What's new

Shamima Begum, regardless of her new image, remains the UK’s responsibility

Homo Sapiens

ELITE MEMBER
Feb 3, 2015
8,655
-3
20,300
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Bangladesh
Shamima Begum, regardless of her new image, remains the UK’s responsibility
Gina Vale


She was groomed as a child and has endured trauma – and to say she now ‘looks western’ is an insult to British Muslims
  • Dr Gina Vale is a senior research fellow at the International Centre for the Study of Radicalisation
Shamima Begum on ITV’s Good Morning Britain, 15 September

Shamima Begum on ITV’s Good Morning Britain, 15 September. Photograph: ITV/Rex/Shutterstock

Thu 16 Sep 2021 16.10 BST



In her first live interview since joining Islamic State (IS), on ITV’s Good Morning Britain, 22-year-old Shamima Begum made her latest appeal to return to the UK. She is one of over 6,000 minors who became affiliated with IS, but ever since the grainy CCTV pictures emerged of her leaving the UK with two east London schoolmates in 2015, her case has captured international media attention.

Begum’s case first raises the issue of accountability of minors who become radicalised. At first, media reporting described the three girls as being “lured” into IS, comparing their childhood innocence to the monstrosity of their recruiters. The then education secretary, Nicky Morgan, wrote to their school saying, “We hope and pray for the safe return of the pupils”. In the rush to explain the fact that young girls could turn away from their lives in Britain to join a terrorist organisation, the “jihadi bride” narrative took hold – a catch-all phrase that focuses on girls’ romantic motives.


Yet this term is problematic, because it simplifies, sexualises and stereotypes women’s involvement with the group.

Begum claims that her motivation for joining IS was to “get married, have children and live a pure Islamic life”. However, growing research into women and girls’ radicalisation into IS has revealed varied and individualised motivations, including a desire for belonging, purpose, adventure, ideological fulfilment and even a thirst for violence.
In the terror group’s published articles, marriage and child-rearing were painted as women’s “jihad” and primary duty, but this was not the limit of their activism. Women adopted roles as teachers, doctors, bureaucrats and even frontline combatants and officers in IS’s infamous “morality police”. From innocent schoolgirls to “monsters”, these women are now viewed as a credible security threat.

However, IS’s strict, anonymising female dress code has left little evidence of individual women’s activities within the group’s territory. In her interview, Begum asserts: “I did not do anything in Isis apart from be a mother and a wife … the government don’t actually have anything on me.”

Begum is now demanding the opportunity to prove her innocence and has renounced her support for IS. For some, this notably includes her “new look”. When she appeared without her hijab and abaya, her interviewers on Good Morning Britain questioned her need to “look western” in an attempt to reflect an internal transformation.

There are two troubling assumptions here. First: whether or not her change in appearance is a public relations stunt, Islamic dress should never be construed as a marker or measure of radicalism. While IS mandated that all women within its territory should wear the full burqa, this does not, in any way, mean that all women who choose to wear the burqa are aligned with IS or support other extremist groups. These garments are items of religious dress, not an IS uniform.

Second, this comment normalises a “western” appearance as being without a hijab or other signifier of Islamic faith. It reinforces the discriminatory sentiment that Muslim women do not belong in western – or here, British – society. The social media accounts of young women and girls who joined IS consistently speak of a lack of acceptance, discrimination and overt Islamophobia as reasons for joining the group. Biases in our society that connect radicalisation and physical appearance are easily exploited by extremist recruiters.

In April 2019, IS lost control of its final enclave in Syria, pushing formerly affiliated women and children into secure camps. According to latest estimates, the largest of these, al-Hol, is home to over 65,000 women and children, with almost 10,000 foreign nationals housed in a high-security annex. Overcrowding, poor sanitation and limited access to healthcare have resulted in high infant mortality rates.

All three of Begum’s children are now deceased. Her youngest, Jarrah, died shortly after her arrival at al-Hol. She describes the shoestring medical facilities leaving her feeling that there was “nothing [she] could do to help him”. Whatever one thinks about Begum, the loss of these children is a tragedy. Born into these circumstances, they have paid the highest price for the choices of their parents. But while the death of baby Jarrah can be attributed in part to Begum’s travel to a warzone, it also could have been avoided if he (and his mother) had been allowed to return to Britain.

The UK government’s decision to strip Begum of her British citizenship (asserting that she has claim to Bangladeshi citizenship through her heritage) has sparked controversy. The 1981 British Nationality Act stipulates that a British-born individual cannot be deprived or stripped of their citizenship if they would be rendered stateless. In effect, this means that citizenship deprivation can only be deployed against the children of migrant parents or children of dual nationals, resulting in what some analysts have highlighted as a discriminatory “two-tiered system”.

Travel to Bangladesh, whether possible or not, should not be part of the debate. Begum is/was British. She was born in England and left Britain to join IS. Her actions have consequences that are the UK’s responsibility. Leaving her (and others) in makeshift detention centres only increases the strain on already over-burdened Kurdish authorities, the evidence of which is clear from recent jail-breaks and smuggling campaigns.

Begum has once again become a “poster girl”, this time for demonised former IS-affiliated women. Irrespective of states’ decisions to repatriate or prosecute their citizens, it is clear that many women like Begum have endured psychological and physical trauma during childhood and early adulthood. Their cases should be managed sensitively. Sensationalist questioning and stereotyping by media and politicians will hinder prospects for rehabilitation, feed into discriminatory and Islamophobic narratives, and even potentially reignite support for extremism.
  • Dr Gina Vale is a senior research fellow at the International Centre for the Study of Radicalisation, King’s College London
 

kingQamaR

FULL MEMBER
Sep 14, 2017
1,610
-7
1,446
Country
United Kingdom
Location
Pakistan
Her only option is to get to the french Calais port get smuggled back into the U.K. . And let’s see what U.K. can do that is absolutely nothing. And U.K. will not be able to deport her anywhere in the world. Her situation became ridiculous because of the former Home Secretary Sajid Khan tool for U.K.
 

DalalErMaNodi

BANNED
May 12, 2020
5,296
6
8,715
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Kuwait
LOL! This little suicide bomber is so desperate to get back to the high life.. I say let her rot in Syria.


Weak Minded, Spineless individuals like her will always be attracted to nefarious activities such as Terrorism.


Ought to be executed and be done with it.
Real question is how tf did she go all the way to Syria without her parents knowing.

Doesn't she have a whole kid now as well.


It's not that hard to walk out of home all nonchalant and fly to turkey within the hour.
 

Genghis khan1

SENIOR MEMBER
Aug 22, 2015
4,082
1
5,261
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
How do you strip off UK born citizen of their nationality. Would they strip of a white nut job of his/her citizen specially when she acted as a minor.
 

jamahir

ELITE MEMBER
Jul 9, 2014
22,857
16
20,223
Country
India
Location
India
When she appeared without her hijab and abaya, her interviewers on Good Morning Britain questioned her need to “look western” in an attempt to reflect an internal transformation.
If she looks "Western" what is wrong ?

While IS mandated that all women within its territory should wear the full burqa, this does not, in any way, mean that all women who choose to wear the burqa are aligned with IS or support other extremist groups. These garments are items of religious dress, not an IS uniform.
So all those non-ISIS but still misguided women who go on burqa marches carrying banners like "The hijab is not my compulsion, it is my pride" are correct ? Since when did the burqa become Islamic dress ? What will be the thoughts of these voluntary burqa wearers on progressive Muslim movements and leaders in say Egypt, Pakistan and the USSR ?
 

DalalErMaNodi

BANNED
May 12, 2020
5,296
6
8,715
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Kuwait
If she looks "Western" what is wrong ?


Whether it is right or wrong isn't the issue here..


The issue is she just pretending to have been reformed as a person.. Can a terrorist who abandoned their future in a prosperous country just to join a group of misguided nutjobs be trusted with a second chance ? It is obvious this is all a sham to save her own skin, that jihad in Syria must not be working out all that well.


Luckily, her three children perished or this brat would use them as a bargaining tool and a sympathy tool.
How do you strip off UK born citizen of their nationality. Would they strip of a white nut job of his/her citizen specially when she acted as a minor.

You are never an X citizen of a white country, You will always, always remain a black/brown/muslim miscreant to them.

They want you only in your success, when the going gets tough, you're just another immigrant to them.
 

jamahir

ELITE MEMBER
Jul 9, 2014
22,857
16
20,223
Country
India
Location
India
Whether it is right or wrong isn't the issue here..

The issue is she just pretending to have been reformed as a person.. Can a terrorist who abandoned their future in a prosperous country just to join a group of misguided nutjobs be trusted with a second chance ? It is obvious this is all a sham to save her own skin, that jihad in Syria must not be working out all that well.
You are correct so she must be put to test. Live TV and YouTube streaming of her debate with British Muslim intellectuals like Tariq Ali and sensible British journalists like Lizzie Phelan who covered the Libya and Syria invasions.
 

PakAlp

FULL MEMBER
Sep 27, 2007
1,293
1
2,125
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Kingdom
She was a teenage girl who went to share beds with the terrorist ISIS and co. She should continue to live in Syria, she betrayed her parents. The people who brainwashed her must be arrested and deported to Syria but unfortunately they are freely walking around. The real terrorist never get caught. The like of dawah man, he is the one encouraging girls to go Syria and sleep with the mujahdeen as they need women. This lady needs to expose these munafiqs
 

PakAlp

FULL MEMBER
Sep 27, 2007
1,293
1
2,125
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Kingdom
Who is he ? Some Tabligh Jamaati type ?
Saudi lover, these types of preachers through street talk, YouTube, Facebook encourage people to go Syria etc, encourage especially the teenagers as they are easy prey. Young girls from Tunsia and other countries went aswell.



 

jamahir

ELITE MEMBER
Jul 9, 2014
22,857
16
20,223
Country
India
Location
India
Saudi lover, these types of preachers through street talk, YouTube, Facebook encourage people to go Syria etc, encourage especially the teenagers as they are easy prey. Young girls from Tunsia and other countries went aswell.

Watched the first vid, will watch the rest after lunch. Well, to me the scenes of East London seem so much like my city in India, especially all those burqa wearers. Here it has been so for the last 20 years. India probably has the most number of burqa wearers in the world. You said Dawah Man is a Saudi lover. Since you live there you will know more than me about this but he may also be inspired by the India-origin Tablighi Jamaat which has been the most successful regressive movement among Muslims that change social atmosphere among Muslims locally and also brain wash Muslims to fight in "Islamic" causes ( like in Syria ) which are really the brainchilds of Western governments. The TJ has been banned outright in Russia and the Muslim-majority Central Asian countries.
 
Last edited:

Azadkashmir

SENIOR MEMBER
Nov 10, 2012
7,200
0
8,690
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Kingdom
i get feeling she is just psychological operation/poster child.
if it was white person then he /she would be shown as victim of evil islam, and will get full health support and financial. probably turned into celebrity and get movie contracts.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Top Bottom