What's new

Bangladesh resists 'debt-trap' of China, avoids Belt and Road Initiative heavy-handedness

Black_cats

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Dec 31, 2010
Messages
10,031
Reaction score
-5
Bangladesh resists 'debt-trap' of China, avoids Belt and Road Initiative heavy-handedness
Popular protests were raised against coal-based projects which, among others, were withdrawn, ostensibly for environmental concerns


Popular protests were raised against coal-based projects which, among others, were withdrawn, ostensibly for environmental concerns3 min read . 05:48 AM ISTANI

DHAKA : Unlike Pakistan and Sri Lanka, Bangladesh has conducted prudent macro-economic management in order to not fall into any 'debt trap' of China and has avoided the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) heavy-handedness!

But Paulo Casaca, writing in South Asia Democratic Forum (SADF) cautioned Bangladesh authorities who have been relatively carefree to now be concerned at the potential geopolitical dependency brought by their participation on the BRI.

Bangladesh did not allow Chinese investmentin deep-sea ports suitable for a future Chinese Navy presence, as it cancelled the Sonadia deep-sea project and only agreed to a port project in Payra, 'approachable only through a 75-kilometre-long canal, a very unlikely place for a naval base', reported S Ramachandran.

Bangladesh formalised its presence in the 'Belt and Road Initiative', on October 15, 2016, during a visit by Chinese President Xi Jinping to the country. Both countries also agreed to promote their relations to the level of 'strategic partnership'.

The volume of investments agreed made Bangladesh the second most important recipient of Chinese funds after Pakistan, reported S Ramachandran.

According to China Daily, and notwithstanding the pandemic-related general slowdown, Chinese investment has been steadily rising in domains such as infrastructure (a new railway crossing on the Padma River is a flagship project) and special economic zones, reported SADF.

The initiative faced some major hurdles. There were important clashes between local workers and Chinese expatriates at the site of the Payra power plant, reported Ramanchadran.

Popular protests were raised against coal-based projects which, among others, were withdrawn, ostensibly for environmental concerns. Contracts were also cancelled for bribery by the state-owned China Communications Construction Company (CCCC), which was blacklisted by Bangladesh authorities in 2018, reported Nikkei Asia.

Moreover, China tried to foray into Bangladesh internal matters when it warned Dhaka to not engage with India and Western powers.

Minister of National Defence Wei Fenghe declared in a meeting with Bangladesh's President Abdul Hamid that in order 'to jointly maintain regional peace and stability, the two sides should make joint efforts against powers outside the region setting up a military alliance in South Asia and practising hegemonism', reported Xinhua.

The point was repeated some days later in a clearer fashion by the Chinese Ambassador in Dhaka: 'Relations with China will be damaged if Bangladesh joins US-led 'Quad' - Quadrilateral Security Dialogue, an initiative of Australia, India, Japan and the US, reported The Daily Star.

The warning was more in line with the new Chinese 'wolf warrior diplomacy' than with the originally announced 'absence of strings attached' with BRI projects, wrote Casaca.

The Bangladeshi authorities' reply came swiftly; 'Foreign Minister AK Abdul Momen made his displeasure clear, telling reporters: "We are an independent and sovereign state. We decide our foreign policy", reported Nikkei Asia.

The answer was sufficiently clear to cool down the Chinese authoritarian mood, for the time being, reported SADF.

In order to checkmate Chinese designs in the region, Casaca advised democratic countries and neighbours to support Bangladesh.

Bangladesh deserves to fully enjoy available support and engagement from democratic countries and neighbours within the multilateral domain, including naturally the Quad, deciding on each issue according to its own judgements and interests, wrote Casaca. (ANI)

 
. . . .
If you borrow money, you get into debt. If you don't borrow money, you're not in debt. If you don't like China's low-interest-rate loans with no political conditions, you can choose a high-interest-rate loan with political conditions attached. It all depends on your choice.

If you find any loans that do not need to be repaid, please let me know. I need free money. :azn:
 
. . .
Bangladesh resists 'debt-trap' of China, avoids Belt and Road Initiative heavy-handedness
Popular protests were raised against coal-based projects which, among others, were withdrawn, ostensibly for environmental concerns


Popular protests were raised against coal-based projects which, among others, were withdrawn, ostensibly for environmental concerns3 min read . 05:48 AM ISTANI

DHAKA : Unlike Pakistan and Sri Lanka, Bangladesh has conducted prudent macro-economic management in order to not fall into any 'debt trap' of China and has avoided the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) heavy-handedness!

But Paulo Casaca, writing in South Asia Democratic Forum (SADF) cautioned Bangladesh authorities who have been relatively carefree to now be concerned at the potential geopolitical dependency brought by their participation on the BRI.

Bangladesh did not allow Chinese investmentin deep-sea ports suitable for a future Chinese Navy presence, as it cancelled the Sonadia deep-sea project and only agreed to a port project in Payra, 'approachable only through a 75-kilometre-long canal, a very unlikely place for a naval base', reported S Ramachandran.

Bangladesh formalised its presence in the 'Belt and Road Initiative', on October 15, 2016, during a visit by Chinese President Xi Jinping to the country. Both countries also agreed to promote their relations to the level of 'strategic partnership'.

The volume of investments agreed made Bangladesh the second most important recipient of Chinese funds after Pakistan, reported S Ramachandran.

According to China Daily, and notwithstanding the pandemic-related general slowdown, Chinese investment has been steadily rising in domains such as infrastructure (a new railway crossing on the Padma River is a flagship project) and special economic zones, reported SADF.

The initiative faced some major hurdles. There were important clashes between local workers and Chinese expatriates at the site of the Payra power plant, reported Ramanchadran.

Popular protests were raised against coal-based projects which, among others, were withdrawn, ostensibly for environmental concerns. Contracts were also cancelled for bribery by the state-owned China Communications Construction Company (CCCC), which was blacklisted by Bangladesh authorities in 2018, reported Nikkei Asia.

Moreover, China tried to foray into Bangladesh internal matters when it warned Dhaka to not engage with India and Western powers.

Minister of National Defence Wei Fenghe declared in a meeting with Bangladesh's President Abdul Hamid that in order 'to jointly maintain regional peace and stability, the two sides should make joint efforts against powers outside the region setting up a military alliance in South Asia and practising hegemonism', reported Xinhua.

The point was repeated some days later in a clearer fashion by the Chinese Ambassador in Dhaka: 'Relations with China will be damaged if Bangladesh joins US-led 'Quad' - Quadrilateral Security Dialogue, an initiative of Australia, India, Japan and the US, reported The Daily Star.

The warning was more in line with the new Chinese 'wolf warrior diplomacy' than with the originally announced 'absence of strings attached' with BRI projects, wrote Casaca.

The Bangladeshi authorities' reply came swiftly; 'Foreign Minister AK Abdul Momen made his displeasure clear, telling reporters: "We are an independent and sovereign state. We decide our foreign policy", reported Nikkei Asia.

The answer was sufficiently clear to cool down the Chinese authoritarian mood, for the time being, reported SADF.

In order to checkmate Chinese designs in the region, Casaca advised democratic countries and neighbours to support Bangladesh.

Bangladesh deserves to fully enjoy available support and engagement from democratic countries and neighbours within the multilateral domain, including naturally the Quad, deciding on each issue according to its own judgements and interests, wrote Casaca. (ANI)

If you borrow money, you get into debt. If you don't borrow money, you're not in debt. If you don't like China's low-interest-rate loans with no political conditions, you can choose a high-interest-rate loan with political conditions attached. It all depends on your choice.

If you find any loans that do not need to be repaid, please let me know. I need free money. :azn:

this article is really funny
 
.
this article is really funny

Well every time anyone utters the word "Chinese Investments" or "Chinese Subs in Bay of Bengal" Sanghis start wetting their pants. Their media starts this dance about China the looming threat...

Never mind the fact that Bangladesh as a sovereign country was never their property or beholden to their dictum as to what can or does happen in their neighborhood.

However Sanghis mistake Bangladesh' diplomacy to yield to their concerns as weakness.

They have to realize that the Bangladesh of twenty years ago is not in the same position anymore, either economically, militarily or strategy/policy-wise.

We don't play second fiddle to anyone, much less a third world entity West of us.
 
.
Well every time anyone utters the word "Chinese Investments" or "Chinese Subs in Bay of Bengal" Sanghis start wetting their pants. Their media starts this dance about China the looming threat...

Never mind the fact that Bangladesh as a sovereign country was never their property or beholden to their dictum as to what can or does happen in their neighborhood.

However Sanghis mistake Bangladesh' diplomacy to yield to their concerns as weakness.

They have to realize that the Bangladesh of twenty years ago is not in the same position anymore, either economically, militarily or strategy/policy-wise.

We don't play second fiddle to anyone, much less a third world entity West of us.

It's like having a friend in adolescence, they may have been forgiving and easily taken advantage of but 10 years down the line you attempt to treat them like you did then it won't work. Pungent India needs to get this down it's throat.
 
.
If you borrow money, you get into debt. If you don't borrow money, you're not in debt. If you don't like China's low-interest-rate loans with no political conditions, you can choose a high-interest-rate loan with political conditions attached. It all depends on your choice.

If you find any loans that do not need to be repaid, please let me know. I need free money. :azn:
Perhaps you're not that bright to think that there are other options !
Like not build a deep sea port with borrowed money on the mouth of the river as the Chinese suggested !
Also not use borrowed money to finance an inflated project with no option to bid.
 
.
If there was a reasonable projected ROI for BD then it would be idiotic to cancel Chinese projects. This only makes sense IF BD did prudent research and came to the conclusion their would be a loss.

But then that begs the question as to why all the projects were design in the first place. Usually the first step is to calculate the cost vs projected revenue for an infrastructure project. but then their are also a lot of indirect expenses/benefits which are hard to calculate.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom