Both are proven winners so absolutely if we want to go to the next level and win things again. Any half decent manager I am sure would have won yesterdays game given the squad and talent a Utd manager has at their disposal.Would you take conte since he just left inter, or even allegri? I thank ole for his service but its time to part ways and find someone who can take us to the next level.
I mean fair play to Emery and Villarreal. Their tactics were spot on and they wanted to win more than Utd. However having said that there is no doubt that on an individual level Utds players are far better than Villareals and any half decent manager would have been able to score a victory yesterday.
Ole has shown repeatedly that in big cup games he is completely overwhelmed and out of his depth. For me the most shocking decision of the season wasn't even taking off a goalscorer in place of a CDM in a cup final when we are 1 goal away from winning the whole thing. For me the most shocking was keeping Fred on against PSG in our champions League game when he was on a yellow and sliding and tackling around like a wild dog. Literally everybody i spoke to at half time said we need to take Fred off, he's going to get booked again. How can so many fans collectively know what's going to happen a couple of minutes into the second half and the manager has no clue!
I can go on and on but honestly Ole was a stop gap measure to prevent a free fall after the Mourinho and Van Gaal disasters. He has achieved that task very well and should be commended for it but enough is enough. If there is any ambition left in the club then he has to go.