What's new

Budget highly ambitious, not implementable: economists

idune

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Dec 14, 2008
Messages
13,663
Reaction score
-40
Country
Bangladesh
Location
United States
Budget highly ambitious, not implementable: economists
Published: 00:51, Jun 02,2017 | Updated: 01:55, Jun 02,2017

Economists on Thursday termed the proposed budget for 2017-18 fiscal highly ambitious and feared that the government would eventually fail to achieve the large revenue collection and implement the annual development target.

The proposed budget is not implementable at all and the government will have to revise major targets later in the next fiscal year, they observed.

They also criticised the government initiative for allocation of Tk 2,000 crore to recapitalise the scam-hit state-run banks as such initiative would spoil public money like previous years.
Finance adviser to a former interim government AB Mirza Azizul Islam told New Age that the government proposed the large size budget, which was highly ambitious, ahead of national election.
In the proposed budget, the government increased the target of revenue collection to Tk 2,48,190 crore from Tk 2,03,152 crore in FY17, which was very high in light of the current trend in revenue collection.
He said, ‘The government will not be able to bring any major change to revenue collection overnight considering its capacity’.
The government’s whole budgetary plan would face trouble as it might fail to achieve the expected revenue target, he feared.
The government has made a big jump in setting the proposed amount to implement its annual development programme as the size of the amount increased to Tk 1,53,331 crore from Tk 1,10,700 crore for the outgoing FY17, he noted.
The government set negative examples in the previous fiscal years as it could implement around 90 per cent of the revised ADP budget, he said.
The government should not keep any allocation to recapitalise the state-run banks in the proposed budget as the previous initiative did not bring any positive results, Mirza Aziz said.
He stressed not disbursing any loan on political ground with a view to strengthening the capital base of the state-run banks.
Former Bangladesh Bank governor Salehuddin Ahmed told New Age that it was highly difficult for the government to implement the proposed budget considering its mega size.
The size of proposed deficit financing was too much as it would exceed five per cent of the GDP, he said.
The government set a deficit financing of Tk 1,12,276 crore for FY18, up from Tk 97,853 crore for FY17.
‘Banks will face crisis if investment in the private sector gets momentum. Besides, the government may borrow a hefty amount from the banking system to implements its mega infrastructural projects’, he said.
The proposed budget was not implementable and the government would have to cut the major targets like revenue collection and expenditure target, he commented.
Policy Research Institute executive director Ahsan H Mansur told New Age that the government would not be able to manage the deficit financing in line with its proposed budgetary goals.
The government has aimed to borrow Tk 30,150 crore from national savings certificates and bonds and Tk 28,203 crore from the banking sources.
The government borrowing from the savings tools will cross Tk 70,000 crore from the savings tolls in FY18 due to higher returns on the tools compared to other rates prevailing in market, he said.
Finance minister AMA Muhith had not declared in his budgetary speech any cut in the returns on the savings tools which would increase its (government) interest liabilities, he predicted.
The bank borrowing by the government would maintain the same track meaning it would not require any lending from the banking system like this year due to the huge net sales in the savings tools, he said.

- See more at: http://www.newagebd.net/article/168...implementable-economists#sthash.bppbXc9d.dpuf
 
Here is track record of awami league regime budget stunt show so that its cheer leaders can do annual ritual of dancing for looting allocation. Here is the tract record, awami league regime could not even implement downward revised budget. Last year budget was revised 7% down.

_72432.jpg
 
Last edited:
Here is tarcj record of awami league regime budget stunt show so that its cheer leaders can do annual ritual of dancing for looting allocation. Here is the tract record, awami league regime could not even implement downward revised budget. Last year budget was revised 7% down.

_72432.jpg

It's better to set higher target but not over the top. Actual budget for FY17 will likely be below 3 trillion taka. Maybe around about 2.8t. Expecting it to grow to 4t by next is highly unrealistic.

BD expect tax to GDP from 11% to 13%. Increase of 2% in 1 year is again not realistic. Before FY13 budgets used to be more realistic with not much difference in actual by the time FY ended.
 
Muhith: Political consensus needed to implement budget
The finance minister called the budget his best budget ever, saying there are no flaws in it

Finance Minister AMA Muhith has said the implementation of budget can be ensured if there is a consensus among all political parties on economic and social welfare issues.

“We have prepared an Awami League budget. It reflects the goals and aspirations of Bangladesh Awami League, but I have urged all to work together to bring comfort to the common people; so, we need to have consensus on social welfare issues,” the minister said while addressing a post-budget press conference at Osmani Memorial Auditorium in Dhaka on Friday.

Muhith said the prices of essentials were not raised by the imposition of the new 15% VAT and the budget for fiscal year 2017-18, which he presented in parliament on Thursday.

“The flash flood in Hoar areas have pushed up the prices of rice. I hope that the prices of essentials will normalise within a short time,” he said.

Muhith was confident that the new VAT law will not affect the small and medium businesses in the country.

“We have emphasised on more private sector investment. We need private investment amounting to 23% of GDP in the next fiscal year to achieve our goals,” the minister said.

He said he was confident about the government’s capacity to implement the budget.

Regarding gas price hike, he said: “I have not said in the budget speech that the price of gas will increase immediately.”

But gas prices will increase in 2018 when LNG comes into the local market, he pointed out.

dddddddddddddd-1.jpg


“We have allocated 54% in the next budget for poverty alleviation and 28% for gender equality,” he said.

He said the government has been promised massive amounts of foreign assistance in the last couple of years by development partners but their disbursement was slow.

“We will increase the review of disbursement of foreign assistance to enhance the capacity,” he said.

Asked what the budget would do to foster job growths, the minister said for a country like Bangladesh, 150,000 jobs will be created for each percent GDP growth.

“If we achieve the 7.4% growth rate within a year, there will be no lack of employment in the country.”

The 15% VAT rate on English medium schools will not create inequality in the education system, he said in reply to a question.

Muhith admitted that there is corruption and plundering in the banking sector.

“But you are wrong in assuming this is going on in private banks,” he said, in reply to a query.

The plundering in banking has now been significantly reduced, he said.

“There are problems in two banks but we are planning to solve those problems.”

Bangladesh Bank Governor Fazle Kabir said state-run banks do government treasury work and often cannot attend to their earnings.

“So sometimes they need recapitalisation funds. That is why the government has allocated Tk2,000 crore allocation for recapitalisation of state banks in the next fiscal year,” he said.

Muhith said the profit of saving instruments will be adjusted within two months as the interest rate in banks is now only 7% while the profit rate of saving instruments is 11%.

“We will not give any incentive to local expatriate workers but the government will reduce the cost of sending remittance from aboard to Bangladesh,” he said.

Besides Muhith and Kabir, Agriculture Minister Matia Chowdhury, Industries Minister Amir Hossain Amu and Planning Minister AHM Mustafa Kamal also fielded questions from journalists at the briefing.

‘Best budget of my life’
The finance minister called the budget his best budget ever, saying there are no flaws in it.

The finance minister held his traditional post-budget media briefing on Friday at the Osmani Memorial Auditorium in Dhaka.

“The budget I have placed in parliament is the best budget of my life. The whole budget is bright, there are no weaknesses in it,” said Muhith.

“I am happy as I have presented my best budget of my life. My first budget was TK91,000 crore which turned into over TK4 lakh crore. This is absolutely unprecedented in the history of budgets,” added Muhith.

The minister said budgets should always be ambitious, addressing queries about the risks of a large budget.

He dismissed views that the government’s implementation of the budget was poor, saying: “If the government cannot implement the budget, how are we handling bigger and bigger budgets each year?”

“This budget is Awami League’s budget but the main aim of the budget is to work for public welfare.
http://www.dhakatribune.com/banglad...-political-consensus-needed-implement-budget/
 
whats the total Layout in USD for FY 17?

The Tk 4,00,266 crores (4 trillion taka or US $ 50 billion)budget, some 26% larger than the outgoing budget outlay, is expected to meet long-standing demands from various quarters, with an eye on the national polls scheduled for January 2019.
 
Back
Top Bottom