What's new

Indian Navy has questions on China’s new aircraft carrier Fujian

MH.Yang

SENIOR MEMBER
Jul 21, 2021
5,279
1
9,851
Country
China
Location
China
If Indians choose to buy F18, we will see flankers(J-15T) take off with ejection and F18 take off with jump.
 
Jun 27, 2022
485
0
509
Country
China
Location
China
J-15 is a stolen design and unlicensed Chinese development based on a T-10K-3 prototype of the Russian Su-33 Flanker-D. It has a maximum take-off weight (MTOW) of 33 tons and an external payload of 6.5 tons. There are conflicting reports of the J-15 design being flawed, resulting in four known and multiple unknown crashes. WS-10H engines are unreliable compared to original Russian Salyut AL-31F engines. It is confirmed that unstable flight control systems were the key factor behind the at least two fatal accidents couple of years ago.

The J-15 may not be capable of taking off from the Liaoning or Shandong’s ski jump with full MTOW. The J-15’s MTOW depends on carrier speeds, which in turn generates headwinds. Though China claims that at the aircraft carrier’s operational speed of 28 knots, the J-15 can take off at 28-33 tons, and even at a slower speed of 20 knots, the weight is 31 tons, there is no way of substantiating these claims.
believe me. The "super invisible MIG 29K" assembled in India is better.

Screenshot_20220715_124335.jpg
 

etylo

FULL MEMBER
Nov 9, 2021
1,293
-15
1,474
Country
Canada
Location
Canada
J-15 is a stolen design and unlicensed Chinese development based on a T-10K-3 prototype of the Russian Su-33 Flanker-D. It has a maximum take-off weight (MTOW) of 33 tons and an external payload of 6.5 tons. There are conflicting reports of the J-15 design being flawed, resulting in four known and multiple unknown crashes. WS-10H engines are unreliable compared to original Russian Salyut AL-31F engines. It is confirmed that unstable flight control systems were the key factor behind the at least two fatal accidents couple of years ago.

The J-15 may not be capable of taking off from the Liaoning or Shandong’s ski jump with full MTOW. The J-15’s MTOW depends on carrier speeds, which in turn generates headwinds. Though China claims that at the aircraft carrier’s operational speed of 28 knots, the J-15 can take off at 28-33 tons, and even at a slower speed of 20 knots, the weight is 31 tons, there is no way of substantiating these claims.
Every tech Chinese got is stolen from your daddys whitemen simply becos you are jealousy that Indians can't make literally any tech products.
 

Hellfire2006

FULL MEMBER
May 2, 2022
179
0
171
Country
India
Location
India
North Korea could probably defeat India tbh. North Korea has ICBMs and proven H bomb capability with 200 kT miniaturized warheads. Indian ICBMs can't even reach North Korea and if they could they only have 20 kT large warheads.
India does possess H bombs. Various tests on the design were run through simulations on supercomputers to validate the effectiveness. Indian arsenal comprises if anything between 15kt-200kt nuclear designs. The test in 1998 was a scaled down version of an H bomb ( some argue it was a boosted fission weapon) with a yield deliberately kept below 60Kt. India didnt carry out more tests due to the clause in indo us nuclear deal that states all nuclear commercial activities will be suspended upon resumption of nuclear tests.india is in possesion of Agni V ICBM. Chinese analysts say it has a range of 8000km
 

MH.Yang

SENIOR MEMBER
Jul 21, 2021
5,279
1
9,851
Country
China
Location
China
India does possess H bombs. Various tests on the design were run through simulations on supercomputers to validate the effectiveness. Indian arsenal comprises if anything between 15kt-200kt nuclear designs. The test in 1998 was a scaled down version of an H bomb ( some argue it was a boosted fission weapon) with a yield deliberately kept below 60Kt. India didnt carry out more tests due to the clause in indo us nuclear deal that states all nuclear commercial activities will be suspended upon resumption of nuclear tests.india is in possesion of Agni V ICBM. Chinese analysts say it has a range of 8000km

1. Agni 5 has a range of 5000 km.

2. Agni 5 is not an ICBM. The threshold of ICBM is 8000+ km.

3. Agni 5 has only one guidance mode and almost no anti-interference ability.

4. India has no nuclear weapon miniaturization technology and cannot launch nuclear weapons with missiles.
 
Jun 27, 2022
485
0
509
Country
China
Location
China
1. Agni-5 uses a three-stage solid-fueled engine which is likely to be able to eliminate strategic targets at ranges as far as 5,500-8,000 km with pinpoint accuracy

2. It is said to have an effective range of 8000 km, covering entire China and could hit targets far into the Pacific as well

3. "CEP" of Chinese ICBMs are horrible as compared to India's Agni series missiles

4. The centrepiece of a host of new technologies incorporated in Agni 5/Agni 3/Agni Prime is its ring laser gyroscope and accelerometer. The ring laser gyroscope was tested and integrated by the Research Centre Imarat (RCI) based in Hyderabad

India is an illegal nuclear-armed country like North Korea. India's testing and development of nuclear weapons is a serious violation of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty. China is right to warn India.

of course. India does not have ICBMs(10000km +). This is beyond India's capabilities.
 

siegecrossbow

PDF THINK TANK: ANALYST
Aug 19, 2010
7,101
7
14,471
Country
China
Location
United States
J-15 is a stolen design and unlicensed Chinese development based on a T-10K-3 prototype of the Russian Su-33 Flanker-D. It has a maximum take-off weight (MTOW) of 33 tons and an external payload of 6.5 tons. There are conflicting reports of the J-15 design being flawed, resulting in four known and multiple unknown crashes. WS-10H engines are unreliable compared to original Russian Salyut AL-31F engines. It is confirmed that unstable flight control systems were the key factor behind the at least two fatal accidents couple of years ago.

The J-15 may not be capable of taking off from the Liaoning or Shandong’s ski jump with full MTOW. The J-15’s MTOW depends on carrier speeds, which in turn generates headwinds. Though China claims that at the aircraft carrier’s operational speed of 28 knots, the J-15 can take off at 28-33 tons, and even at a slower speed of 20 knots, the weight is 31 tons, there is no way of substantiating these claims.

 

Hellfire2006

FULL MEMBER
May 2, 2022
179
0
171
Country
India
Location
India

1. Agni 5 has a range of 5000 km.
Your own chinese analysts say it's 8000km
2. Agni 5 is not an ICBM. The threshold of ICBM is 8000+ km.
The threshold is 5,500km, a missile as big as Agni V can easily reach 8,000km. India deliberately downplayed the range to avoid raising western suspicion.
3. Agni 5 has only one guidance mode and almost no anti-interference ability.
No sir
It has Ring laser gyroscope inertial navigation system. Optionally augmented by GPS/NavIC satellite guidance.
It's coming with advanced chip-embedded guidance system

4. India has no nuclear weapon miniaturization technology and cannot launch nuclear weapons with missiles.
What ! Where's the Proof ? Is india stupid to develop strategic missiles but not being able to miniaturise the warhead ? This is a laughable claim. Are you trying to be comedic or what ?
India is an illegal nuclear-armed country like North Korea. India's testing and development of nuclear weapons is a serious violation of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty. China is right to warn India.
ok , but what can china do about it ? Will china denuclearise india ? Why dosen't china invade india to disarm india's WMDs ? A superpower like the Great PRC must be able to do that
 
Last edited:

VkdIndian

FULL MEMBER
Jan 6, 2021
1,390
-6
1,327
Country
India
Location
India
Entire China was on PDF asking questions about Indian Aircraft Carrier‘s perceived design deficiencies. Each one of them had nothing but scorn for India and anything made in India.

Its lovely to see them crying like babies on this thread. Because someone has pointed out deficiencies in their carrier?

China did copy from western powers but it is still far away from getting it right. Suck it up and accept it.
 

redtom

FULL MEMBER
Aug 2, 2020
1,166
-1
2,135
Country
China
Location
United States
I think based on the past performance of the Indian Navy, if they question you, then you are right. If they praise you, make sure you check your mistakes.
 

MH.Yang

SENIOR MEMBER
Jul 21, 2021
5,279
1
9,851
Country
China
Location
China
Your own chinese analysts say it's 8000km

The threshold is 5,500km, a missile as big as Agni V can easily reach 8,000km. India deliberately downplayed the range to avoid raising western suspicion.

No sir
It has Ring laser gyroscope inertial navigation system. Optionally augmented by GPS/NavIC satellite guidance.
It's coming with advanced chip-embedded guidance system


What ! Where's the Proof ? Is india stupid to develop strategic missiles but not being able to miniaturise the warhead ? This is a laughable claim. Are you trying to be comedic or what ?

ok , but what can china do about it ? Will china denuclearise india ? Why dosen't china invade india to disarm india's WMDs ? A superpower like the Great PRC must be able to do that
1, You can Google to see if there are any reports that India has obtained nuclear weapon miniaturization technology. None.

2, Indian media spread rumors. Du Wenlong's original words are: India's Agni 5 missile has a range of only 5000 kilometers, but it does not reach 8000 kilometers, so it is not ICBM. This is a screenshot of Du Wenlong's program report.


IMG_20220725_194458.jpg


3, What you said is that there is only one guidance mode.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Top Bottom