Case Study: What should be our response to Taliban's demands?

[T-123456]

Pakistans intelligence ageny ISI is one of the best in the world,i heard.
I'm sure there were many chances(provided by ISI ?)to kill many important figures of the TTP and slowly eradicate them all.
So my question would be;why didnt they before and bring it this far?

 

[ranjeet]

Pakistans intelligence ageny ISI is one of the best in the world,i heard.
I'm sure there were many chances(provided by ISI ?)to kill many important figures of the TTP and slowly eradicate them all.
So my question would be;why didnt they before and bring it this far?

TTP is using the same tool which ISI once thought could be used against its enemies. As long as people within Pakistan will differentiate between the good and bad terrorists, one cannot have a clear idea about with whom to dealt with an Iron fist and whom with baby gloves.

 

[Aamna14]

Pakistans intelligence ageny ISI is one of the best in the world,i heard.
I'm sure there were many chances(provided by ISI ?)to kill many important figures of the TTP and slowly eradicate them all.
So my question would be;why didnt they before and bring it this far?

You are forgetting Afghanistan and how it provides safe haven to terrorists Fazlullah wasn't droned in Afghanistan while he was residing there comfortably infact none of those terrorists get droned as soon as they leave Pakistani territory.

 

[rockstar08]

here it goes ,
1. F-16
2. Jf-17
3. Al khalid
4. al zarar
5. SSG's
6. Drones
7. G3
8. laser guided bombs
9. cobra heli
10. Snipers

use them against taliban to get good results ....

 

[T-123456]

TTP is using the same tool which ISI once thought could be used against its enemies. As long as people within Pakistan will differentiate between the good and bad terrorists, one cannot have a clear idea about with whom to dealt with an Iron fist and whom with baby gloves.

There are no good or bad terrorists,they are all bad.

You are forgetting Afghanistan and how it provides safe haven to terrorists Fazlullah wasn't droned in Afghanistan while he was residing there comfortably infact none of those terrorists get droned as soon as they leave Pakistani territory.

Maybe after NATO leaves,you can get them there(Afghanistan).

 

[airmarshal]

6. Name your handlers/funders both in Pakistan and abroad.

They would not even know about this.

As for other demands, there are many groups there so enforcing these demands will be difficult.

 

[pak-marine]

Stop living in delusions screw this talks garbage ,gear up and fight !

 

[Shabaz Sharif]

TTP is using the same tool which ISI once thought could be used against its enemies. As long as people within Pakistan will differentiate between the good and bad terrorists, one cannot have a clear idea about with whom to dealt with an Iron fist and whom with baby gloves.

Randhwe stop posting that Karma is bharti whore again and again, sick of bhartis and their retarded ways. ISI didn't train TTP. TTP didnt fight Afghan Jihad. These are completly different beast.

 

[Counter-Errorist]

How about someone try and convince me why we should tolerate these barbarians who're killing our innocents on a daily basis and whose goal is to establish their twisted version of sharia in Pakistan?

 

[Donatello]

Havent you tried killing them?

Actually,no.

Pakistan has never went after these terrorists with full will. However, when the state did go against these TTP terrorists in Swat, it wasn't very pleasant for these thugs.

That's how they need to be treated and killed.

Here we go again..

Go again on what?

 

[ranjeet]

Randhwe stop posting that Karma is bharti whore again and again, sick of bhartis and their retarded ways. ISI didn't train TTP. TTP didnt fight Afghan Jihad. These are completly different beast.

Lol why are you getting so mad at the truth? I never said ISI trained TTP read again what I said.

There are no good or bad terrorists,they are all bad.


Maybe after NATO leaves,you can get them there(Afghanistan).

I know they are all bad but some Pakistanis on the ground don't agree with this theory. So as long as such people have a say in the higher ups of political establishment no concrete step can be taken against these terrorists.

 

[Areesh]

My take:

1. Surrender or leave Pakistan.

5. Deposit your weapons to the Pakistan Army.

These two. The rest demands would be fulfilled if these kharjis accept these two demands.

But then at this point of time those terrorists won't accept these demands. So lets launch an all out comprehensive attack against them and force them to accept these conditions. These dialogue would only succeed if govt conducts them from a point of strength. Or else result of any dialogue would be the same what we are witnessing right now.

 

[Jazzbot]

Dude haven't you seen the way that Burka Mullah reacted when Taliban agreed to even talk under the constitution? He almost walked away. No TTP representative has the power to compromise - if they agree to even concession from their demands, then they will become targets of the psychos themselves.

Mark my words, if the TTP agrees to any reasonable peace terms then their sub-groups will disown them and continue with attacks until they get what they want (or are killed).

Valid point, but even that will be a win win situation for us. At least we'll be able to split them and make them fight each other, hence a weaken enemy. Plus we'll clearly know which groups are ready to accept our terms and which are our true enemies.

 

[EasyNow]

Valid point, but even that will be a win win situation for us. At least we'll be able to split them and make them fight each other, hence a weaken enemy. Plus we'll clearly know which groups are ready to accept our terms and which are our true enemies.

True. I suppose in that sense it is worth hoping for agreement on some terms - and then wait for the inevitable cracks to appear.