What's new

Russian Su-30 fighter jets criticized by Belarus, they want F-16 :P

Pak-Canuck

FULL MEMBER
Aug 29, 2018
153
2
347
Country
Pakistan
Location
Canada
https://defence-blog.com/news/russian-su-30-fighter-jets-criticized-by-belarus-they-want-f-16.html

Russia has started implementing a contract on the delivery of a batch of its newest Su-30SM multirole fighter jets to Belarus, but some analysts raised concerns about costs over the entire life cycle of the aircraft, from fabrication to maintenance.

The publication Lenta.ru reported Friday that a wide range of renowned experts has expressed their concerns regarding Belarus selected Russian-made combat aircraft to replace ageing Soviet-era MiG-29 fleet.

Andrey Porotnikov, BelarusSecurityBlog’s project leader, said that operating and support costs of Russian aircraft are more expensive than U.S.-made F-16 fighter aircraft.

Usually, the combat aircraft life-cycle cost for an estimated life of 35 years is 2-2.5 times its purchase price, as a result of which the total cost of maintenance of each Belarus’s Su-30SM will cost $100-125 million.

“And now, to sum up, the price of aircraft [about $ 50 million], the maintain of airworthiness and modernization. We get the amount from 185 to 210 million dollars for each (!) aircraft in the next 35 years. And the squadron [12 aircraft], respectively, from 2.22 billion to 2.52 billion dollars. The amount is not small, ”- Andrey Porotnikov stated.

Another disadvantage of the fighter manufactured in Russia is its AL-31FP engines, which six units “eat” during the Su-30SM life cycle (two of them are already installed and paid for at the time of purchase). This circumstance in the publication is explained by the fact that “Soviet (Russian) aircraft engines are traditionally inferior to Western ones not only in fuel efficiency but also in between-repairs and operating life cycles.”

“The Polish Air Force simultaneously operates the Soviet twin-engine fighter MiG-29 and the American single-engine F-16. It is assumed that the American fighter will fly off all 35 years with the same engine that was originally installed on it. Unfortunately, this does not work out with the MiG-29: eight engines will have to be replaced in the same period, ” explained analyst.

According to TASS, the Su-30SM is a generation 4++ serial-produced and upgraded two-seat super-maneuverable fighter jet. The Su-30SM is furnished with two AL-31FP thrust-vectoring reheated double-flow turbofan engines. The fighter has an operating range of 1,500 km and flight endurance of 3.5 hours without refueling.
 

Inception-06

SENIOR MEMBER
Aug 17, 2007
3,470
15
4,553
Country
Pakistan
Location
Germany
https://defence-blog.com/news/russian-su-30-fighter-jets-criticized-by-belarus-they-want-f-16.html

Russia has started implementing a contract on the delivery of a batch of its newest Su-30SM multirole fighter jets to Belarus, but some analysts raised concerns about costs over the entire life cycle of the aircraft, from fabrication to maintenance.

The publication Lenta.ru reported Friday that a wide range of renowned experts has expressed their concerns regarding Belarus selected Russian-made combat aircraft to replace ageing Soviet-era MiG-29 fleet.

Andrey Porotnikov, BelarusSecurityBlog’s project leader, said that operating and support costs of Russian aircraft are more expensive than U.S.-made F-16 fighter aircraft.

Usually, the combat aircraft life-cycle cost for an estimated life of 35 years is 2-2.5 times its purchase price, as a result of which the total cost of maintenance of each Belarus’s Su-30SM will cost $100-125 million.

“And now, to sum up, the price of aircraft [about $ 50 million], the maintain of airworthiness and modernization. We get the amount from 185 to 210 million dollars for each (!) aircraft in the next 35 years. And the squadron [12 aircraft], respectively, from 2.22 billion to 2.52 billion dollars. The amount is not small, ”- Andrey Porotnikov stated.

Another disadvantage of the fighter manufactured in Russia is its AL-31FP engines, which six units “eat” during the Su-30SM life cycle (two of them are already installed and paid for at the time of purchase). This circumstance in the publication is explained by the fact that “Soviet (Russian) aircraft engines are traditionally inferior to Western ones not only in fuel efficiency but also in between-repairs and operating life cycles.”

“The Polish Air Force simultaneously operates the Soviet twin-engine fighter MiG-29 and the American single-engine F-16. It is assumed that the American fighter will fly off all 35 years with the same engine that was originally installed on it. Unfortunately, this does not work out with the MiG-29: eight engines will have to be replaced in the same period, ” explained analyst.

According to TASS, the Su-30SM is a generation 4++ serial-produced and upgraded two-seat super-maneuverable fighter jet. The Su-30SM is furnished with two AL-31FP thrust-vectoring reheated double-flow turbofan engines. The fighter has an operating range of 1,500 km and flight endurance of 3.5 hours without refueling.
Jf-17 has also a russian engine !
 

Beast

ELITE MEMBER
Feb 5, 2011
24,180
-38
56,507
Country
China
Location
China
Jf-17 has also a russian engine !
No, it a Chinese clone RD-93 engine called WS-13 which life cycle and lifespan is much higher. Most importantly, it overhaul either by Chinese or PAC which significantly reduce maintenance cost.
 
Last edited:

JohnWick

BANNED
Nov 13, 2018
2,946
-2
2,531
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
https://defence-blog.com/news/russian-su-30-fighter-jets-criticized-by-belarus-they-want-f-16.html

Russia has started implementing a contract on the delivery of a batch of its newest Su-30SM multirole fighter jets to Belarus, but some analysts raised concerns about costs over the entire life cycle of the aircraft, from fabrication to maintenance.

The publication Lenta.ru reported Friday that a wide range of renowned experts has expressed their concerns regarding Belarus selected Russian-made combat aircraft to replace ageing Soviet-era MiG-29 fleet.

Andrey Porotnikov, BelarusSecurityBlog’s project leader, said that operating and support costs of Russian aircraft are more expensive than U.S.-made F-16 fighter aircraft.

Usually, the combat aircraft life-cycle cost for an estimated life of 35 years is 2-2.5 times its purchase price, as a result of which the total cost of maintenance of each Belarus’s Su-30SM will cost $100-125 million.

“And now, to sum up, the price of aircraft [about $ 50 million], the maintain of airworthiness and modernization. We get the amount from 185 to 210 million dollars for each (!) aircraft in the next 35 years. And the squadron [12 aircraft], respectively, from 2.22 billion to 2.52 billion dollars. The amount is not small, ”- Andrey Porotnikov stated.

Another disadvantage of the fighter manufactured in Russia is its AL-31FP engines, which six units “eat” during the Su-30SM life cycle (two of them are already installed and paid for at the time of purchase). This circumstance in the publication is explained by the fact that “Soviet (Russian) aircraft engines are traditionally inferior to Western ones not only in fuel efficiency but also in between-repairs and operating life cycles.”

“The Polish Air Force simultaneously operates the Soviet twin-engine fighter MiG-29 and the American single-engine F-16. It is assumed that the American fighter will fly off all 35 years with the same engine that was originally installed on it. Unfortunately, this does not work out with the MiG-29: eight engines will have to be replaced in the same period, ” explained analyst.

According to TASS, the Su-30SM is a generation 4++ serial-produced and upgraded two-seat super-maneuverable fighter jet. The Su-30SM is furnished with two AL-31FP thrust-vectoring reheated double-flow turbofan engines. The fighter has an operating range of 1,500 km and flight endurance of 3.5 hours without refueling.
Whole JF-17 is the continuation of russian Mig 33.
 

Ultima Thule

ELITE MEMBER
Jan 26, 2012
16,887
0
1,091
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
No, it a Chinese clone RD-93 engine called WS-13 which life cycle and lifespan is much higher. Most importantly, it overhaul either by Chinese or PAC which significantly reduce maintenance cost.
No we still using RD-93 sir, as per various senior and professional members here, and PAF quite satisfied with RD-93's performance, sorry to disappoint you sir
 

PradoTLC

SENIOR MEMBER
Mar 17, 2007
4,245
1
4,983
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Arab Emirates
https://defence-blog.com/news/russian-su-30-fighter-jets-criticized-by-belarus-they-want-f-16.html

Russia has started implementing a contract on the delivery of a batch of its newest Su-30SM multirole fighter jets to Belarus, but some analysts raised concerns about costs over the entire life cycle of the aircraft, from fabrication to maintenance.

The publication Lenta.ru reported Friday that a wide range of renowned experts has expressed their concerns regarding Belarus selected Russian-made combat aircraft to replace ageing Soviet-era MiG-29 fleet.

Andrey Porotnikov, BelarusSecurityBlog’s project leader, said that operating and support costs of Russian aircraft are more expensive than U.S.-made F-16 fighter aircraft.

Usually, the combat aircraft life-cycle cost for an estimated life of 35 years is 2-2.5 times its purchase price, as a result of which the total cost of maintenance of each Belarus’s Su-30SM will cost $100-125 million.

“And now, to sum up, the price of aircraft [about $ 50 million], the maintain of airworthiness and modernization. We get the amount from 185 to 210 million dollars for each (!) aircraft in the next 35 years. And the squadron [12 aircraft], respectively, from 2.22 billion to 2.52 billion dollars. The amount is not small, ”- Andrey Porotnikov stated.

Another disadvantage of the fighter manufactured in Russia is its AL-31FP engines, which six units “eat” during the Su-30SM life cycle (two of them are already installed and paid for at the time of purchase). This circumstance in the publication is explained by the fact that “Soviet (Russian) aircraft engines are traditionally inferior to Western ones not only in fuel efficiency but also in between-repairs and operating life cycles.”

“The Polish Air Force simultaneously operates the Soviet twin-engine fighter MiG-29 and the American single-engine F-16. It is assumed that the American fighter will fly off all 35 years with the same engine that was originally installed on it. Unfortunately, this does not work out with the MiG-29: eight engines will have to be replaced in the same period, ” explained analyst.

According to TASS, the Su-30SM is a generation 4++ serial-produced and upgraded two-seat super-maneuverable fighter jet. The Su-30SM is furnished with two AL-31FP thrust-vectoring reheated double-flow turbofan engines. The fighter has an operating range of 1,500 km and flight endurance of 3.5 hours without refueling.

Every one knows PAF F-16s made shot work of Su-30s.... except ENDians.....
 

wali87

FULL MEMBER
Jun 22, 2007
871
-1
844
No, it a Chinese clone RD-93 engine called WS-13 which life cycle and lifespan is much higher. Most importantly, it overhaul either by Chinese or PAC which significantly reduce maintenance cost.
No almost all of the engines being used on our JFs are rd93. However there fleet few WS13 being tested on earlier versions of block 1 aircrafts currently. Hopefully in a few years, there are high chances that we will shift over two ws13 or another new Chinese engine.
 

Beast

ELITE MEMBER
Feb 5, 2011
24,180
-38
56,507
Country
China
Location
China
No almost all of the engines being used on our JFs are rd93. However there fleet few WS13 being tested on earlier versions of block 1 aircrafts currently. Hopefully in a few years, there are high chances that we will shift over two ws13 or another new Chinese engine.
Do not mix up WS-13 with WS-19... They are different type of engine. WS-19 are new gen engine with TVC and more than 10000kg of thrust with afterburner. WS-13 is a engine similar in class to RD-93 that enter service almost 10 years ago in Chinese military.

https://www.ainonline.com/aviation-news/defense/2017-10-27/chinese-fighter-developments-revealed

The chief engineer of WS-19 is a female and she was awarded for successful completion of this project.
https://mil.news.sina.com.cn/jssd/2019-04-17/doc-ihvhiewr6611870.shtml
 

wali87

FULL MEMBER
Jun 22, 2007
871
-1
844
Do not mix up WS-13 with WS-19... They are different type of engine. WS-19 are new gen engine with TVC and more than 10000kg of thrust with afterburner. WS-13 is a engine similar in class to RD-93 that enter service almost 10 years ago in Chinese military.

https://www.ainonline.com/aviation-news/defense/2017-10-27/chinese-fighter-developments-revealed
WS19. Hmmm, hadn’t head of that one sir. Is WS19 around the same dimensions as WS13? Because I heard somewhere we cannot fit a bigger engine considering the size of JFs engine tunnel.
 

Beast

ELITE MEMBER
Feb 5, 2011
24,180
-38
56,507
Country
China
Location
China
WS19. Hmmm, hadn’t head of that one sir. Is WS19 around the same dimensions as WS13? Because I heard somewhere we cannot fit a bigger engine considering the size of JFs engine tunnel.
WS-19 is new gen engine to replace WS-13, of cos the dimension is similar. Do read up more info for J-31 as the engine is intend for this 5th gen fighter. It interchangeable engine between JF-17 and J-31 engine.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Top Bottom