Bangladesh bans marriages for Rohingya Muslim refugees

[livingdead]

this is inhuman. bangladeshis obviously will blame india (and israel even)..

 

[Jaanbaz]

Bangladesh has no respect for Ummah and Chumma. I strongly oppose this.

Why do Indians always want chumma from Bengalis anyway?

 

[livingdead]

Why do Indians always want chumma from Bengalis anyway?

you jelly?

 

[Jaanbaz]

you jelly?

Not really, we have the ummah you can have the chummi from Bengalis.

 

[the just]

What i am saying is that mass migration of bangladeshi are disturbing already the fragile peace in northeastern areas and adding to communal tension in northeast, distubing the regional demographic and when we complain you guys say ...meh.But i hope that now when you are present in the same sitiuation you will hopefully realize our headache and strain on indian resources similar to the strain on bangladeshi resources due to rohingya migration.

First of all we know when and how this refugee s started to come.You can't say a definit reason why people of Bangladesh are going to india to become refugee and living in camps.
Second,we know how many are here,officially 4 million.unofficially close to 6.5 million.If you people to be believed, there are 50 million Bangladeshi in india.How that is possible god knows. Your government doesn't know it seems.
Third,they are recognized by UN and other international organization who specialized in refugee programs. You don't have such in your country.
Fourth,the Hindu populace do get married to their indian counter part, usually the girls go to india and girls from there comes here.some workers who does manual labor goes to india to work alone living his families here.they don't marry locals to claim they are indian,in which case its get reported to local police station.
Fifth,we also have illegal Indians working in Bangladesh (1.5 million) but they also don't marry locally to claim citizenship. So locals don't bother them.they stay in their own community.
We also have white collar Indians and Srilankas working in BD .they stay within their community also.they don't want BD citizenship ,so we have vno problems with either of them.
We currently have almost 7/8 million leftover Pakistani people,who's country did not take them back after our Independence. They live in camps( intentionally mostly) some break away ,take BD citizenships through proper procedures, but rear to see them marry local Bangladeshi people .
So no I don't understand what you are trying to say.
Because you cannot compare reality with fabricated fiction.

 

[kalu_miah]

Simple.From 1988 officially rohingyas of Myanmar started coming in hoards in Bangladesh. Because Myanmar government decided that people who are not descendants of tibbetian origin is not part of Myanmar, so either they are killed or forced to flee the country, where they are the original people of that land.
Now in Bangladesh, with its political turmoil and struggle, people of government and local generous individuals hav been aiding,providing these refugees with place,food,cloths.in some privet own NGOs even give them work for money.there are schools inside the camp.run by our people. Teachers are mostly from the camps.
Now.the problem we face currently is the population and extensive work ,money,time,efforts that goes in to these camps .So far we got international aid only thrice in last 20 so years.UN only observe but they don't help,not even red Cross. Any epidemic in on of these camps if starts can kill millions of Bangladeshi people as well as rohingys over night.
Few hundreds has been sent back ,but with rohingys and local illiterate /clueless people almost every day they are coming in to Bangladesh unnoticed and getting lost in local community.
Until we find a way to send these people to their country the are and will be a threat to our nation.Population is a minor headech compared to other serious matter regarding rohingyas.Yaba business, small arms,(mostly hand made),prostitution,moral standard in terms of lifestyle are in jepordy.
These are little tit bits I can provide you now.
But after reading this, would you still think that we should welcome them with open arms?
A small push from USA can resolve this issue in no time.But until then they should be in camps like they are meant to,because they are refugee from Myanmar not Bangladeshi.

The people in Myanmar, at least Burman majority and Rakhine Buddhists in Rakhine state want them out and want to have nothing to do with them. Its a slow motion ethnic cleansing. So they are going to wherever they can escape to, to save their lives. Bangladesh being close to their location and us being their closest ethnic and religious kin, they will naturally infiltrate into Bangladesh where they can get lost into local population. This situation will continue till no Rohingya is left in Myanmar. First we have to accept this reality and then try to take actions that will minimize damage for all, the Rohingya and people of Bangladesh.

Claiming that this is not our problem and USA should give a push, will get you nowhere, unfortunately, because not one of the players - the Rohingya, the Rakhine, the Burman dominated govt. of Myanmar or the international community, care about how we Bangladeshi's feel about this issue. So in the end its a matter of life and death for them and I believe we have no option but to help save their lives, as fellow human beings, as Muslims and as their ethnic kins.

 

[notsuperstitious]

Polevaulters polevaulted!!!

 

[Icewolf]

Good move by BD, muslims breed like rabbits. And these rohingys could probably even out-breed bd muslims.

No wonder Hindu India is the worlds most populated country!!! LOL.. Kinda ironic

 

[extra terrestrial]

Replace bangladesh with india and rohingyas with bangladeshi's....and then i will hope you will come to appreciate india's concern of illeggal migration from bangladesh.

I don't think you can equate your issue with ours since we have registered valid numbers about the illegal immigration from Burma but you only have some wild estimates which are of no value.

First we have to accept this reality and then try to take actions that will minimize damage for all, the Rohingya and people of Bangladesh

What could be the solution? We can't accept such a huge number of people since we are already struggling with our scarce resources.

 

[kalu_miah]

What could be the solution? We can't accept such a huge number of people since we are already struggling with our scarce resources.

The solution I propose is to hold a talk between Myanmar, Bangladesh, OIC, GCC, ASEAN, UN, China, Japan and South Korea and then work out a comprehensive deal on Rohingya issue between these multilateral bodies, Bangladesh and Myanmar with the three East Asian countries as witness:

- Myanmar should reconsider its citizenship of Rohingya population and if they are proven to be from before 1947, they should be accepted as citizens (I think very few migrated there after 1947, Pakistan was a prosperous state and who would want to go to a hell hole like that?)
- The ones that are proven and determined to be non-citizens and migrants after 1947, from former East Pakistan and later Bangladesh, they should be accepted by Bangladesh
- to finance settling of all refugees, Bangladesh should seek financial help from OIC and GCC member countries and China, Japan and South Korea
- OIC member countries could accept some small number of these refugees

We cannot just let these people die in the hands of killers in Myanmar. We have the responsibility to save their lives regardless of how difficult this financial burden is for Bangladesh.

@Nihonjin1051

 

[extra terrestrial]

The solution I propose is to hold a talk between Myanmar, Bangladesh, OIC, GCC, ASEAN, UN, China, Japan and South Korea and then work out a comprehensive deal on Rohingya issue between these multilateral bodies, Bangladesh and Myanmar with the three East Asian countries as witness:

- Myanmar should reconsider its citizenship of Rohingya population and if they are proven to be from before 1947, they should be accepted as citizens (I think very few migrated there after 1947, Pakistan was a prosperous state and who would want to go to a hell hole like that?)
- The ones that are proven and determined to be non-citizens and migrants after 1947, from former East Pakistan and later Bangladesh, they should be accepted by Bangladesh
- to finance settling of all refugees, Bangladesh should seek financial help from OIC and GCC member countries and China, Japan and South Korea
- OIC member countries could accept some small number of these refugees

We cannot just let these people die in the hands of killers in Myanmar. We have the responsibility to save their lives regardless of how difficult this financial burden is for Bangladesh.

@Nihonjin1051

I don't think it would be that easy, now as Burma is heading towards democracy, the Rohingya issue will turn into a political tool which would just exacerbate the situation. Besides, the anti-Muslim propaganda movements by the military junta like 969 have totally turned the masses against the Rohingyas.

 

[kalu_miah]

I don't think it would be that easy, now as Burma is heading towards democracy, the Rohingya issue will turn into a political tool which would just exacerbate the situation. Besides, the anti-Muslim propaganda movements by the military junta like 969 have totally turned the masses against the Rohingyas.

Even if they kick all of them out, at least we will have some financial help to resettle them in Bangladesh or elsewhere. If we do not make a deal, the present situation will continue and we will have to bear the full financial burden, without any help from outside.

 

[extra terrestrial]

Even if they kick all of them out, at least we will have some financial help to resettle them in Bangladesh or elsewhere. If we do not make a deal, the present situation will continue and we will have to bear the full financial burden, without any help from outside.

Well, no financial help would be sufficient unless we are awarded with foreign land. Also, why only we will have to face the burden when Burma is responsible for the whole issue.

 

[Chronos]

Really my pity is for the Rohingyas. They are chased in the country they live in, not welcomed in the country they had lived in, talk the bengali language and others.
Fee sorry for them.

quoted your post again to remind some of the posters here that there is a Humanitarian crisis going on.

 

[kalu_miah]

Well, no financial help would be sufficient unless we are awarded with foreign land. Also, why only we will have to face the burden when Burma is responsible for the whole issue.

Do you think we are in a position to invade and annex full or parts of Arakan/Rakhine?