What's new

Why Pakistani Hindus leave their homes for India

Josef K

FULL MEMBER
Mar 18, 2015
505
-5
920
Country
India
Location
Saudi Arabia
Why Pakistani Hindus leave their homes for India - BBC News

Mala Das can just about write her name. At 16, this has been her greatest achievement. "When I came here I was completely unlettered. Today I can write my name," she says.
But Mala is still unsure about numbers - when asked about the year she came to India, she draws a blank.
Her family and neighbours say they arrived in 2011 from the Pakistani city of Hyderabad to escape "religious and cultural persecution and government apathy".

About 1,200 people, who have migrated from Pakistan in the past five years, are housed in three camps in Delhi and many say one of the biggest problems they faced back home was that they were unable to educate their children.

Bhagwan Das, who was among a group of 71 people who reached Delhi three weeks ago, has two growing children with no formal education. He says they were treated like "second-class citizens" in Pakistan.
"Our children don't feel welcome in schools there. Muslims taunt us for being Hindu. Our girls are also sexually harassed," Mr Das says.
There is a primary school in the migrant camp where children are taught how to read and write.

Rajwanti, 13, and other children in the camp allege that Hindu boys and girls are made to read the Quran (Muslim holy book) in Pakistani schools and that Muslim students laugh at their religious practices.
Mala says she is happy to see that Hindus in India can practice their religion openly. "Here Hindus pray without fear in temples and organise religious festivals outdoor. In Pakistan we prayed at home. If we went to temples, we avoided the gaze of our neighbours."
Ishwar Lal, 18, who came to Delhi five months ago, says he feels liberated in India. "We have full religious freedom here. We are free."

Moreover, he says, in India "everyone is respectful of each other's faith".
Pakistan was created in 1947 after being carved out of India's mainly Muslim areas. A huge exchange of population took place during the partition which was often bloody.
Today, Muslims constitute 14% of India's population, while in Pakistan, Hindus are said to be just over 2%.
There is no official estimate of the number of Pakistani Hindus living in India, but over the years, small groups have been crossing the border to reach Delhi or other northern states, such as Rajasthan and Haryana. Once in India, they apply for asylum and, eventually, citizenship.

Islamabad has repeatedly said its Hindu community is safe and reports of their leaving are exaggerated.
In a written reply to a BBC query, the Indian government has revealed that more than 1,400 Pakistanis have been given citizenship since 2011 and that an overwhelming majority of them are Hindus.
Those living in the Delhi camps, however, say they are yet to get Indian citizenship.
"We applied in 2011 but nothing has happened. The BJP government which claims to have sympathy for us is no different from other governments. We feel frustrated," says Arjun Das, who is regarded as the leader of Pakistani Hindus in Delhi camps.

Pahlaj, who arrived three weeks ago, says he is disappointed that "no Hindu leader or neighbour has visited us yet".
But most say they are happy to be in India where they feel "at home" and Pahlaj says most Pakistani Hindus want to leave their country.
"A small number has come to India. Millions of Pakistani Hindus are waiting for an opportunity to do the same."
 

The-king

BANNED
Sep 7, 2015
362
-1
389
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Arab Emirates
It is all about religion no but economics they find India more suitable because in Indian they granted refugee status lot of sympathies and many economic benefits for being suppressed and deprived. If you go logical you will find most of them jobless and have no property or anything valuable, you may fail to find any wealthy or middle class family that moved from Pakistan to India. If we / Pakistani are so hostile towards them why not these wealthy or middle class move to India ? As i mentioned above its all about opportunist choice OK move to India get the benefits. India must check before giving them refugee status either their stories are correct or biased because they are availing the benefits meant for really needy persons in India.
@WAJsal @Spectre
Would you people like to add your views on this.
 

Spectre

SENIOR MEMBER
Jun 4, 2015
3,735
46
6,087
Country
India
Location
India
It is all about religion no but economics they find India more suitable because in Indian they granted refugee status lot of sympathies and many economic benefits for being suppressed and deprived. If you go logical you will find most of them jobless and have no property or anything valuable, you may fail to find any wealthy or middle class family that moved from Pakistan to India. If we / Pakistani are so hostile towards them why not these wealthy or middle class move to India ? As i mentioned above its all about opportunist choice OK move to India get the benefits. India must check before giving them refugee status either their stories are correct or biased because they are availing the benefits meant for really needy persons in India.
@WAJsal @Spectre
Would you people like to add your views on this.
I apologize but I have no first hand of knowledge about life in Pakistan, let alone quality of life of Hindus in Pakistan hence any comment I make would be based on hearsay and may be motivated second hand accounts.

That said - it is true that these people would benefit from outpouring of public sympathy and be hailed as lost brethren. I am not sure about their economic standing in Pakistan but even if what you say is true then also it is certainly not easy to be a Hindu in Pakistan. The minuscule numbers of Hindus in Pakistan denies them even the comfort of strong community able to protect itself which Muslims in India have in addition there seems to be visceral hatred of Hindus among many Pakistanis as is evident from the posts on PDF and social media in general as they associate Hindus with India same as many people associate Muslims with Pakistanis in India.

So to end I would say it is unfair to term this people as opportunists seeking economic migration alone without doing a thorough due diligence and it is alright if GoI gives them the benefit of doubt.

Regards
 
Last edited:

cloud_9

SENIOR MEMBER
Jul 16, 2010
4,919
-2
5,045
Country
India
Location
New Zealand
It is all about religion no but economics they find India more suitable because in Indian they granted refugee status lot of sympathies and many economic benefits for being suppressed and deprived. If you go logical you will find most of them jobless and have no property or anything valuable, you may fail to find any wealthy or middle class family that moved from Pakistan to India. If we / Pakistani are so hostile towards them why not these wealthy or middle class move to India ? As i mentioned above its all about opportunist choice OK move to India get the benefits. India must check before giving them refugee status either their stories are correct or biased because they are availing the benefits meant for really needy persons in India.
@WAJsal @Spectre
Would you people like to add your views on this.
It's "India" we are talking about, not"Germany" or "UK".
They are moving to India to save their lives while leaving their homes and lands back in Pakistan.
 

Politico

FULL MEMBER
Sep 3, 2015
1,640
-5
1,878
Country
India
Location
South Africa
i have hindu friend in pakistan who say this all nonsense. my friend will also not visit stinkhole called india :lol:
 

wadi79

BANNED
May 1, 2014
346
-7
867
Country
India
Location
India
Why Pakistani Hindus leave their homes for India - BBC News

Mala Das can just about write her name. At 16, this has been her greatest achievement. "When I came here I was completely unlettered. Today I can write my name," she says.
But Mala is still unsure about numbers - when asked about the year she came to India, she draws a blank.
Her family and neighbours say they arrived in 2011 from the Pakistani city of Hyderabad to escape "religious and cultural persecution and government apathy".

About 1,200 people, who have migrated from Pakistan in the past five years, are housed in three camps in Delhi and many say one of the biggest problems they faced back home was that they were unable to educate their children.

Bhagwan Das, who was among a group of 71 people who reached Delhi three weeks ago, has two growing children with no formal education. He says they were treated like "second-class citizens" in Pakistan.
"Our children don't feel welcome in schools there. Muslims taunt us for being Hindu. Our girls are also sexually harassed," Mr Das says.
There is a primary school in the migrant camp where children are taught how to read and write.

Rajwanti, 13, and other children in the camp allege that Hindu boys and girls are made to read the Quran (Muslim holy book) in Pakistani schools and that Muslim students laugh at their religious practices.
Mala says she is happy to see that Hindus in India can practice their religion openly. "Here Hindus pray without fear in temples and organise religious festivals outdoor. In Pakistan we prayed at home. If we went to temples, we avoided the gaze of our neighbours."
Ishwar Lal, 18, who came to Delhi five months ago, says he feels liberated in India. "We have full religious freedom here. We are free."

Moreover, he says, in India "everyone is respectful of each other's faith".
Pakistan was created in 1947 after being carved out of India's mainly Muslim areas. A huge exchange of population took place during the partition which was often bloody.
Today, Muslims constitute 14% of India's population, while in Pakistan, Hindus are said to be just over 2%.
There is no official estimate of the number of Pakistani Hindus living in India, but over the years, small groups have been crossing the border to reach Delhi or other northern states, such as Rajasthan and Haryana. Once in India, they apply for asylum and, eventually, citizenship.

Islamabad has repeatedly said its Hindu community is safe and reports of their leaving are exaggerated.
In a written reply to a BBC query, the Indian government has revealed that more than 1,400 Pakistanis have been given citizenship since 2011 and that an overwhelming majority of them are Hindus.
Those living in the Delhi camps, however, say they are yet to get Indian citizenship.
"We applied in 2011 but nothing has happened. The BJP government which claims to have sympathy for us is no different from other governments. We feel frustrated," says Arjun Das, who is regarded as the leader of Pakistani Hindus in Delhi camps.

Pahlaj, who arrived three weeks ago, says he is disappointed that "no Hindu leader or neighbour has visited us yet".
But most say they are happy to be in India where they feel "at home" and Pahlaj says most Pakistani Hindus want to leave their country.
"A small number has come to India. Millions of Pakistani Hindus are waiting for an opportunity to do the same."
Despite all the so called oppression of Muslims in India, as claimed by Pakistan, we don't see any Indian Muslim refugees going to the stinkhole that was allegedly created in their name. Indian Muslims continue to remain proud citizens of India, and long may they prosper. Meanwhile, the land of peace and tolerance, milk and honey, blasphemy and AK47, suicide bombers and Taliban continues to see desperate refugees trickling out. I think this is all a plot by CIA/Mossad/RAW to defame Pakistan.

Pakistan isn't the country that officially, in its constitution, discriminates against people based on religion/sect. So the question of discrimination doesn't arise.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)

Top