Can Pakistan buy kashmir like it bought Gwadar?

[INDIC]

Yeah only the valley largely wants to join Pakistan.

You know that not true.
Only 2% Kashmiris want to join Pak: Survey

BTW, Kashmir valley is not of much worth, the main rivers are the Chenab and Indus river which don't flows through valley.

 

[Jf Thunder]

Agreed, I think a study said 80% of them didn't want anything to do with Pakistan, as for us - yeah they hate us we hate back, one more partition is impossible, the best they can hope for is some more autonomy.

Republic of Kashmir not feasible?

 

[janon]

higher importance how? Your soliders laid there lives in Sri lanka, what did you get in return? There land? Why don't you name an object for barter?
...

They laid down their lives for our national interest. Wars are not fought only for territory, but also for national interests - whether justified ones or unjust ones. Did American soldiers die in Iraq or Afghanistan so that those countries would become part of USA? In the war with LTTE, the Indian soldiers were fighting for other national interests, not for land. Which is why I said that example is totally irrelevant to this topic.

Republic of Kashmir not feasible?

Everybody knows it is not. It would be a landlocked republic with no resources, completely dependant on India or Pak for trade and access to the outside world. It would be an Afghanistan, with no way to make money.

 

[illusion8]

higher importance how? Your soliders laid there lives in Sri lanka, what did you get in return?

Nobody as yet has offered to pay a price for the lost lives in Sri Lanka and we don't expect anyone to be able to pay a price for the price of a soldiers life ..right?

So what do you propose?

Nothing, you are the one who's trying to propose here.

 

[INDIC]

They lied down their lives for our national interest. Wars are not fought only for territory, but also for national interests - whether justified ones or unjust ones. Did American soldiers die in Iraq or Afghanistan so that those countries would become part of USA? In the war with LTTE, the Indian soldiers were fighting for other national interests, not for land. Which is why I said that example is totally irrelevant to this topic.

Its too about their national interest. Kashmir for Pakistan is about rivers, not about the Muslim majority. Jinnah called Kashmir as jugular veins of Pakistan, veins here means Chenab-Indus-Jhelum river system.

 

[illusion8]

And who is going to make them autonomous?

Smells like you want the fruit but don;t want to sow the seed.

You are not making a lot of sense.

 

[Jf Thunder]

They laid down their lives for our national interest. Wars are not fought only for territory, but also for national interests - whether justified ones or unjust ones. Did American soldiers die in Iraq or Afghanistan so that those countries would become part of USA? In the war with LTTE, the Indian soldiers were fighting for other national interests, not for land. Which is why I said that example is totally irrelevant to this topic.


Everybody knows it is not. It would be a landlocked republic with no resources, completely dependant on India or Pak for trade and access to the outside world. It would be an Afghanistan, with no way to make money.

but Afghanistan is surviving, no?

 

[illusion8]

Republic of Kashmir not feasible?

How?

 

[nForce]

No I am damn sure. Just wanted to know if it is a real option. (not talking about feasibility)

The option has been exercised multiple times.As you noted about Gwadar, same was done with Alaska.The Yankees bought it from the Ruskies.
Feasibility is an entirely different story.

 

[Jf Thunder]

How?

idk, think of something

 

[illusion8]

idk, think of something

Why?

 

[Jf Thunder]

Why?

.............cuz swag?

 

[illusion8]

You know that not true.
Only 2% Kashmiris want to join Pak: Survey

BTW, Kashmir valley is not of much worth, the main rivers are the Chenab and Indus river which don't flows through valley.

Damn!! I got that 80% who don't want anything to do with Pakistan wrong.

 

[janon]

but Afghanistan is surviving, no?

In what condition?

 

[Jf Thunder]

In what condition?

ummm, surviving is surviving, no matter what condition