What's new

Supreme Court Decision on Presidential Reference

Sugarcane

ELITE MEMBER
Jun 2, 2011
20,918
29
41,322
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
1652798820293.png
 

Asimzranger

SENIOR MEMBER
Oct 6, 2016
3,538
5
7,926
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Disagree

PDM was smart enough not to use PTI dissenters vote for the National Assembly which means Shahbaz Sharif stays in power

PDM used PTI dissenters vote in Punjab Assembly to make Hamza the CM, that means Hamza will be deseated because those votes are invalid. CM Punjab is the most powerful person after the PM, if you have Punjab you have 60% of Pakistan
looks like reelection for cm Punjab minus the 26 deviant members of pti.
 

insight-out

FULL MEMBER
Sep 16, 2009
981
2
1,494
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Disagree

PDM was smart enough not to use PTI dissenters vote for the National Assembly which means Shahbaz Sharif stays in power

PDM used PTI dissenters vote in Punjab Assembly to make Hamza the CM, that means Hamza will be deseated because those votes are invalid. CM Punjab is the most powerful person after the PM, if you have Punjab you have 60% of Pakistan
You're right, at the federal level, PDM did not use the votes of PTI dissenters. But I believe they used two of PML-Q's votes. I am not sure about the law, but they certainly have lost moral authority to form government. I don't think they care about morals though.
 

Salza

ELITE MEMBER
Dec 20, 2014
9,730
0
15,905
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Breaking :

Ex Finance minister Hafeez Sheikh arrives in Karachi from Dubai.

Caretaker FM or pm
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20220517_195800_648.jpg
    IMG_20220517_195800_648.jpg
    319.1 KB · Views: 7

IceCold

PDF VETERAN
May 1, 2007
18,754
10
24,145
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Disagree

PDM was smart enough not to use PTI dissenters vote for the National Assembly which means Shahbaz Sharif stays in power

PDM used PTI dissenters vote in Punjab Assembly to make Hamza the CM, that means Hamza will be deseated because those votes are invalid. CM Punjab is the most powerful person after the PM, if you have Punjab you have 60% of Pakistan
True! but this also makes crime Minister subject to more blackmailing from allies as they now know that now if any single one backs out, shahbaz goes. So if Shahbaz has any and i mean even an ounce of sense left, he should immediately dissolve assemblies.
 

Savak

FULL MEMBER

New Recruit

Aug 14, 2018
77
1
134
Country
Pakistan
Location
Canada
I wonder if this is the establishment acknowledgement that they made a mistake by backing the PDM on the no confidence motion and seeing the massive public backing for IK and the confusion, indecision, badniyati in the PDM ranks, they are making a uturn
 

ziaulislam

BANNED
Apr 22, 2010
21,582
9
22,919
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
View attachment 844830
How is this possible in a short time, did they burn reserves? @ziaulislam
Reserves are not being used as state bank doesnt want to burn it as fast

Its all due to uncertianty

Disagree

PDM was smart enough not to use PTI dissenters vote for the National Assembly which means Shahbaz Sharif stays in power

PDM used PTI dissenters vote in Punjab Assembly to make Hamza the CM, that means Hamza will be deseated because those votes are invalid. CM Punjab is the most powerful person after the PM, if you have Punjab you have 60% of Pakistan
If President asks for numbers shehabaz doesnt have them

This is establishment asking PDM to do election
 

Amaa'n

STAFF
Aug 19, 2012
10,662
149
21,337
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Kingdom
The SC can only interpret the laws, but it cannot make them. If the Constitution does not say anything about a particular situation, the SC must send the issue back to the legislature which can clarify the law in keeping with any other relevant clauses that may apply to the situation. That is the correct due process.
Funny how they can do cherry picking on this....Article 69 :whistle:

and yet we saw April decision
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Top Bottom