What's new

Indian might launch a surprise attack across the Himalayan border.

FairAndUnbiased

SENIOR MEMBER
Nov 25, 2011
7,202
0
10,657
Country
China
Location
United States
Chinese assessment is completely out of this world. India can never attack even if China retakes hundreds of 1000 sq kms blocks. There is no option to start a civilian revolt as the conflict zone is an empty land. Indian politicians don't go to war unless more than one of the following are true: (1) they are able to buy local civilian support in the enemy territory, (2) the Indian army strength is several times larger in numbers, (3) conflict zone is cut off with the mainland of enemy.. not just cut off, but there should be a distance of 100s if not thousands of kilometers and Indians are sitting in between two parts (4) there are no civilians available to use as human shield.

Not saying anything against IA as it might be a professional force, but Indian politicians only act when they have full confidence of 200% win as no Indian government wants to lose next elections.

So... no.. Indian is not attacking. If anything has to happen, it will happen from Chinese side.. But then again, China is not there for war. It is there to stretch the Indian forces across thousands of kilometers..
Indians could indeed attack in an ill conceived war just as racial supremacist ideology motivated Nazi Germany to undertake an unwinnable war against the UK and Soviet Union.

Nazi Germany had an economy 1/2 the size of the Soviets alone, never mind UK as well. But they believed that they were racially superior and the Soviets were unmotivated despite their larger economy and military.

Similar arguments are being advanced by Indians on this very forum: Chinese PLA is weak and unmotivated despite being larger, Indians are the superior master race.
 

PakSword

MODERATOR
Dec 6, 2015
17,401
55
32,812
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Arab Emirates
Indians could indeed attack in an ill conceived war just as racial supremacist ideology motivated Nazi Germany to undertake an unwinnable war against the UK and Soviet Union.

Nazi Germany had an economy 1/2 the size of the Soviets alone, never mind UK as well. But they believed that they were racially superior and the Soviets were unmotivated despite their larger economy and military.

Similar arguments are being advanced by Indians on this very forum: Chinese PLA is weak and unmotivated despite being larger, Indians are the superior master race.
Indians claim AJK and Gilgit Baltistan. They could have attacked to capture these areas against a much smaller enemy.

If Indians couldn't attack Pakistan, which has 33% of disputed region, forget about them going to war against China for 1000 sq kms.
 

52051

FULL MEMBER
Sep 9, 2016
1,890
-8
6,113
Country
China
Location
China
Well, such assesement is target domestic audience, the purpose of this article is inform the public the risk of war, so any further action taken by PLA is justified to the public.
 

Dalit

BANNED
Mar 16, 2012
11,206
-16
19,485
Country
Pakistan
Location
Netherlands
Coronavirus has affected the tiny brains of RSS fanatics. Doing something big against China will be suicide for Hindustan.

LOL what kind of a surprise attack is announced through the media anyway? Might as well pick up a megaphone. Indians are masters of BS. Absolutely crazy fanatics.
 

xyx007

SENIOR MEMBER
Nov 27, 2017
2,297
3
3,407
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
There's a chance of an Indian attack before the fifth province declaration passed from parliament. Indian is waiting for the American green signal for attack. Armenia and Azbergian on the brink of a full-scale war in the South Caucasus. In a few days, we will see a clear picture of the Great Game Plan.
 

Dalit

BANNED
Mar 16, 2012
11,206
-16
19,485
Country
Pakistan
Location
Netherlands
There's a chance of an Indian attack before the fifth province declaration passed from parliament. Indian is waiting for the American green signal for attack. Armenia and Azbergian on the brink of a full-scale war in the South Caucasus. In a few days, we will see a clear picture of the Great Game Plan.
I hope India commits a mistake. They won't forget for generations to come.
 

Bossman

SENIOR MEMBER
Jul 11, 2010
2,502
-3
3,234
So you are saying India achieved its “wish” to be a super power by 2020? Yes I totally agree with you, the following statistics proves it.

- No 2 country in the world in terms of the most covid19 cases but sorry to say only no 3 in term of fatalities. This is such a great thing to be proud off, as per your media I.e low fatality rate. You guys need to work harder.
- The largest number of people living in sheer poverty.
- largest population defecating in public.
- largest population with stunted children.
- Highest level of suicides among farmers, daily wagers and soldiers.
- so on and so on, now go ride your horses.
 

Vapour

FULL MEMBER
Jul 2, 2020
611
2
767
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Kingdom
There's a chance of an Indian attack before the fifth province declaration passed from parliament. Indian is waiting for the American green signal for attack. Armenia and Azbergian on the brink of a full-scale war in the South Caucasus. In a few days, we will see a clear picture of the Great Game Plan.
If that is the plan, shouldn't Pakistan preempt this?
 

xyx007

SENIOR MEMBER
Nov 27, 2017
2,297
3
3,407
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
If that is the plan, shouldn't Pakistan preempt this?
This good fortune will be undone if the Indian government continues to advance a troubling domestic RSS agenda and try to exploit Modi’s missteps. New Delhi’s most significant challenge on Kashmir is not Pakistan — it’s Indian policy.
New Delhi should know from its own history of struggles that no amount of material gain, economic development, or large-scale subjugation can offset political demands deeply rooted in identity. If Kashmir implodes — or if it continues to damage its international credibility — New Delhi will only have itself to blame. Military action will pounce when it believes India is weak and lacks the support of its international supporters. Right now it is not the right time for any preempt action unless they attack us.
 

KurtisBrian

FULL MEMBER
Aug 24, 2020
681
-4
202
Country
Canada
Location
Canada
- The largest number of people living in sheer poverty.
- largest population defecating in public.
- largest population with stunted children.
- Highest level of suicides among farmers, daily wagers and soldiers.
These are all a potential cause of a huge war.

poverty: Soldiers get paid and fed which will reduce poverty. Create a 50-100 million man army. Those poor men are not doing anything anyways.
poverty: turn manufacturing into weapon construction to arm those 50-100 million men.
50 million excess men: Some soldiers die which will reduce the excess men.
woman shortage: historically soldiers capture women.... that treasure which African Americans call the booty.
crowding: Soldiers can capture new land which will alleviate crowding. Rome rewarded soldiers with land. Land, women and money....all reasons for poor men to fight.
crap economy: the USA used Vietnam war to spur the US economy. Hitler used war to raise his people up from ruin....didn't end well. :D Stalin and the modern US use military production and consumption to spur economy.
no toilets: invade and take the nice things from others. That is what the Greeks, Romans and Germanic cow herders all did in Europe.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Top Bottom