What's new

When India Invaded Pakistan

S_O_C_O_M

SENIOR MEMBER
Jun 14, 2010
2,476
0
2,112
When India Invaded Pakistan

Submitted by Aurangzeb on September 8, 2012 – 1:39 am



PKKH Exclusive | By Atiq Durrani

“We are at war” Pakistani President Ayub Khan made an emergency broadcast to the nation on 6th September 1965. He said the Indian attack was proof of the evil intentions which India had always harbored against Pakistan.

Since August 1965 tensions between India and Pakistan was high because of the Kashmir issue. India alleged Pakistan had sent militants to Kashmir to fight against Indian Army. Pakistan claimed it was a local uprising against India’s atrocities.

The issue was raised in different international forums and India assured at these forums that India will not cross the international borders. But at the midnight between 05 and 06 September 1965, Indian army invaded West Pakistan, crossing the international border at three points.



Who started the war?

BBC News on 6th Sep, 1965 reported India-Pakistan war as: “Indian Army invades W.Pakistan”.

According to BBC News “Indian troops have invaded West Pakistan, crossing the border at three points in an attack which appears to be aimed mainly at the city of Lahore. Authorities in Delhi say their action was intended to prevent a direct attack by Pakistani forces against India.”

One of the reasons India’s then Defense Minister Yashwantrao Chavan gave for crossing international borders and invading Pakistan was that “It was quite apparent Pakistan’s next move was to attack Punjab across the international frontier.”

But in reality when India crossed Pakistani border in Punjab and arrived in Batapur, Pakistani army was not even prepared for war. Pakistan believed that India will not cross the border after assurance at international forums. When Indian’s didn’t find much resistance at border they thought it must be a trap, and become more careful which ultimately affected their pace of attack and the Pakistan Army got some time to prepare, defend and counter attack. This clearly shows that Pakistani Army was not having any intentions to cross the international border.

Later as a result of counterattack by Pakistan near the west bank of the BRB Canal, at the border of India and Pakistan. Major General Prasad’s entourage itself was ambushed and he was forced to flee his vehicle.

Other reason that Indian Army gave for invading Pakistan is that Pakistan was involved in the uprising in Kashmir and alleged that Pakistan had sent militants in Kashmir to fight against Indian Army. Pakistan stand on this issue was that Kashmir is a disputed territory and whatever happens in Kashmir cannot be dubbed as a war.

BBC News also stated that ceasefire line was established in 1949 after the first Indo-Pakistan war, into Indian-administered Jammu and Kashmir. Since then there have been a number of clashes along the ceasefire line, there had been a few minor clashes in the Rann of Kutch too, but this is the first time Indian troops have crossed into West Pakistan in what is being seen as an act of war.

On the other side before the start of all-out war, Indian Prime Minister Lal Bhadur Shastri had said “We will open the front of our choice”. Similarly The Indian chief of army staff Joyanto Nath Chowdhuri had said: “I’ll have a bada (large) peg in the Lahore Gymkhana.” All these statements are recorded in history but what happened was completely against the wishes of Indian government and Indian Army. Pakistan Army completely destroyed their dreams.

It is obvious from the above facts that India is the one who started the war and invaded Pakistan.

When India invaded Pakistan

After the Indian invasion Pakistan Army not only defended its borders against the much mightier Indian Army but it also moved into the Indian Territory and claimed to have captured 1075 km2 of Indian territory.

Time magazine reported that “despite claims from both sides the awkward fact is that Khemkaran is under Pakistan administration.”

The London Daily Mirror reported: “There is a smell of death in the burning Pakistan sun. For it was here that India’s attacking forces came to a dead stop.”

“By all accounts the courage displayed by the Pakistan Air Force pilots is reminiscent of the bravery of the few young and dedicated pilots who saved this country from Nazi invaders in the critical Battle of Britain during the last war.” stated Patrick Seale, in The Observer, London on September 12, 1965.

In Times reporter Louis Karrar wrote: “Who can defeat a nation which knows how to play hide and seek with death”.

“Pakistan claims to have destroyed something like 1/3rd the Indian Air Force, and foreign observers, who are in a position to know say that Pakistani pilots have claimed even higher kills than this; but the Pakistani Air Force are being scrupulously honest in evaluating these claims. They are crediting Pakistan Air Force only those killings that can be checked from other sources.” said Roy Meloni on American Broadcasting Corporation (September 15, 1965).

“During the night they threw in every reinforcement they could find. But wave after wave of attacks were repulsed by the Pakistanis” “India is being soundly beaten by a nation which is outnumbered by four and a half to one in population and three to one in size of armed forces.” said the London Daily Times.

USA – Aviation Week & Space Technology – said in December 1968 issue “For the PAF, the 1965 war as climatic as the Israeli victory over the Arabs in 1967. A further similarity was that Indian air power had an approximately 5:1 numerical superiority at the start of the conflict. Unlike the Middle East conflict, the Pakistani air victory was achieved to a large degree by air-to-air combat rather than on a air-to-ground one. But it was as absolute as that attained by Israel.”

Indian failure can also be assessed by the Official History of the 1965 War drafted by the Ministry of Defense of India in 1992. According to this document, on September 22 when the Security Council was pressurizing both the countries for the ceasefire, Indian Prime Minister asked commanding Gen. Chaudhuri if India could possible win the war. The general urged negotiations for ceasefire and replied that most of India’s frontline ammunition had been used up and the Indian Army had suffered considerable tank losses. But later it was determined that till that time India had used only 14% of its frontline ammunition.

On the other side our then foreign minister Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto declared in a very emotional speech at the UN Security Council that “If needed, for Kashmir we would fight a war for a thousand years” although Pakistan had used 80% of its frontline ammunition till that time. But the nation was still determined to fight. That was the main difference between the morale of Indian and Pakistani people which was sky-high at our end.

The war lasted till September 22, 1965, when a ceasefire was declared due to the intervention of the United Nations and it was decided that on the International border pre-war positions should be held by the both countries.

It can be concluded that Pakistan was invaded by India and Pakistan successfully defended its borders. Many Pakistanis and international analysts considered the performance of Pakistani military to be positive. September 6 is celebrated as Defense Day in Pakistan, in commemoration of the successful defense of Lahore against the Indian army. The performance of the Pakistani Air Force, in particular, was praised. Kashmir issue was once again highlighted in the international forums and United Nations passed four resolutions (210,211,214 and 215) on this issue.

Maj. Raja Aziz Bhatti was awarded with Nishan-e-Haider and became the hero of Pakistan who died defending the lines near Lahore. Many stories of bravery and patriotism emerged from the battle field. It was first time that Pakistan was invaded and the people of Pakistan were standing united with the soldiers of Pakistan Army to defend their country. Today again we are under attack by the enemies of Pakistan from Inside as well as outside Pakistan. Our spirits should be the same as it was in 1965 so that we can again defend our homeland and tell our enemies that we were united and we are united to defend our Pakistan.

When India Invaded Pakistan | PKKH.tv
 

T90TankGuy

ELITE MEMBER
Aug 12, 2010
9,409
8
11,280
Country
India
Location
India
do you have any links which are not pakistani which say we started the war? even the one of the bbc mentioned in the article will do:)
 

MandarK

FULL MEMBER
Aug 10, 2012
887
-11
866
Country
India
Location
India
^^^When Pakistani infiltrators attacked Kashmir, India attacked Pakistan :lol:

Its funny that people say that pakistan can attack from kashmir because LoC is not an international border but India should not attack from Punjab and Rajasthan border as these are international borders....bahiyo hamne kya Morality ka Jhanda utha rakha hai?? Attack chahe LoC pe ho ya IB pe......reply to milega he.....
 

WAR-rior

SENIOR MEMBER
Nov 26, 2010
4,861
-15
4,667
Country
India
Location
France
Different places. Different History.

Above all, the fact remains that the version of a democratic nation >> version of a dictatorship where All news are filtered as per own convinience.
 

Shardul.....the lion

SENIOR MEMBER
Jul 15, 2011
3,074
-1
2,354
Country
India
Location
India
So if India attacks gilgit, baltistan and other kasmiri areas today, it will not be called attack on Pakistan because its just crossing of LOC. Dont know why Vajpayee respected the LOC so much during kargil war, because even we had crossed LOC Aurangzeb would have said India has not attacked Pakistan.
 
Feb 13, 2012
1,258
0
1,492
Let 1965 be a very permanent reminder of what can happen if you guys illegally train and send terrorists to Kashmir, or try to stab India when it isnt looking from the backside to invade Kashmir :police:
 

PlanetWarrior

SENIOR MEMBER
Oct 23, 2009
6,096
-2
8,793
Country
India
Location
Zimbabwe
First you send your troops and goons into our Kashmir and then expect us to sit back and hand out chappatis to them. Then we go to Lahore and you call us back stabbing evil Yindoos. Man, when will this end ?
 

AUz

ELITE MEMBER
Sep 14, 2010
8,342
-12
14,171
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
^^^When Pakistani infiltrators attacked Kashmir, India attacked Pakistan :lol:

Its funny that people say that pakistan can attack from kashmir because LoC is not an international border but India should not attack from Punjab and Rajasthan border as these are international borders....bahiyo hamne kya Morality ka Jhanda utha rakha hai?? Attack chahe LoC pe ho ya IB pe......reply to milega he.....
Exactly.

Indian started the war , not Pakistan. So please tell this to your poor brainwashed masses.... Pakistan was just creating a low-level insurgency in Kashmir (Not even mainland India) ... We also think that India is creating insurgency in Balochistan...but we don't invade Indian international borders...

Indian invasion of Lahore is what formally started 1965 war ... which ended in Pakistan's military victory as Pakistan defeated Indian attack on Lahore city and forced indians to retreat , captured strategically important Indian towns like Khem Kharan , captured strategically important Indian supply-lines like Muna Bao railway station , PAF just badly battered five times larger IAF , and all this eventually forced India to face the humiliation of signing an agreement of stalemate with SEVEN TIMES smaller nation-that was badly outgunned and outnumbered during the war... Your OWN media back then called it as "giving a walkover to Pakistan." :agree:

So we have no problem with your 'reply' ...but just don't brainwashed your masses that Pakistan started the war. It was aggressor India who invaded the West Pakistan.:)
 

Bang Galore

ELITE MEMBER
Feb 21, 2010
10,685
12
22,736
Country
India
Location
India
Exactly.

Indian started the war , not Pakistan. So please tell this to your poor brainwashed masses.... Pakistan was just creating a low-level insurgency in Kashmir (Not even mainland India) ... We also think that India is creating insurgency in Balochistan...but we don't invade Indian international borders...

Indian invasion of Lahore is what formally started 1965 war ... which ended in Pakistan's military victory as Pakistan defeated Indian attack on Lahore city and forced indians to retreat , captured strategic towns like Khem Kharan , captured strategically important supply-lines like Muna Bao railway station , PAF just badly battered five times larger IAF , and all this forced India to face the humiliation of signing an agreement of stalemate with SEVEN TIMES smaller nation-that was badly outgunned and outnumbered during the war...

So we have no problem with your 'reply' ...but just don't brainwashed your masses that Pakistan started the war. It was India who invaded West Pakistan.

Err chap...I like your idea of what constitutes winning. Some 65 years after independence, we still have our part of Kashmir which after all was what you were after. So...yeah..you won all wars with India & we just held on to Kashmir...Fair enough ! May Pakistan win a 100 more victories like that of..err...1965 ?? Surely the greatest of military victories.:enjoy:
 
Feb 13, 2012
1,258
0
1,492
Exactly.

Indian started the war , not Pakistan. So please tell this to your poor brainwashed masses.... Pakistan was just creating a low-level insurgency in Kashmir (Not even mainland India) ... We also think that India is creating insurgency in Balochistan...but we don't invade Indian international borders...

Indian invasion of Lahore is what formally started 1965 war ... which ended in Pakistan's military victory as Pakistan defeated Indian attack on Lahore city and forced indians to retreat , captured strategically important Indian towns like Khem Kharan , captured strategically important Indian supply-lines like Muna Bao railway station , PAF just badly battered five times larger IAF , and all this eventually forced India to face the humiliation of signing an agreement of stalemate with SEVEN TIMES smaller nation-that was badly outgunned and outnumbered during the war... Your OWN media back then called it as "giving a walkover to Pakistan." :agree:

So we have no problem with your 'reply' ...but just don't brainwashed your masses that Pakistan started the war. It was aggressor India who invaded the West Pakistan.:)
Article 370 clearly states Kashmri as being an "integral" part of India. An attack on Kashmir will be treated no diferent than an attack in Delhi/Mumbai/Kolkata/Chennai. You learned that the hard way in 1965, but forgot the lessons very quickly in Kargil. Lets see how long it takes for you to forget this again, as we are always willing to refresh your memory if old age happens to be failing you :cheers:
 

Contrarian

ELITE MEMBER
Oct 23, 2006
11,572
4
10,721
Pakistani's start the wars, then when they fail in each objective, end up defending their 2nd or 3rd most important city, they say they didnt lose because India didnt destroy us completely and signed a cease fire agreement!

What amazing logic! Pakistani's do have this thing. Every Pakistani truly believes that they didnt lose the wars with India. That they are fighting an enemy '7 times larger'.

And the golden piece is When asked what has Pakistan got to show for itself after 65 years of independence? What has Pakistan achieved?

Pat comes the reply - We are still existing! After 65 years, the only achievement is a nuclear bomb and the existence of Pakistan (which mind you is under no threat whatsoever until Pakistan only decides to wage war on its neighbours!!)
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)

Top