian exporters find alternative buyers for the affected commodities.

"This reshuffling of global trade is precisely the reason the damage inflicted on Australia has been limited," Mr Rajah said.

1618282497316.png

The Australian wine industry has been hit hard by Chinese tariffs in its most valuable export market. (Getty)


He highlighted coal exports to China, which fell by $6 billion, as one example of successful diversification.
Australia's coal exports to other countries increased by $9.5 billion in annualised terms.

But wine has been unable to find a long term alternative market to the prized China market.

Last month Chinese authorities confirmed they were extending tariffs on Australia wine exports for another five years.

China has maintained the taxes - expected to be up to 220 per cent - were an anti-dumping measure.

Wine exports had dropped to less than $1 million in January, from a high of $164 million last October.

Total beef exports also declined but this is more of a reflection of supply issues after years of drought.


All Australia needs to do is stop iron ore exports to China and watch the Chinese on their knees begging. LOL
 
. .
All Australia needs to do is stop iron ore exports to China and watch the Chinese on their knees begging. LOL

Actually, I would argue the opposite. Australian Iron ore is booming in price, it's ridiculously HIGH (highest prices to date) and it's making the Chinese pay lots more.
 
.
Actually, I would argue the opposite. Australian Iron ore is booming in price, it's ridiculously HIGH (highest prices to date) and it's making the Chinese pay lots more.

Vey true, we need to keep increasing iron ore prices.
 
.
Need to note down USA takes over from Australia in barley, beef and coal China trade. AMERICA FIRST !!!!!
 
.
trade minister Dan Tehan says businesses must help Canberra repair ties with Beijing
Tehan said, adding that his January letter to his counterpart, Chinese commerce minister Wang Wentao, remains unanswered.
  • Detailed report says Australian businesses, the government and academia can work together to increase trade in Asia as part of a ‘Team Australia’ approach
  • But one expert says businesses cannot be expected to take lead on diplomacy while the government keeps making ‘diplomatic blunders’
:drag::drag:
 
. .
It's about where Australian economy would have been with better trade relationship with china.It's about the loss incurred against the surplus. Even Congo's economy has grown in 2021,if you just want to be so technical.
Not to mention that,Australia's growth doesn't even cover the losses in past year. The debt to gdp has ballooned by more than20%.
AUSTRALIA is like India,living in their own world ,as long as the people get their daily does of sky news australia justifying them,they will be happy in their head and wouldn't care .
 
Last edited:
.
Vey true, we need to keep increasing iron ore prices.
I suggest you check the historic iron ore prices and then come back to me. The sanctions by China is fcking up Australia hard, my cousin is there okay. Education tourism and mining are the 3 pillar industries of Australia and guess who are the top contributors? It might not cripple Australia as a whole, but it did cripple a whole bunch of industries mate.
 
.
Sanctions only really work against weak developing nations, not developed nations like Australia, which has robust financial and trade sectors, and is firmly within the US camp.
 
. . . .
China isn't the one that needs to worry, US does why try to spin it? US destroyers are obsolete, just using the same kind of logic as the thread you created.
LOL I simply asked if sanctions affect China given your previous statement and you went all wu mao on me :meeting:
 
.
Reality: Australian coal exports exports down 6%
Reality: Australian coal exports to China down 30%
Reality: Australian coal exports down to four year lows in major coal mining states
Some "journalist" citing an "expert": Chinas sanctions fail because Australia still made money
No "journalist" citing no "expert": India, Japan and Korea are now paying Australia 30% higher prices for less coal.

Congratulation to any shill that manages to force himself to act like hes falling for this with a straight face.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom