What's new

Why Taiwan Needs Nuclear Weapons

dani191

SENIOR MEMBER
Jul 10, 2017
3,205
-9
1,093
Country
Israel
Location
Israel

May 31, 2020 Topic: Security Region: Asia Tags: TaiwanChinaMilitaryTechnologyNuclear Weapons
Why Taiwan Needs Nuclear Weapons
With communist authorities in China openly and gleefully shredding the post-World War II liberal order, it may be time for the United States and Taiwan to show Beijing the dangers of doing so by allowing Taiwan to become a nuclear weapons power.
by Michael Rubin

Chinese President Xi Jinping is on the warpath. He has abrogated the 1984 Sino-British Joint Declaration which guaranteed Hong Kong’s special status more than a quarter-century early. He has precipitated the worst military crisis with India since the 1962 Sino-India War. His repression and incarceration of the Uighur minority is on a scale far greater than what happened during the Balkan wars at the end of the 20th century. China’s artificial island-building in the South China Sea and its farcical and ahistorical claims to the “Nine-Dash Line” represent a land grab against the Philippines and the theft of maritime resources against other regional states.
SPONSORED CONTENT
Stay Safe, Stay Home

While Crime Fell, the Cost of Cops Soared: The History of America's Policing BudgetWhile Crime Fell, the Cost of Cops Soared: The History of America's Policing BudgetBloomberg


Play this geopolitical strategy game and win World War III!Play this geopolitical strategy game and win World War III!Conflict of Nations | Dorado Games


Limited Time Offer - Bloomberg.com For Just $1.99Limited Time Offer - Bloomberg.com For Just $1.99Bloomberg.com


Now, Chinese officials are again signaling they may attack Taiwan. On Friday, Li Zuocheng, chief of the Joint Staff Department and member of the Central Military Commission, promised to “resolutely smash any separatist plots or actions.” He added, “We do not promise to abandon the use of force, and reserve the option to take all necessary measures, to stabilize and control the situation in the Taiwan Strait.” What Li sees as “separatist plots or actions,” the Taiwanese might call popular sovereignty and the exercise of democracy. After all, Taiwanese—both those indigenous to the island and those who are more recent immigrants—have a very different narrative, one rooted more in history. They realize that while Chinese officials have long claimed the island nation as an indivisible part of China, historically and with the exception of just a few decades over the course of centuries, Taiwan has been distinct and its own entity. Any visitor to Taiwan can observe this the second they leave the airport.

Authorities in Taiwan cannot afford to take Chinese threats lightly. They recognize that the fact that Western democracies and regional Asian states have offered little more than rhetoric in response to Chinese aggression only emboldens Beijing and makes it more likely the fact that Chinese ‘salami-slicing’ will continue. And while the U.S. Navy will continue to traverse the South China Sea to demonstrate its commitment to maintain freedom of passage in international waters, the Pentagon is simply not prepared to risk war with China to counter the occupation of the Scarborough Shoal or Mischief Reef, let alone the Penghu islands or the Taiwanese mainland.
With communist authorities in China openly and gleefully shredding the post-World War II liberal order, it may be time for the United States and Taiwan to show Beijing the dangers of doing so by allowing Taiwan to become a nuclear weapons power.
Primis Player Placeholder





6.3M

4.2K
Will Turkey Really Get an Aircraft Carrier Armed with F-35s?







The Clinton administration popularized the term “rogue regime” as a state that promoted terrorism or acted aggressively toward its neighbors but for political scientists, the origin of the concept was different. In 1977, for example, political scientist Richard K. Betts spoke wrote about nuclear ambitions among paranoid, pygmy, and pariah states. He defined both Israel and Taiwan as pariah states, not as a moral judgment, but rather because neighboring and regional states posed existential challenges to their national status. Two years later, the New York Times wrote about Israel, Taiwan, and South Africa as “nuclear outcasts” because they might require nuclear weapons to deter existential challenges.
SPONSORED CONTENT
Stay Safe, Stay Home


Super research versus super germs
Learn More
Only new antibiotics help against antibiotic-resistant germs. And they need to be better, too. ""PK150"" could be the penicillin of tomor…Merck


Most Dangerous Selfies Ever TakenMost Dangerous Selfies Ever TakenFar & Wide


VMworld - הכנס הטכנולוגי של השנה יוצא לדרך! הירשמו עכשיוVMworld - הכנס הטכנולוגי של השנה יוצא לדרך! הירשמו עכשיו
Register Now
VMworld by VMware


While Israel has never signed the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) and so is not governed by its constraints, Taiwan’s nuclear program was in violation of its treaty obligations. In 1968, Taiwan—then recognized at the United Nations—as the legitimate government of China has signed the NPT and was a member of the International Atomic Energy Agency. Officially, when Washington and the United Nations shifted recognition of China from Taipei to Beijing, the United States and Taiwan agreed that Taiwan would continue to abide by the NPT. As Taiwan nevertheless quietly pursued a nuclear capability, the Clinton administration acted covertly to sabotage Taiwanese ambitions.
In hindsight, that was a mistake. If the Trump administration wishes to push back on Xi’s aggression, it is time to reconsider the interpretation of Taiwan’s NPT commitments, both in Washington and Taipei. After all, if the international community will not uphold its obligations to Taiwan, then Taiwan should not bend over backward to preserve an order in which the People’s Republic of China is deliberately ending.
SPONSORED CONTENT
Stay Safe, Stay Home

The King of Germany Will Accept Your Bank Deposits NowThe King of Germany Will Accept Your Bank Deposits NowBloomberg.com


Discover A More Secure Journey To Cloud Trusted By Thousands Of EnterprisesDiscover A More Secure Journey To Cloud Trusted By Thousands Of EnterprisesIBM


They Have More Money Than Anyone on EarthThey Have More Money Than Anyone on EarthWork + Money


Should Taiwan start from scratch and indigenously build its program, it might precipitate further communist Chinese aggression. But, if Taiwan was gifted medium-range nuclear weapons which were placed under its control, it would both acquire a sufficient deterrent in order to maintain stability if not peace across the Taiwan Strait and absolve the United States of the need to deploy multiple carrier groups to the region should communist China attack the only remaining free and democratic Chinese republic.
Now is the time for hard decisions in Washington. If China digests Taiwan as it has Hong Kong, it is unlikely it will simply be satiated. As China faces its own economic turmoil, Xi can put forward baseless claims as fact and encroach further in Southeast Asia, the East China Sea, and the Pacific. And while Taiwan’s membership in the nuclear weapons club will be a blow to the spirit of the NPT, no country should be expected to sacrifice the freedom of 24 million people to preserve order and a system in which the international community lets Beijing deconstruct with ease.
 

Patriot forever

FULL MEMBER
Jun 2, 2020
602
1
1,079
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan

May 31, 2020 Topic: Security Region: Asia Tags: TaiwanChinaMilitaryTechnologyNuclear Weapons
Why Taiwan Needs Nuclear Weapons
With communist authorities in China openly and gleefully shredding the post-World War II liberal order, it may be time for the United States and Taiwan to show Beijing the dangers of doing so by allowing Taiwan to become a nuclear weapons power.
by Michael Rubin

Chinese President Xi Jinping is on the warpath. He has abrogated the 1984 Sino-British Joint Declaration which guaranteed Hong Kong’s special status more than a quarter-century early. He has precipitated the worst military crisis with India since the 1962 Sino-India War. His repression and incarceration of the Uighur minority is on a scale far greater than what happened during the Balkan wars at the end of the 20th century. China’s artificial island-building in the South China Sea and its farcical and ahistorical claims to the “Nine-Dash Line” represent a land grab against the Philippines and the theft of maritime resources against other regional states.
SPONSORED CONTENT
Stay Safe, Stay Home
While Crime Fell, the Cost of Cops Soared: The History of America's Policing Budget's Policing BudgetWhile Crime Fell, the Cost of Cops Soared: The History of America's Policing BudgetBloomberg
Play this geopolitical strategy game and win World War III!Play this geopolitical strategy game and win World War III!Conflict of Nations | Dorado Games
Limited Time Offer - Bloomberg.com For Just $1.99Limited Time Offer - Bloomberg.com For Just $1.99Bloomberg.com

Now, Chinese officials are again signaling they may attack Taiwan. On Friday, Li Zuocheng, chief of the Joint Staff Department and member of the Central Military Commission, promised to “resolutely smash any separatist plots or actions.” He added, “We do not promise to abandon the use of force, and reserve the option to take all necessary measures, to stabilize and control the situation in the Taiwan Strait.” What Li sees as “separatist plots or actions,” the Taiwanese might call popular sovereignty and the exercise of democracy. After all, Taiwanese—both those indigenous to the island and those who are more recent immigrants—have a very different narrative, one rooted more in history. They realize that while Chinese officials have long claimed the island nation as an indivisible part of China, historically and with the exception of just a few decades over the course of centuries, Taiwan has been distinct and its own entity. Any visitor to Taiwan can observe this the second they leave the airport.

Authorities in Taiwan cannot afford to take Chinese threats lightly. They recognize that the fact that Western democracies and regional Asian states have offered little more than rhetoric in response to Chinese aggression only emboldens Beijing and makes it more likely the fact that Chinese ‘salami-slicing’ will continue. And while the U.S. Navy will continue to traverse the South China Sea to demonstrate its commitment to maintain freedom of passage in international waters, the Pentagon is simply not prepared to risk war with China to counter the occupation of the Scarborough Shoal or Mischief Reef, let alone the Penghu islands or the Taiwanese mainland.
With communist authorities in China openly and gleefully shredding the post-World War II liberal order, it may be time for the United States and Taiwan to show Beijing the dangers of doing so by allowing Taiwan to become a nuclear weapons power.
Primis Player Placeholder





6.3M

4.2K
Will Turkey Really Get an Aircraft Carrier Armed with F-35s?







The Clinton administration popularized the term “rogue regime” as a state that promoted terrorism or acted aggressively toward its neighbors but for political scientists, the origin of the concept was different. In 1977, for example, political scientist Richard K. Betts spoke wrote about nuclear ambitions among paranoid, pygmy, and pariah states. He defined both Israel and Taiwan as pariah states, not as a moral judgment, but rather because neighboring and regional states posed existential challenges to their national status. Two years later, the New York Times wrote about Israel, Taiwan, and South Africa as “nuclear outcasts” because they might require nuclear weapons to deter existential challenges.
SPONSORED CONTENT
Stay Safe, Stay Home
Super research versus super germs
Learn More
Only new antibiotics help against antibiotic-resistant germs. And they need to be better, too. ""PK150"" could be the penicillin of tomor…Merck

Most Dangerous Selfies Ever TakenMost Dangerous Selfies Ever TakenFar & Wide
VMworld - הכנס הטכנולוגי של השנה יוצא לדרך! הירשמו עכשיוVMworld - הכנס הטכנולוגי של השנה יוצא לדרך! הירשמו עכשיו
Register Now
VMworld by VMware


While Israel has never signed the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) and so is not governed by its constraints, Taiwan’s nuclear program was in violation of its treaty obligations. In 1968, Taiwan—then recognized at the United Nations—as the legitimate government of China has signed the NPT and was a member of the International Atomic Energy Agency. Officially, when Washington and the United Nations shifted recognition of China from Taipei to Beijing, the United States and Taiwan agreed that Taiwan would continue to abide by the NPT. As Taiwan nevertheless quietly pursued a nuclear capability, the Clinton administration acted covertly to sabotage Taiwanese ambitions.
In hindsight, that was a mistake. If the Trump administration wishes to push back on Xi’s aggression, it is time to reconsider the interpretation of Taiwan’s NPT commitments, both in Washington and Taipei. After all, if the international community will not uphold its obligations to Taiwan, then Taiwan should not bend over backward to preserve an order in which the People’s Republic of China is deliberately ending.
SPONSORED CONTENT
Stay Safe, Stay Home
The King of Germany Will Accept Your Bank Deposits NowThe King of Germany Will Accept Your Bank Deposits NowBloomberg.com
Discover A More Secure Journey To Cloud Trusted By Thousands Of EnterprisesDiscover A More Secure Journey To Cloud Trusted By Thousands Of EnterprisesIBM
They Have More Money Than Anyone on EarthThey Have More Money Than Anyone on EarthWork + Money

Should Taiwan start from scratch and indigenously build its program, it might precipitate further communist Chinese aggression. But, if Taiwan was gifted medium-range nuclear weapons which were placed under its control, it would both acquire a sufficient deterrent in order to maintain stability if not peace across the Taiwan Strait and absolve the United States of the need to deploy multiple carrier groups to the region should communist China attack the only remaining free and democratic Chinese republic.
Now is the time for hard decisions in Washington. If China digests Taiwan as it has Hong Kong, it is unlikely it will simply be satiated. As China faces its own economic turmoil, Xi can put forward baseless claims as fact and encroach further in Southeast Asia, the East China Sea, and the Pacific. And while Taiwan’s membership in the nuclear weapons club will be a blow to the spirit of the NPT, no country should be expected to sacrifice the freedom of 24 million people to preserve order and a system in which the international community lets Beijing deconstruct with ease.
The last I heard China is already a nuclear state :D
 

samsara

SENIOR MEMBER
Oct 28, 2016
2,327
7
6,869
Country
Lao Peoples Democratic Republic
Location
China
The island is too small to host any nuke arms. Just have no depth of landmass to secure any of that. One nuke explosion, the island is gone.
 

samsara

SENIOR MEMBER
Oct 28, 2016
2,327
7
6,869
Country
Lao Peoples Democratic Republic
Location
China
if israel can have the can too
Israel is a Rothschild's offspring. To build that Jew country in the land of the former Ottoman's province of Palestine, the Rothschild even arranged a World War I to destroy the Three Empires at that time: Ottoman; Hapsburg and Tsar Russia. Then followed by setting up the World War II involved the USA to help Britain against Germany in return for a favor of Balfour Declaration -- The Grand Deal of Centuries!. The Rothschild even instigated the Holocaust using the Nazi's hand to compel the European Jews to relocate to the Palestine land. Just like the Battle of Waterloo clashing the Britain vs Napoleon France, the Rothschilds played both sides in the WWII for their own agendas! Read here: https://www.savethemales.ca/000447.html

One may wish to look for the works and writing by the American famous historian, David Irving, with regard to the German-Jews-Holocaust real stories!

The Yellow Race in that island is nothing compared to the Anglo Rothschild's Chosen Tribe and nation!
 
Last edited:

kankan326

SENIOR MEMBER
Jun 7, 2011
2,690
-4
6,842
Country
China
Location
China
One of conditions that mainland China promised to immediately reunify Taiwan by force is: Taiwan plans to own nuke weapon.
 

Pandora

SENIOR MEMBER
Feb 15, 2013
6,289
7
9,361
Country
Pakistan
Location
Australia
If any one country is allowed to have nukes then it will spur development of nukes across the globe. Only way a country can possess nukes is if current nuclear control regime become biased. There are several countries itching for a chance for US to be biased in favor of one country after that it will be free for all. US may help Taiwan with MOAB type bombs which is as deadly as a tactical nuke in order to bypass the dangers of nuclear proliferation. All that considering china will sit and watch while all this unravels. From what i see there will be major conflict soon in SCS.
 

hualushui

FULL MEMBER
Jul 3, 2019
1,005
-1
1,556
Country
China
Location
China
India, the United States, Israel, you can give nuclear weapons to Taiwan, hurry up and don’t hesitate.

You are all cowards, the mouth cannon is the most powerful :omghaha: :omghaha: :omghaha:
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)

Top