What's new

SC hears PTI petition against Sindh local govt law

W.11

ELITE MEMBER
Jan 20, 2011
14,795
-31
11,693
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
ISLAMABAD: A bench of the Supreme Court headed by Chief Justice Gulzar Ahmed on Wednesday heard a constitutional petition seeking directions for the Sindh government to devolve powers to the local government institutions, ARY News reported.

The court earlier, set aside objections of the Registrar’s Office over the petition filed by Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI).

The bench issued notices to the Government of Sindh, Attorney General of Pakistan and Advocate General Sindh.

The petition has challenged the Sindh Local Government Act (SLGA) seeking directions for the provincial government to devolve powers to the local bodies in the province in view of Article 140-A as well as Articles 3, 4, 9, 14, 16, 17, 19, 19A and 25 of the Constitution.

While hearing the petition Justice Ijazul Ahsan asked, “if the local government of Karachi generates its own funds?” MQM counsel replied that District Tax has been abolished in the city. Provincial Finance Commission issues funds to local governments. “If the MQM raised voice against the legislation”, the bench asked. “It was in minority and was not heard over the matter,” MQM counsel Barrister Salahuddin said.

“The entire game is to keep powers in one’s own hand. What is guarantee that the local governments would work properly if being delegated powers,” Chief Justice Gulzar Ahmed asked. “Every system made for Karachi didn’t give good results so far,” the top judge remarked.

“The powers will also bring accountability,” Justice Ijazul Ahsan said. “If in government they don’t like to share powers, when not in government, they talk about devolution of powers,” the Justice further remarked.

“Presence of local government is not someone’s choice but it is compulsory,” the chief justice said.

“How did you perform in your local government. People were drowning, houses were collapsing where was your city government at that time,” chief justice asked the MQM counsel. “Twenty thousand KMC employees are getting salaries, where were they and why they didn’t seen at that time,” the CJP further questioned.

“You should legislate a comprehensive and ideal law, the court will extend its helping hand,” chief justice said.

MQM counsel in his arguments said that clause 74 and 75 of the SLGA contravene the constitution and under clause 74 the provincial government could take back any powers from local governments.

The CJP told the counsel to restrict him to the legal points of the case and said that the bench would not be available for hearing for the next two weeks.

The court asked the counsels to submit their arguments in writing.

====

from the highlighted statements by the SC judge it already seems like that in enemity of Karachi the judge himself is politicizing the matter and probably would dismiss this case in favour of Sindh government.

The authority demanded by the petition is already too weak, only water board and building control authority probably and not mass transit, master plan, major revenue collection etc.

regards
 
Last edited:

Syed1.

SENIOR MEMBER
Dec 7, 2016
5,753
-1
10,609
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan

W.11

ELITE MEMBER
Jan 20, 2011
14,795
-31
11,693
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Lo jee Feb se petition dali hoi hai PM ne. First hearing in September and then holiday for two weeks.

The CJP said first the petitioners have to bring alternate comprehensive local government system. But PTI Sindh MPAs already did that in July and rejected by Sindh Assembly



Ikhees toppon ki salaami for our judicial system.
lmao, so the only thing which the PTI asks from sindh govt is water board, solid wate management and building control authority

here is whats demanded by the PTI for the LG

Any office, agency or authority established or maintained by the Government, which at the commencement of this Act is providing public services or discharging other duties in relation to the Education, building control, solid waste management, water supply, and sewerage collection and disposal function in a Metropolitan, shall, subject to such conditions and control as the Government may impose, stand transferred to the respective Metropolitan Corporation
and here is SLGO 2001 implemented under musharraf

1600894390993.png



no policing, master plan, construction of bridges/flyovers, roads, urban and rural planning, landscaping, housing, gardens, markets, development, environment, KDA, mass transit etc

PTI seems to be in favour of urban and rural divide as well which was eliminated by muharraf's ordinance.

nothing but PTI wanting implementation of 1979 laws which was usurped by the PPP in 2013 there is no improvement from there.

The current government of the PTI has come up with a butchered local government system that is not only against the spirit of devolution and empowerment but also backtracks on local empowerment.

regards
 

Syed1.

SENIOR MEMBER
Dec 7, 2016
5,753
-1
10,609
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
lmao, so the only thing which the PTI asks from sindh govt is water board, solid wate management and building control authority

here is whats demanded by the PTI for the LG



and here is SLGO 2001 implemented under musharraf

View attachment 672571


no policing, master plan, construction of bridges/flyovers, roads, urban and rural planning, landscaping, housing, gardens, markets, development, environment, KDA, mass transit etc

PTI seems to be in favour of urban and rural divide as well which was eliminated by muharraf's ordinance.

nothing but PTI wanting implementation of 1979 laws which was usurped by the PPP in 2013 there is no improvement from there.



regards
MQM and Altaf Hussain supporters shouldn't even talk.


Know your level
 
Last edited:

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)

Top