What's new

How to take on Chinese 'wolf warriors' through Bollywood movies. The Economic Times

Cornered Tiger

FULL MEMBER
Sep 4, 2013
550
0
636
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
It might be funny to even suggest Armed forces of any country to counter mighty PLA with Bollywood movies but The Economic Times has done such a wonder again. Read out and enjoy.

To take on Chinese ‘wolf warriors’, India must fix military asymmetry

Until 2014 or so, Chinese films hardly depicted any military conflict beyond World War II or the Chinese civil war of the 1940s. This trend changed completely with a new range of Hollywood-style Chinese war movies. They showcased a new kind of PLA and the idea of China as a global military superpower.

A nation’s movies often reflect its self-image. War films, even more so. As Indian troops face down China’s People Liberation Army in the Galwan Valley and across the Line of Actual Control, it is not entirely coincidental that the shift to such aggressive posturing by China on its real-life borders, from Ladakh to the South China Sea, was preceded in recent years by a major shift in depictions of the PLA in Chinese films.

Until 2014 or so, Chinese films hardly depicted any military conflict beyond World War II or the Chinese civil war of the 1940s. This trend changed completely with a new range of Hollywood-style Chinese war movies. They showcased a new kind of PLA and the idea of China as a global military superpower, as the journalists Charles Clover and Sherry Fei Ju noted in a perceptive 2018 overview of this phenomenon. The shift started, they said, with ‘Wolf Warrior’ in 2015, ‘Sky Hunter’ in 2017 and ‘Operation Red Sea’ in 2018.

All these films had one thing in common: Chinese commandos fighting in global conflict zones from the Middle East to Africa, often against ‘White’ American mercenaries. Like the Rambo films of the 1980s that reflected America’s idea of itself as a superpower, this set of Chinese films reflected the emerging Chinese self-image of a muscular global power. So much so that when Chinese diplomats now respond to diplomatic tussles with verbal aggression, they are said to be practising ‘Wolf Warrior’ diplomacy, as Gideon Rachman recently noted.

Many of these Chinese films were produced with direct support from the Chinese military and had real military equipment — ‘Operation Red Sea’ featured the Chinese Navy’s frigates, ‘Sky Hunter’ had the J20 stealth fighter and ‘Wolf Warrior 2’, the biggest blockbuster in Chinese history, had PLA tanks.

In contrast, Indian war films have always had a local canvas: remaining focused almost entirely on Pakistan. There have been exceptions like Chetan Anand’s masterly Haqeeqat on the 1962 war or the odd Madras Café on Sri Lanka — but they have all been rooted in past Indian conflicts. As in the world of fiction, in the real world too, our security imagination as a society has almost entirely been Pakistan-focused. China was always in the background, but most people took the calm of the last 40 years on the eastern borders for granted. Now that this illusion is broken, it is time to do an honest stock-taking.

Make no mistake: the Indian Army is more than capable of giving the Chinese a bloody nose and is well-matched in the mountains as we have seen in recent clashes. Yet, at structural levels, there is a huge asymmetry that we must fix.

First, China spends $182 per person per year on defence. Indian per capita spending on defence is less than one-third: $52 per person. Even though India has been spending more than China on defence as a percentage of government spending — 8.8% compared to 5.4% by China — Chinese defence spending completely dwarfs India’s in real terms because China’s economy is much larger. China, in 2019, was estimated by SIPRI to have spent $261 billion on defence, more than three-and-a-half times India’s estimated $71 billion. In the last 10 years, Chinese military spending more than doubled, from $115.7 billion in 2010 to $261 billion in 2019. Indian military spending, on the other hand, is estimated to have gone up only by half from $46 billion in 2010.

Second, though India’s defence budget gets the highest allocation of all ministries, much of it goes into wages. This year the defence ministry will be spending almost as much on pensions (28.4%) as on salaries (30.2%).

Third, China’s increased military spending is part of a clear strategic ramp-up. The PLA was not a modern force until a decade ago. Xi Jinping termed the problems with the Chinese military as the ‘Five Incapables’ and publicly set a target in 2012 to turn the PLA into a “world class force” by 2030.

Since then, China not only downsized its Army personnel by 300,000, it reorganised the army, navy and air force into five integrated “theatre commands” for greater battle efficiency. In contrast, India’s army (7), navy (3) and air force (7) operate a total of 19 commands, all separately managed by each service (except two joint commands).

Fourth, there is a weapons gap. The Indian Navy is deployed on the eastern seaboard but has only 16 submarines, compared to China’s 74. Indian Air Force has 538 combat aircraft, China’s has 1,232. India has 8,686 armoured vehicles, the Chinese over 30,000.

India has a battle-hardened Army while the PLA hasn’t fought a war in over 40 years, but in the long run, India will need to rebalance its huge military asymmetry with China. Beijing has reset its strategic calculus. It is time New Delhi does so too.

Source: https://economictimes.indiatimes.co...ocial&utm_campaign=socialsharebutton&from=mdr


@Zarvan @Tipu7
 

Zarvan

ELITE MEMBER
Apr 28, 2011
50,528
81
55,852
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
It might be funny to even suggest Armed forces of any country to counter mighty PLA with Bollywood movies but The Economic Times has done such a wonder again. Read out and enjoy.

To take on Chinese ‘wolf warriors’, India must fix military asymmetry

Until 2014 or so, Chinese films hardly depicted any military conflict beyond World War II or the Chinese civil war of the 1940s. This trend changed completely with a new range of Hollywood-style Chinese war movies. They showcased a new kind of PLA and the idea of China as a global military superpower.

A nation’s movies often reflect its self-image. War films, even more so. As Indian troops face down China’s People Liberation Army in the Galwan Valley and across the Line of Actual Control, it is not entirely coincidental that the shift to such aggressive posturing by China on its real-life borders, from Ladakh to the South China Sea, was preceded in recent years by a major shift in depictions of the PLA in Chinese films.

Until 2014 or so, Chinese films hardly depicted any military conflict beyond World War II or the Chinese civil war of the 1940s. This trend changed completely with a new range of Hollywood-style Chinese war movies. They showcased a new kind of PLA and the idea of China as a global military superpower, as the journalists Charles Clover and Sherry Fei Ju noted in a perceptive 2018 overview of this phenomenon. The shift started, they said, with ‘Wolf Warrior’ in 2015, ‘Sky Hunter’ in 2017 and ‘Operation Red Sea’ in 2018.

All these films had one thing in common: Chinese commandos fighting in global conflict zones from the Middle East to Africa, often against ‘White’ American mercenaries. Like the Rambo films of the 1980s that reflected America’s idea of itself as a superpower, this set of Chinese films reflected the emerging Chinese self-image of a muscular global power. So much so that when Chinese diplomats now respond to diplomatic tussles with verbal aggression, they are said to be practising ‘Wolf Warrior’ diplomacy, as Gideon Rachman recently noted.

Many of these Chinese films were produced with direct support from the Chinese military and had real military equipment — ‘Operation Red Sea’ featured the Chinese Navy’s frigates, ‘Sky Hunter’ had the J20 stealth fighter and ‘Wolf Warrior 2’, the biggest blockbuster in Chinese history, had PLA tanks.

In contrast, Indian war films have always had a local canvas: remaining focused almost entirely on Pakistan. There have been exceptions like Chetan Anand’s masterly Haqeeqat on the 1962 war or the odd Madras Café on Sri Lanka — but they have all been rooted in past Indian conflicts. As in the world of fiction, in the real world too, our security imagination as a society has almost entirely been Pakistan-focused. China was always in the background, but most people took the calm of the last 40 years on the eastern borders for granted. Now that this illusion is broken, it is time to do an honest stock-taking.

Make no mistake: the Indian Army is more than capable of giving the Chinese a bloody nose and is well-matched in the mountains as we have seen in recent clashes. Yet, at structural levels, there is a huge asymmetry that we must fix.

First, China spends $182 per person per year on defence. Indian per capita spending on defence is less than one-third: $52 per person. Even though India has been spending more than China on defence as a percentage of government spending — 8.8% compared to 5.4% by China — Chinese defence spending completely dwarfs India’s in real terms because China’s economy is much larger. China, in 2019, was estimated by SIPRI to have spent $261 billion on defence, more than three-and-a-half times India’s estimated $71 billion. In the last 10 years, Chinese military spending more than doubled, from $115.7 billion in 2010 to $261 billion in 2019. Indian military spending, on the other hand, is estimated to have gone up only by half from $46 billion in 2010.

Second, though India’s defence budget gets the highest allocation of all ministries, much of it goes into wages. This year the defence ministry will be spending almost as much on pensions (28.4%) as on salaries (30.2%).

Third, China’s increased military spending is part of a clear strategic ramp-up. The PLA was not a modern force until a decade ago. Xi Jinping termed the problems with the Chinese military as the ‘Five Incapables’ and publicly set a target in 2012 to turn the PLA into a “world class force” by 2030.

Since then, China not only downsized its Army personnel by 300,000, it reorganised the army, navy and air force into five integrated “theatre commands” for greater battle efficiency. In contrast, India’s army (7), navy (3) and air force (7) operate a total of 19 commands, all separately managed by each service (except two joint commands).

Fourth, there is a weapons gap. The Indian Navy is deployed on the eastern seaboard but has only 16 submarines, compared to China’s 74. Indian Air Force has 538 combat aircraft, China’s has 1,232. India has 8,686 armoured vehicles, the Chinese over 30,000.

India has a battle-hardened Army while the PLA hasn’t fought a war in over 40 years, but in the long run, India will need to rebalance its huge military asymmetry with China. Beijing has reset its strategic calculus. It is time New Delhi does so too.

Source: https://economictimes.indiatimes.co...ocial&utm_campaign=socialsharebutton&from=mdr


@Zarvan @Tipu7
This is exactly and only thing they can do. Otherwise mighty Indian Army first was exposed by us and now China as for good for nothing force.
 

crankthatskunk

SENIOR MEMBER
May 20, 2011
4,292
3
8,221
Country
United Kingdom
Location
United Kingdom
This writer failed to mention, what percentage of Indian arms are in working conditions!!
Most of its artillery is dis-functional. Similarly, 40% of its fighter jets waiting for spare parts.
 

Zarvan

ELITE MEMBER
Apr 28, 2011
50,528
81
55,852
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
This writer failed to mention, what percentage of Indian arms are in working conditions!!
Most of its artillery is dis-functional. Similarly, 40% of its fighter jets waiting for spare parts.
The delusions of our neighbors are on next level. I have seen people getting blinded by patriotism but Indians take that blindness to whole new level. They still are not getting out of that mindset of being ruled by 600 years by Muslims and British that memory still haunts them in their dreams and their reactions and behavior is direct result of that.
 

PAKISTANFOREVER

ELITE MEMBER
Aug 15, 2015
13,378
-3
21,832
Country
United Kingdom
Location
Pakistan
It might be funny to even suggest Armed forces of any country to counter mighty PLA with Bollywood movies but The Economic Times has done such a wonder again. Read out and enjoy.

To take on Chinese ‘wolf warriors’, India must fix military asymmetry

Until 2014 or so, Chinese films hardly depicted any military conflict beyond World War II or the Chinese civil war of the 1940s. This trend changed completely with a new range of Hollywood-style Chinese war movies. They showcased a new kind of PLA and the idea of China as a global military superpower.

A nation’s movies often reflect its self-image. War films, even more so. As Indian troops face down China’s People Liberation Army in the Galwan Valley and across the Line of Actual Control, it is not entirely coincidental that the shift to such aggressive posturing by China on its real-life borders, from Ladakh to the South China Sea, was preceded in recent years by a major shift in depictions of the PLA in Chinese films.

Until 2014 or so, Chinese films hardly depicted any military conflict beyond World War II or the Chinese civil war of the 1940s. This trend changed completely with a new range of Hollywood-style Chinese war movies. They showcased a new kind of PLA and the idea of China as a global military superpower, as the journalists Charles Clover and Sherry Fei Ju noted in a perceptive 2018 overview of this phenomenon. The shift started, they said, with ‘Wolf Warrior’ in 2015, ‘Sky Hunter’ in 2017 and ‘Operation Red Sea’ in 2018.

All these films had one thing in common: Chinese commandos fighting in global conflict zones from the Middle East to Africa, often against ‘White’ American mercenaries. Like the Rambo films of the 1980s that reflected America’s idea of itself as a superpower, this set of Chinese films reflected the emerging Chinese self-image of a muscular global power. So much so that when Chinese diplomats now respond to diplomatic tussles with verbal aggression, they are said to be practising ‘Wolf Warrior’ diplomacy, as Gideon Rachman recently noted.

Many of these Chinese films were produced with direct support from the Chinese military and had real military equipment — ‘Operation Red Sea’ featured the Chinese Navy’s frigates, ‘Sky Hunter’ had the J20 stealth fighter and ‘Wolf Warrior 2’, the biggest blockbuster in Chinese history, had PLA tanks.

In contrast, Indian war films have always had a local canvas: remaining focused almost entirely on Pakistan. There have been exceptions like Chetan Anand’s masterly Haqeeqat on the 1962 war or the odd Madras Café on Sri Lanka — but they have all been rooted in past Indian conflicts. As in the world of fiction, in the real world too, our security imagination as a society has almost entirely been Pakistan-focused. China was always in the background, but most people took the calm of the last 40 years on the eastern borders for granted. Now that this illusion is broken, it is time to do an honest stock-taking.

Make no mistake: the Indian Army is more than capable of giving the Chinese a bloody nose and is well-matched in the mountains as we have seen in recent clashes. Yet, at structural levels, there is a huge asymmetry that we must fix.

First, China spends $182 per person per year on defence. Indian per capita spending on defence is less than one-third: $52 per person. Even though India has been spending more than China on defence as a percentage of government spending — 8.8% compared to 5.4% by China — Chinese defence spending completely dwarfs India’s in real terms because China’s economy is much larger. China, in 2019, was estimated by SIPRI to have spent $261 billion on defence, more than three-and-a-half times India’s estimated $71 billion. In the last 10 years, Chinese military spending more than doubled, from $115.7 billion in 2010 to $261 billion in 2019. Indian military spending, on the other hand, is estimated to have gone up only by half from $46 billion in 2010.

Second, though India’s defence budget gets the highest allocation of all ministries, much of it goes into wages. This year the defence ministry will be spending almost as much on pensions (28.4%) as on salaries (30.2%).

Third, China’s increased military spending is part of a clear strategic ramp-up. The PLA was not a modern force until a decade ago. Xi Jinping termed the problems with the Chinese military as the ‘Five Incapables’ and publicly set a target in 2012 to turn the PLA into a “world class force” by 2030.

Since then, China not only downsized its Army personnel by 300,000, it reorganised the army, navy and air force into five integrated “theatre commands” for greater battle efficiency. In contrast, India’s army (7), navy (3) and air force (7) operate a total of 19 commands, all separately managed by each service (except two joint commands).

Fourth, there is a weapons gap. The Indian Navy is deployed on the eastern seaboard but has only 16 submarines, compared to China’s 74. Indian Air Force has 538 combat aircraft, China’s has 1,232. India has 8,686 armoured vehicles, the Chinese over 30,000.

India has a battle-hardened Army while the PLA hasn’t fought a war in over 40 years, but in the long run, India will need to rebalance its huge military asymmetry with China. Beijing has reset its strategic calculus. It is time New Delhi does so too.

Source: https://economictimes.indiatimes.co...ocial&utm_campaign=socialsharebutton&from=mdr


@Zarvan @Tipu7





Can someone please explain this article? So let's get this straight. An indian who wrote this article is allegedly educated and claims that the best way to defeat China in reality is to start making indian films where they defeat China militarily?????????..........WTF!!!!!!!!!!!!...........:o::o::o::o::o::o::o:


In ALL HONESTY and trolling aside, indians DO NOT live on the same planet as NON-indians.
 

Max

ELITE MEMBER
Nov 3, 2014
8,350
-3
11,478
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Bharati trying to be "phunny". Other part you didn't notice was where he said India have bettle hardened military while China didn't fought any major war in last 40 years.

Which war India fought in last 40 years? Kargil was secret operation of Pakistan highly localized where Pakistan didn't even owned its people.

What war experience India have? Killing rag tag LeT and Nexals? Or firing on LoC which btw is not war either.
 

ADIL SHERDIL

FULL MEMBER
May 20, 2016
932
1
1,060
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
India can only win in Movies.Bollywood is not known for their innovations but rather known for item songs and dancing. Just imagine if Indian makes a movie on recent encounter with China, there will be soldiers diving in gulwan river and singing some patriotic songs, then hero will come with a machine gun and start killing Chinese soldiers he will destroy tanks jets and in the end President Xi will come and hand over the surrender.
This writer failed to mention, what percentage of Indian arms are in working conditions!!
Most of its artillery is dis-functional. Similarly, 40% of its fighter jets waiting for spare parts.
Sir what good are their weapons which are in working condition. IAF Crashes their planes regularly and IN forgets to close the Hatchets of their submarines and IA usually down their own heli. Their soldiers are mostly hungry and seen protesting

Can someone please explain this article? So let's get this straight. An indian who wrote this article is allegedly educated and claims that the best way to defeat China in reality is to start making indian films where they defeat China militarily?????????..........WTF!!!!!!!!!!!!...........:o::o::o::o::o::o::o:


In ALL HONESTY and trolling aside, indians DO NOT live on the same planet as NON-indians.
Actually no one can explain what Indian articles are all about. Yes Indians are not from this planet they were dropped on earth by the aliens. The authors has made it clear that Chinese might win the war in real life but they will never in Bollywood Movies featuring Sunny Deol who has been called from retirement for only this purpose.
 

PAKISTANFOREVER

ELITE MEMBER
Aug 15, 2015
13,378
-3
21,832
Country
United Kingdom
Location
Pakistan
India can only win in Movies.Bollywood is not known for their innovations but rather known for item songs and dancing. Just imagine if Indian makes a movie on recent encounter with China, there will be soldiers diving in gulwan river and singing some patriotic songs, then hero will come with a machine gun and start killing Chinese soldiers he will destroy tanks jets and in the end President Xi will come and hand over the surrender.


Sir what good are their weapons which are in working condition. IAF Crashes their planes regularly and IN forgets to close the Hatchets of their submarines and IA usually down their own heli. Their soldiers are mostly hungry and seen protesting


Actually no one can explain what Indian articles are all about. Yes Indians are not from this planet they were dropped on earth by the aliens. The authors has made it clear that Chinese might win the war in real life but they will never in Bollywood Movies featuring Sunny Deol who has been called from retirement for only this purpose.



indians are clearly the creation of aliens that went horribly wrong. They didn't want their mistake to be on their home planet so they decided to drop it off on earth.
 

masterchief_mirza

ELITE MEMBER
Apr 29, 2019
8,762
15
18,292
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Kingdom
Looking forward to Panipat 4. Highlights: The first encounter between the mighty Marathas - fresh from their decisive victory against the Afghans - and the new Ming dynasty menace arising in the north. Watch out for, making their historical debut, the Bihari regiment of the Maratha army and the moment they misunderstand the "Weapons Free!" command, with comical results.
 

Bagheera

BANNED
Jan 16, 2013
4,683
-49
1,508
Country
India
Location
India
Bharati trying to be "phunny". Other part you didn't notice was where he said India have bettle hardened military while China didn't fought any major war in last 40 years.

Which war India fought in last 40 years? Kargil was secret operation of Pakistan highly localized where Pakistan didn't even owned its people.

What war experience India have? Killing rag tag LeT and Nexals? Or firing on LoC which btw is not war either.
It's relative. Compared to Pakistani military, India's experience is negligible. But in Chinese context India's experience is more than enough. Apart from Kashmir and Naxalites, India had a bit of insurgency in North East.

- PRTP GWD
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Top Bottom