Centre collects revenue from south, spends on north: Andhra Chief Minister Chandrababu Naidu

[Taimoor Khan]

That's a very bad example. The North South difference is not the same.

Point is, South can still trade with north while being independent entity.

 

[kvpak]

Many of the IT crowd are North Indians. There has been a significant brain drain from the North to the South.

And South India is also an industrial powerhouse that sells to North Indians. Take defence for example. Most of the industry is in South India and employs South Indians generally. You can only imagine how much money is spent on just defence alone by the central govt. Our nuclear weapons program and space program are also located in South India.

Kerala attracts tourists from North India and is a huge money spinner.

Chennai is the Detroit of India and is a major car manufacturing hub which sells to the rest of India.

And all this while North India bears the brunt of all security issues that India faces.

<<<<Many of the IT crowd are North Indians. There has been a significant brain drain from the North to the South.>>>

Either you are anm ignorant idiot or an outright liar. Most IT professionals are South. The unskilled workers are a lot of Hiondi people. These illiterate migrants do not learn our language and expect us to talk to them in Hindi. They should be kicked out and unskiled jobs also should go to locals.




<<<And South India is also an industrial powerhouse that sells to North Indians. Take defence for example. Most of the industry is in South India and employs South Indians generally. You can only imagine how much money is spent on just defence alone by the central govt.>>>>


Almost all defense programs are for trhe defense of North. South is in no danger from Pzak or China.


<<< Our nuclear weapons program and space program are also located in South India.>>>>


I want thse programs out of south. India puts them here because they are farther from Pakand China. In case of war, Chindese missiles will strike south to destroy these weapon centres. So put these miliotary producers to north.




<<<Chennai is the Detroit of India and is a major car manufacturing hub which sells to the rest of India.>>>>


Sells to world too. Moreover taxes from them are taken to Delhi and given to Hindi states.




<<<<MAnd all this while North India bears the brunt of all security issues that India faces.>>>>


It is because of your geography. South is safe from Pakmand China. Unfortunately we pay for YOUR defense.

 

[SrNair]

The central govt already pays for a lot of stuff down south.

As for the bimaru states, what do you want, them to improve or them to start immigrating to your state for jobs and such?



That's a very bad example. The North South difference is not the same.



India is already a parliamentary republic.



That's temporary, our states have gone through the same process when we were at that level.

India's population growth will start reducing within a generation. But South Indian states are going to get even more richer anyway.

That is the topic of this thread .
Our share is much less than the North.
It is not helping them, that is the problem.

The spending is going nowhere not much development on ground .


Dont think so .
South Indian states some how decided to stand on their own .
But that cant be say about North India

 

[randomradio]

Point is, South can still trade with north while being independent entity.

Nope. Tariffs.

Either you are anm ignorant idiot or an outright liar. Most IT professionals are South. The unskilled workers are a lot of Hiondi people. These illiterate migrants do not learn our language and expect us to talk to them in Hindi. They should be kicked out and unskiled jobs also should go to locals.

You are too stupid to realize the difference between "many" and "most".

Almost all defense programs are for trhe defense of North. South is in no danger from Pzak or China.

The defence of the north is vital for the defence of the south. You forget that the entire navy's function is the defence of the south from Chinese aggression from the seas.

I want thse programs out of south. India puts them here because they are farther from Pakand China. In case of war, Chindese missiles will strike south to destroy these weapon centres. So put these miliotary producers to north.

Ever heard of PLAN?

Sells to world too. Moreover taxes from them are taken to Delhi and given to Hindi states.

Chennai sells peanuts to the world.

It is because of your geography. South is safe from Pakmand China. Unfortunately we pay for YOUR defense.

No. The center pays the south for the development of defence in the north.

Dude, you are an idiot false flagger. Your post is so evident from that.

 

[randomradio]

That is the topic of this thread .
Our share is much less than the North.
It is not helping them, that is the problem.

The spending is going nowhere not much development on ground .


Dont think so .
South Indian states some how decided to stand on their own .
But that cant be say about North India

Half our infrastructure projects are funded by the center.

Kochi Metro
http://www.thehindu.com/todays-pape...crore-allocation-in-budget/article5701317.ece
The State and Central governments are expected to pool in Rs 753.73 crore each for the project.

Bangalore Metro
http://www.financialexpress.com/eco...rs-12k-crore-for-phase-two-of-project/199367/
Both the Centre and state government will contribute 50% of the project cost through equity, while the remaining 50% will be met through borrowings,” Pradeep Singh Kharola, managing director, BMRCL said.

Interlinking rivers
http://www.financialexpress.com/ind...ould-help-india-fight-floods-droughts/836773/

The interlinking river project is designed to bring water from the surplus north to the deficit south.

http://www.thehindu.com/news/nation...s-Krishna-near-Vijayawada/article14494188.ece
The interlinking of the Godavari and the Krishna rivers became a reality with nearly 2400 cusecs of Godavari water reaching the Ferry here on Saturday afternoon on its way to the Prakasam barrage about 15 km away.

Sorry, man. You have zero arguments here.

 

[kvpak]

You list metro and river projects funded by Centre and State. Where does centre's money come from South's taxes because Hindi states get from India more than it pays in taxes.

For every Rs. 100 Tamil Nadu (non-Hindi, South) pays in tax to india, it gets back Rs. 45 from centre in projects like metro, etc.

For every Rs. 100 pays Uttar Pradesh (Hindi, north) in tax to india, it gets back Rs. 179 from centre in projects like metro, etc.

So Hindi states are not paying anything for south state projects. Kochi, Bengaluru, Chennai Metro all funded by South without a Rs. from Hindi states

 

[manlion]

Sorry, man. You have zero arguments here.

the inter basin water transfer projects (in Tamilnadu) were started by the British in the 19th CE

Taking Tamils plight to heart, a British Colonel built the Mullai Periyar dam using is own fund (sold his and his wife's properties in England) , Tamils in the region celebrate his birthday not Pongal or Diwali

India will not even implement the Kaveri Tribunal to quench dying Tamilnadu's thirst. The British had contributed more to Tamilnadu than India e.g world class infra structure - railway network, roads, education institutes - (Vellore Christian Medical College ) etc. By building the nuclear plants in Tamilnadu India has endangered the lives and environment of Tamilnadu (nuclear waste).

China and Pakistan are not Tamilnadu's enemies so why must Tamilnadu bear the brunt of India's provocative war with Pakistan or China

Tamils literally worship Pennyquick , who built the Mullai Periyar Dam

 

[randomradio]

You list metro and river projects funded by Centre and State. Where does centre's money come from South's taxes because Hindi states get from India more than it pays in taxes.

For every Rs. 100 Tamil Nadu (non-Hindi, South) pays in tax to india, it gets back Rs. 45 from centre in projects like metro, etc.

For every Rs. 100 pays Uttar Pradesh (Hindi, north) in tax to india, it gets back Rs. 179 from centre in projects like metro, etc.

So Hindi states are not paying anything for south state projects. Kochi, Bengaluru, Chennai Metro all funded by South without a Rs. from Hindi states

Lol. The consumer is what matters. North also pays taxes. So do the east and west and northeast.

I would recommend living in India first.

the inter basin water transfer projects (in Tamilnadu) were started by the British in the 19th CE

Taking Tamils plight to heart, a British Colonel built the Mullai Periyar dam using is own fund (sold his and his wife's properties in England) , Tamils in the region celebrate his birthday not Pongal or Diwali

India will not even implement the Kaveri Tribunal to quench dying Tamilnadu's thirst. The British had contributed more to Tamilnadu than India e.g world class infra structure - railway network, roads, education institutes - (Vellore Christian Medical College ) etc. By building the nuclear plants in Tamilnadu India has endangered the lives and environment of Tamilnadu (nuclear waste).

China and Pakistan are not Tamilnadu's enemies so why must Tamilnadu bear the brunt of India's provocative war with Pakistan or China

Tamils literally worship Pennyquick , who built the Mullai Periyar Dam

Another guy who is so proud of his country that he pretends to be Indian out of shame.

 

[SrNair]

Half our infrastructure projects are funded by the center.

Kochi Metro
http://www.thehindu.com/todays-pape...crore-allocation-in-budget/article5701317.ece
The State and Central governments are expected to pool in Rs 753.73 crore each for the project.

Bangalore Metro
http://www.financialexpress.com/eco...rs-12k-crore-for-phase-two-of-project/199367/
Both the Centre and state government will contribute 50% of the project cost through equity, while the remaining 50% will be met through borrowings,” Pradeep Singh Kharola, managing director, BMRCL said.

Interlinking rivers
http://www.financialexpress.com/ind...ould-help-india-fight-floods-droughts/836773/

The interlinking river project is designed to bring water from the surplus north to the deficit south.

http://www.thehindu.com/news/nation...s-Krishna-near-Vijayawada/article14494188.ece
The interlinking of the Godavari and the Krishna rivers became a reality with nearly 2400 cusecs of Godavari water reaching the Ferry here on Saturday afternoon on its way to the Prakasam barrage about 15 km away.

Sorry, man. You have zero arguments here.

How much we pay through the taxes ?
How many of them take tickets in North India when they board a train ?
How much from South India especially Kerala ?
In metro both of them took some amount .
But in North nothing from state ,total from centre and majority will goes to politicians project

 

[randomradio]

How much we pay through the taxes ?
How many of them take tickets in North India when they board a train ?
How much from South India especially Kerala ?
In metro both of them took some amount .
But in North nothing from state ,total from centre and majority will goes to politicians project

The rules are the same for the other states.

http://indianexpress.com/article/cities/lucknow/lucknow-metro-rail-project-gets-cabinet-nod/
Out of the Rs 6,928 crore cost, the Centre will fund Rs 1,300 crore in the form of equity and subordinate debt.

This is what Jaitley has been arguing about and he's right. Only the special status states get 90% centre funds, and this is what Naidu wants for AP.

Also you forget that while our states submitted to the British, it was some of the poorest states today that fought against British rule. That's why they did not receive any economic aid during British times, and that's biting them now. We are merely ahead because we took advantage of our servitude to the British. The same with Punjab.

The world over weaker economies are helped by stronger economies. That's why Poland gets a surplus of funds compared to their EU contribution while the UK has a deficit. The WTO too expects stronger states to sacrifice for the weaker ones.

You also have to consider that with our states with better industries, the richer the highly populated, underdeveloped states get, the more we can sell to them due to the open door policy we have with other states. They are our captive markets. If you let them develop more slowly, then they will capture our industries and start selling to us due to the rising labour cost difference between the rich and poor states. The labour cost difference shouldn't get larger than it is today.

How much we pay through the taxes ?

India is divided into 6 zones. North, South, East, West, Central and Northeast.

The West (Guj, Maha and Goa) and South are the richest. The rest are the poorest. If you divide the country between these two regions, then the GDP of the west+south is $1.35T and the rest of India is $1.2T. So it's more or less the same.

 

[patman]

Lol. The consumer is what matters. North also pays taxes. So do the east and west and northeast.

I would recommend living in India first.



Another guy who is so proud of his country that he pretends to be Indian out of shame.

Both are proven false faggers

the inter basin water transfer projects (in Tamilnadu) were started by the British in the 19th CE

Taking Tamils plight to heart, a British Colonel built the Mullai Periyar dam using is own fund (sold his and his wife's properties in England) , Tamils in the region celebrate his birthday not Pongal or Diwali

India will not even implement the Kaveri Tribunal to quench dying Tamilnadu's thirst. The British had contributed more to Tamilnadu than India e.g world class infra structure - railway network, roads, education institutes - (Vellore Christian Medical College ) etc. By building the nuclear plants in Tamilnadu India has endangered the lives and environment of Tamilnadu (nuclear waste).

China and Pakistan are not Tamilnadu's enemies so why must Tamilnadu bear the brunt of India's provocative war with Pakistan or China

Tamils literally worship Pennyquick , who built the Mullai Periyar Dam

<<<<Many of the IT crowd are North Indians. There has been a significant brain drain from the North to the South.>>>

Either you are anm ignorant idiot or an outright liar. Most IT professionals are South. The unskilled workers are a lot of Hiondi people. These illiterate migrants do not learn our language and expect us to talk to them in Hindi. They should be kicked out and unskiled jobs also should go to locals.




<<<And South India is also an industrial powerhouse that sells to North Indians. Take defence for example. Most of the industry is in South India and employs South Indians generally. You can only imagine how much money is spent on just defence alone by the central govt.>>>>


Almost all defense programs are for trhe defense of North. South is in no danger from Pzak or China.


<<< Our nuclear weapons program and space program are also located in South India.>>>>


I want thse programs out of south. India puts them here because they are farther from Pakand China. In case of war, Chindese missiles will strike south to destroy these weapon centres. So put these miliotary producers to north.




<<<Chennai is the Detroit of India and is a major car manufacturing hub which sells to the rest of India.>>>>


Sells to world too. Moreover taxes from them are taken to Delhi and given to Hindi states.




<<<<MAnd all this while North India bears the brunt of all security issues that India faces.>>>>


It is because of your geography. South is safe from Pakmand China. Unfortunately we pay for YOUR defense.

Oi , come on mr.south Indians , translate what I'm saying , prove you are one of us , @manlion @kvpak i can speak every south Indian language so talk to me I don't care if it's Tamil, Telugu, Kannada , malyanum, tulu


Here translate

• Gi poieora nalla koli kontu va

• Ni yab sooma e dudanni

• Nan netraru mane ali girile idde

• Ereg madwe athund ya, aver pudarr ?

 

[Ajaxpaul]

It's a fact, for every 1re spent on south 1.9rs is spent on North.

Can only hope it doesn't go to waste.

 

[randomradio]

It's a fact, for every 1re spent on south 1.9rs is spent on North.

Can only hope it doesn't go to waste.

Let's not forget that their population is also bigger. The population of South India is 250 million while UP alone is 207 million.

 

[protest]

Let's not forget that their population is also bigger. The population of South India is 250 million while UP alone is 207 million.

By 1951 census, Tamilnadu population was larger than Bihar, by 2011 Bihar is over 1.5 times Tamilnadu and expanding. So it would seem you also fault Tamilnadu for not producing enough babies as Bihar did, right? We cannot compensate states for overbreeding. Tamilnadu with smaller families progressed faster. Similar is the case with all other south states.

If you are to provide for more funds to populated states provide condition based aid. Provide for further aid only if they live up to those conditions. Why would south want to compensate for lazy north?

 

[kvpak]

Let's not forget that their population is also bigger. The population of South India is 250 million while UP alone is 207 million.

Either you do not understand what is going on or you pretend not to understand.

Yes, UP population is more. So they should pay more taxes and get more from centre. That does not happen. They pay less tax but get more from centre.

Tamil Nadu gets back from India Rs. 45 for every Rs. 100 it pays in taxes. If everything is fair, UP should also get the same ration. But UP gets back from India Rs. 179 for every Rs. 100 it pays in taxes. That is not fair.