Signalian
PDF THINK TANK: CONSULTANT
- Joined
- Aug 18, 2015
- Messages
- 10,608
- Reaction score
- 305
- Country
- Location
I explicitly had wheeled options in mind.
- Why would the Indian Army NOT use ATGMs to destroy the Type-15 light tank?
- Mobility is precisely why I suggested that armoured cars/fire support vehicles/tank destroyers. Neither tracked vehicles nor the heavy armour of MBTs is necessary in what you have pointed out is an infantry support role.
You can't have your cake and eat it too. If we are discussing the possibility that India is looking for a light tank and wishes to procure such a system, my remarks relate to that. The advantages of wheeled vehicles is precisely why I suggested that these vehicles mentioned are preferable to light tanks.
If, as you point out, we are talking only about what the Indian Army has at present, the T90, then this discussion is unnecessary.
Combining the two cases totally muddles the issue.
Wheeled option is better but then again its lesser armored and carries slightly smaller cannon than MBT. Recovery is easy too. Some of these can carry troops. So over all, a suitable option.
Destroying Type-15 is not the issue here, deployment of Indian Armor is what we are talking here. Type-15 has been deployed by PLA already and whether IA deploys T-90 or not, which means Type-15 will be supporting infantry in any case. Although howitzers can give enormous fire cover for advancing infantry, yet the presence of tanks could suggest that PLA infantry could be mobile to keep up with tanks.
In case of mobility, CJ-3 or M-151 with RR gun or TOW still seems an adequate option They have proved themselves in every terrain but they are outdated now. Maybe something in the class of Piranha 8x8 or Stryker or Ratel series. The protection from small arms fire is there, mobility should be of lesser worry and can mount a decent cannon. But armored vehicles will not be the only candidates in the battlefield - expect others at some stage like gunships, lots of tube artillery, MLRS, ground strike aircraft which would require air superiority etc. Maybe transport helis for air borne Ops.