What's new

Fair Karachi census would have prevented PPP majority based on rural area and changed political landscape, establishment prevented that

W.11

ELITE MEMBER
Jan 20, 2011
14,795
-31
11,690
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
establishment ensured that PPPP formed government through rural areas, increasing the Karachi representation through fair census would have ensured PPP couldn't form govt based solely on interior rural sindh's votes, Lack of majority would have forced PPP concede to Karachi demands by seeking its coalition otherwise it would have lead to assembly dissolution, relection and political turmoil.

Karachi was handed short stick by the very own armed establishment so lets not blame PPP solely for the bad situation of the city.

regards
 
Last edited:

PaklovesTurkiye

SENIOR MEMBER
Dec 1, 2015
6,351
9
15,742
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
establishment ensured that PPPP formed government through rural areas, increasing the Karachi representation through fair census would have ensured PPP couldn't form govt based solely on interior rural sindh's votes, Lack of majority would have forced PPP concede to Karachi demands by seeking its coalition otherwise it would have lead to assembly dissolution, relection and political turmoil.

Karachi was handed short stick by the very own armed establishment so lets not blame PPP solely for the bad situation of the city.

regards
So true.

But apna time ayega, IA.

Ye Zulm mazeed nh chalega.
 

HAIDER

ELITE MEMBER
May 21, 2006
23,219
13
22,672
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
establishment ensured that PPPP formed government through rural areas, increasing the Karachi representation through fair census would have ensured PPP couldn't form govt based solely on interior rural sindh's votes, Lack of majority would have forced PPP concede to Karachi demands by seeking its coalition otherwise it would have lead to assembly dissolution, relection and political turmoil.

Karachi was handed short stick by the very own armed establishment so lets not blame PPP solely for the bad situation of the city.

regards
Literally, tired of this constant suffering . We need solution. If not, then ..... this is constant oppression and suppression of basic rights ...
 

newb3e

ELITE MEMBER
Jun 25, 2007
9,239
-21
8,613
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
I think national and provincial assembly seats of Karachi should be decreased. Because Karachi is a small area. In some other areas of Sindh national assembly halqas are of thousands of square kilometers and in Karachi Few thousand square km area have 21 MNAs.
genius!
 

newb3e

ELITE MEMBER
Jun 25, 2007
9,239
-21
8,613
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Do you agree with me? Halqas k liye population k sath minimum and maximum area requirement bhi honi chahiye.
itna proper zoning khi may possible nai hai yahan sab bas keeray makorun ki turgan grow ho raha hai khi ka solution Pakistan keh dosray ilaqun may roozgar hai jab logon ko apnay abaye ilaqun may roozgar milay ga toh khi may khuwar honay nai aye gey aur jo aagaye hain woh wapis chalay jain gey is turhan kpi 20-24% abadi kum hojaye gee aur infrastructure ko fix karna asaan hojahe ga!

ya vote shote ka chakkar sirf thaikaydarun ki game hai inko sirf paisay bananay may interest hai awaam aur mulk may nai;
 

Imad.Khan

SENIOR MEMBER
Sep 24, 2015
6,163
9
8,892
Country
Pakistan
Location
Australia
There should be a maximum and minimum area requirement for halqas. In Balochistan Dera bugti kohlu barkhan sibi all these districts combined have 1 national assembly seat. And an other city of Balochistan quetta have 2 or 3 seats. Kya itnay baray halqa main koi aam politician campaign kar skta ha?
So you reckon instead of electoral constituencies maybe just go by districts or tehsils irrespective of the population density?
 

Imad.Khan

SENIOR MEMBER
Sep 24, 2015
6,163
9
8,892
Country
Pakistan
Location
Australia
Tehsil and districts are not of same size. Aik city main kisi halqa ki population ziada bhi ho wahan campaign krna logon say milna easier hota ha kyonki thori place par ziada log rehtay Hain. Lahore ki 14 ki jaga 6 or 7 seats hon to koi farq nhi paray ga.
Halqa bandi k liye area requirement honi chahiye. for Example halqa 600 square km sa kam na ho and 6,000 square km sa ziada na ho.
interesting perspective, i might have to do some more digging around on this and see the impact and/or benefits
 

Super Falcon

ELITE MEMBER
Jul 3, 2008
14,038
-4
5,331
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Arab Emirates
Dont agree probleum is more than half population of karachi is based on people who come from other provinces if u talj fair take them out first than do census who has stakes in karachi probleum is not only with ppp probleum is no one is sincere
 

0xDEADBEEF

FULL MEMBER

New Recruit

Feb 28, 2019
65
0
96
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Arab Emirates
Dont agree probleum is more than half population of karachi is based on people who come from other provinces if u talj fair take them out first than do census who has stakes in karachi probleum is not only with ppp probleum is no one is sincere
Take them out first? What do you mean by that? In 1947 Karachi had population of around 5 hundred thousands only and then everyone came to Karachi for work and living at some point in past. Everyone has right to go and live where ever than want. Why do people think Karachi is only for muhajirs?
 

W.11

ELITE MEMBER
Jan 20, 2011
14,795
-31
11,690
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Take them out first? What do you mean by that? In 1947 Karachi had population of around 5 hundred thousands only and then everyone came to Karachi for work and living at some point in past. Everyone has right to go and live where ever than want. Why do people think Karachi is only for muhajirs?
mohajirs came and settled in the city and they are counted in its census, ask federal govt, why they only count half of karachi's population
 

0xDEADBEEF

FULL MEMBER

New Recruit

Feb 28, 2019
65
0
96
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Arab Emirates
mohajirs came and settled in the city and they are counted in its census, ask federal govt, why they only count half of karachi's population
I am not talking about what govt did or didn't do. I am talking about this mentality that Karachi is for mohjirs only take other people out or sent them back home.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)

Top