What's new

Thank you, Mr Modi!

Norwegian

BANNED
Aug 19, 2014
11,860
9
18,057
Country
Pakistan
Location
Norway
Thank you, Mr Modi
By Rizwan Mehboob
Published: July 6, 2015

The writer is a public policy expert

For many Pakistanis, Mr Modi, it all began with that infamous pronouncement from one of your illustrious predecessors. “We have drowned the Pakistani ideology in the Indian Ocean” was how Indira Gandhi bragged about the events of 1971. As we tried to reconcile with the reality of the dismemberment of Pakistan, our national outlook on the Pakistani ideology started undergoing a transition. The majority amongst us chose to remain loyal to this notion just like faithful sailors on board a storm-hit ship who refuse to get away on lifeboats. But there were others amongst us who sought to question this ideology by reaching out to the safety of the lifeboats of pragmatic notions, such as softening of borders and harping on about shared cultures between India and Pakistan.

And it is about these exchanges over the last four decades, between us on the storm-hit ship, and the wise lifeboat people that I will tell you, my dear Mr Modi. The first thing that the lifeboat people kept harping about was that the predicament of our ship was not a phenomenon resulting from 1971. We were informed that the ship should, in fact, not have taken sail in 1947 in the first place. We were told that our ship – the Pakistani ideology – was actually an artificial after-thought by a band of zealots, who were completely divorced from the vision of our founding fathers.

And to the collective dismay of those glued to the storm-hit ship, the lifeboat people also started, what they termed, was the deconstruction of myths about our national history. They took pains to convince us that our founding fathers had no intention of according central significance to religion in our national life. We were told to forget the butchering of hundreds of thousands during Partition and rather focus on one speech amongst hundreds made by the Father of the Nation, to prove that there was a disconnect between our ideology and Pakistan. And, I must admit, my faith in the Pakistani ideology was shaken a bit. The lifeboat people also started enlightening us on the nexus between this faulty ideology and security paradigms and that there was an unwarranted build-up of security apparatus at the cost of the wellbeing of billions in this region. Ceremonies, such as the Wagah border flag-lowering every evening, were termed uncalled for events, scaring peace-loving doves on both sides.

Every now and then, these doves would cross the border, dancing and chanting songs of peace. Our faith in the Pakistani ideology would be further diluted as we were told stories of the love which they received on the other side of border. The blood spilt during Partition, the three India-Pakistan wars, Kashmir, the Bangladesh debacle — all of these were fast becoming hazy in contrast to the colours of peace that these doves painted.

But then came you, Mr Modi and that picture. We saw you smiling as you received souvenirs from the Bangladeshi prime minster for services rendered during the unfortunate 1971 saga. We could not miss the scorn, the venom, which came shrieking out of that picture. The lancet cut you jointly administered to us with your Bangladeshi counterpart through that picture has been a blessing in disguise. Our faith in the Two-Nation Theory and the Pakistani ideology is reborn. Our commitment to uphold democratic values as the best guarantee against shenanigans of incompetent rulers will never again be lost on us. We are reminded how important it is to stand behind our soldiers who would always be our ultimate line of defence against the wiles of unrelenting foes.

So, Mr Modi, we will always remember this picture of yours and liken it to the picture of Dorian Gray, reminding us of the collective sins of our adversaries, perpetrated to soil the intrinsic beauty of our cherished ideology. Let me also assure you that the next time we visit the Wagah border, we will chant Pakistan Zindabad slogans at the top of our voices so that we are heard – and clearly understood – on your side of the border.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 6th, 2015.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
Thank you, Mr Modi - The Express Tribune

So Modi ji wasn't that bad for Pakistan after all! :smitten:
 

VCheng

ELITE MEMBER
Sep 29, 2010
38,978
54
33,365
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
Let me also assure you that the next time we visit the Wagah border, we will chant Pakistan Zindabad slogans at the top of our voices so that we are heard – and clearly understood – on your side of the border.
But chanting slogans without the hard work to back them up does not mean much.
 

ito

ELITE MEMBER
Jun 5, 2014
9,186
-33
10,891
Country
India
Location
India
Isn't it is a defeat of two nation theory as implied by the OP?...what Islam could not do to keep Pakistan united, India is doing to keep Pakistan united. The guy who wrote the article is confused.
 

Foxtrot-Bravo

FULL MEMBER
Jul 4, 2015
1,079
2
1,100
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Isn't it is a defeat of two nation theory as implied by the OP?...what Islam could not do to keep Pakistan united, India is doing to keep Pakistan united. The guy who wrote the article is confused.

If this is unity, I would love to unite India into Khalistan.
 

xyxmt

BANNED
Apr 27, 2012
21,412
-5
18,891
Country
Pakistan
Location
Canada
Thank you, Mr Modi
By Rizwan Mehboob
Published: July 6, 2015

The writer is a public policy expert

For many Pakistanis, Mr Modi, it all began with that infamous pronouncement from one of your illustrious predecessors. “We have drowned the Pakistani ideology in the Indian Ocean” was how Indira Gandhi bragged about the events of 1971. As we tried to reconcile with the reality of the dismemberment of Pakistan, our national outlook on the Pakistani ideology started undergoing a transition. The majority amongst us chose to remain loyal to this notion just like faithful sailors on board a storm-hit ship who refuse to get away on lifeboats. But there were others amongst us who sought to question this ideology by reaching out to the safety of the lifeboats of pragmatic notions, such as softening of borders and harping on about shared cultures between India and Pakistan.

And it is about these exchanges over the last four decades, between us on the storm-hit ship, and the wise lifeboat people that I will tell you, my dear Mr Modi. The first thing that the lifeboat people kept harping about was that the predicament of our ship was not a phenomenon resulting from 1971. We were informed that the ship should, in fact, not have taken sail in 1947 in the first place. We were told that our ship – the Pakistani ideology – was actually an artificial after-thought by a band of zealots, who were completely divorced from the vision of our founding fathers.

And to the collective dismay of those glued to the storm-hit ship, the lifeboat people also started, what they termed, was the deconstruction of myths about our national history. They took pains to convince us that our founding fathers had no intention of according central significance to religion in our national life. We were told to forget the butchering of hundreds of thousands during Partition and rather focus on one speech amongst hundreds made by the Father of the Nation, to prove that there was a disconnect between our ideology and Pakistan. And, I must admit, my faith in the Pakistani ideology was shaken a bit. The lifeboat people also started enlightening us on the nexus between this faulty ideology and security paradigms and that there was an unwarranted build-up of security apparatus at the cost of the wellbeing of billions in this region. Ceremonies, such as the Wagah border flag-lowering every evening, were termed uncalled for events, scaring peace-loving doves on both sides.

Every now and then, these doves would cross the border, dancing and chanting songs of peace. Our faith in the Pakistani ideology would be further diluted as we were told stories of the love which they received on the other side of border. The blood spilt during Partition, the three India-Pakistan wars, Kashmir, the Bangladesh debacle — all of these were fast becoming hazy in contrast to the colours of peace that these doves painted.

But then came you, Mr Modi and that picture. We saw you smiling as you received souvenirs from the Bangladeshi prime minster for services rendered during the unfortunate 1971 saga. We could not miss the scorn, the venom, which came shrieking out of that picture. The lancet cut you jointly administered to us with your Bangladeshi counterpart through that picture has been a blessing in disguise. Our faith in the Two-Nation Theory and the Pakistani ideology is reborn. Our commitment to uphold democratic values as the best guarantee against shenanigans of incompetent rulers will never again be lost on us. We are reminded how important it is to stand behind our soldiers who would always be our ultimate line of defence against the wiles of unrelenting foes.

So, Mr Modi, we will always remember this picture of yours and liken it to the picture of Dorian Gray, reminding us of the collective sins of our adversaries, perpetrated to soil the intrinsic beauty of our cherished ideology. Let me also assure you that the next time we visit the Wagah border, we will chant Pakistan Zindabad slogans at the top of our voices so that we are heard – and clearly understood – on your side of the border.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 6th, 2015.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
Thank you, Mr Modi - The Express Tribune

So Modi ji wasn't that bad for Pakistan after all! :smitten:
He is soo good for Pakistan we will know it clearly after his 5 years. Seems like he is working for Pakistani foreign policy, its his brilliant leadership that Russian are now supporting Pakistan on international level. I always said Modi will be good for Pakistan even before he was elected, all nationalist leaders in the end fcuk up their country and with the grace of Allah Modi will do the same.
 

Foxtrot-Bravo

FULL MEMBER
Jul 4, 2015
1,079
2
1,100
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
He is soo good for Pakistan we will know it clearly after his 5 years. Seems like he is working for Pakistani foreign policy, its his brilliant leadership that Russian are now supporting Pakistan on international level.
and are ignoring them on International level, offcourse.
 

my2cents

SENIOR MEMBER
Apr 8, 2011
4,199
-5
2,121
Country
United States
Location
India
Isn't it is a defeat of two nation theory as implied by the OP?...what Islam could not do to keep Pakistan united, India is doing to keep Pakistan united. The guy who wrote the article is confused.
You hit the second nail on the coffin. They keep harping on their failed ideology to be relevant.
 
Last edited:

Kaniska

ELITE MEMBER
Apr 11, 2011
9,070
4
8,322
Country
United States
Location
India
Trust me..I am not sure why people think that Two nation theory is wrong..It might be the perception of people from Congress party of India..But for me and many people like us, We should give credit to Mr Jinha who really make it happen....Two nation theory was a necessity and Gandhi was crazy and lack foresight who could not foresee at that point of time...
 

OrionHunter

ELITE MEMBER
May 28, 2011
13,820
-5
23,056
Country
India
Location
India
Let me also assure you that the next time we visit the Wagah border, we will chant Pakistan Zindabad slogans at the top of our voices so that we are heard – and clearly understood – on your side of the border.
So what's new? It's a ritual done every time during the ceremony! :P And we do it too, shouting slogans at the top of our voices - Bharat Mata Ki Jai! :D
 

MilSpec

BANNED
Feb 19, 2011
12,296
36
22,485
Country
India
Location
United States
Dude, chanting slogans IS a hard work in itself. Haven't you tried it sometimes? :sarcastic:


Yepp! A symbol of liberation from West Pakistan!
In the article, which founding father/s is the writer referring to?

If it was remotely related to progressive federation for Muslim minorities of Indian Subcontinent as proposed by M.A Jinnah, then that ship has indeed sailed the day Ayub Khan set that ideology in the trash can and subsequently stomped upon by dictator after dictator, and not a single Pakistani till date hasn't objected....

And btw, as far as Founding Fathers in plural sense is concerned, most of them originated from present day Bangladesh, where was the towering respect for these founding fathers when the region they belonged to was deliberately subjugated to inequality both economically, militarily and politically from day one?
 

HariPrasad

BANNED
Aug 5, 2013
14,081
-22
12,205
Country
India
Location
India
Thank you, Mr Modi
By Rizwan Mehboob
Published: July 6, 2015

The writer is a public policy expert

For many Pakistanis, Mr Modi, it all began with that infamous pronouncement from one of your illustrious predecessors. “We have drowned the Pakistani ideology in the Indian Ocean” was how Indira Gandhi bragged about the events of 1971. As we tried to reconcile with the reality of the dismemberment of Pakistan, our national outlook on the Pakistani ideology started undergoing a transition. The majority amongst us chose to remain loyal to this notion just like faithful sailors on board a storm-hit ship who refuse to get away on lifeboats. But there were others amongst us who sought to question this ideology by reaching out to the safety of the lifeboats of pragmatic notions, such as softening of borders and harping on about shared cultures between India and Pakistan.

And it is about these exchanges over the last four decades, between us on the storm-hit ship, and the wise lifeboat people that I will tell you, my dear Mr Modi. The first thing that the lifeboat people kept harping about was that the predicament of our ship was not a phenomenon resulting from 1971. We were informed that the ship should, in fact, not have taken sail in 1947 in the first place. We were told that our ship – the Pakistani ideology – was actually an artificial after-thought by a band of zealots, who were completely divorced from the vision of our founding fathers.

And to the collective dismay of those glued to the storm-hit ship, the lifeboat people also started, what they termed, was the deconstruction of myths about our national history. They took pains to convince us that our founding fathers had no intention of according central significance to religion in our national life. We were told to forget the butchering of hundreds of thousands during Partition and rather focus on one speech amongst hundreds made by the Father of the Nation, to prove that there was a disconnect between our ideology and Pakistan. And, I must admit, my faith in the Pakistani ideology was shaken a bit. The lifeboat people also started enlightening us on the nexus between this faulty ideology and security paradigms and that there was an unwarranted build-up of security apparatus at the cost of the wellbeing of billions in this region. Ceremonies, such as the Wagah border flag-lowering every evening, were termed uncalled for events, scaring peace-loving doves on both sides.

Every now and then, these doves would cross the border, dancing and chanting songs of peace. Our faith in the Pakistani ideology would be further diluted as we were told stories of the love which they received on the other side of border. The blood spilt during Partition, the three India-Pakistan wars, Kashmir, the Bangladesh debacle — all of these were fast becoming hazy in contrast to the colours of peace that these doves painted.

But then came you, Mr Modi and that picture. We saw you smiling as you received souvenirs from the Bangladeshi prime minster for services rendered during the unfortunate 1971 saga. We could not miss the scorn, the venom, which came shrieking out of that picture. The lancet cut you jointly administered to us with your Bangladeshi counterpart through that picture has been a blessing in disguise. Our faith in the Two-Nation Theory and the Pakistani ideology is reborn. Our commitment to uphold democratic values as the best guarantee against shenanigans of incompetent rulers will never again be lost on us. We are reminded how important it is to stand behind our soldiers who would always be our ultimate line of defence against the wiles of unrelenting foes.

So, Mr Modi, we will always remember this picture of yours and liken it to the picture of Dorian Gray, reminding us of the collective sins of our adversaries, perpetrated to soil the intrinsic beauty of our cherished ideology. Let me also assure you that the next time we visit the Wagah border, we will chant Pakistan Zindabad slogans at the top of our voices so that we are heard – and clearly understood – on your side of the border.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 6th, 2015.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
Thank you, Mr Modi - The Express Tribune

So Modi ji wasn't that bad for Pakistan after all! :smitten:
Writer discovers so much of consolation.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)

Top