What's new

Dealing with India and TTP

Mr.Green

FULL MEMBER
Dec 19, 2014
329
2
261
Country
Pakistan
Location
New Zealand
The Tamils initially started their liberation movement in South of India in Tamil Nadu. After some time RAW infiltrated them and convinced the leadership that if they launch their movement in Sri Lanka then there is a bigger opportunity for them to achieve independence there. So in this way the Indians got the Tamil burden off their backs and handed the present to Sri Lanka.

We should do the same with TTP and convince them that there is more opportunity to work in occupied Kashmir after the fall of Kabul. The Afghan Taliban would also by sympathetic to such a development.

Yesterday's bomb blast in Anarkali, Lahore by Baloch Nationalists is a wake up reminder to us that India has not stopped support to the insurgents in Pakistan.

We can kill two birds with one stone by opening up the way for TTP to operate in occupied Kashmir.

Might also motivate the ISIS-K in the same way to make a Khilafat in occupied Kashmir.
 
Last edited:

Titanium100

SENIOR MEMBER
Mar 1, 2019
6,828
-9
5,653
Country
Denmark
Location
Denmark
Launching insurgency in Kashmir is fruitless and there is no tactical upside to it. The Indian army is large enough to deal with it and they have endless recruit options. It will be like a drop into the ocean. The indians can redeploy from an endless pool of 1.4bil...

The best thing to do with them is re-integrate them into the armed forces and besides there is no insurgency solution to India but they must be rolled over in an offensive all out war.. There is no rush
 

Shehryar Ashraf

FULL MEMBER
Aug 18, 2021
197
1
285
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
insurgencies are wars of attrition and only work if the enemy is short of manpower, or making the conflict politically unfeasible, like Vietnam.
neither of these apply to Gangaland, who have no shortage of recruitments, and the war is a vote winner over there.
so any one talking about an insurgency is an idiot.
the problem with dealing with that state on our east is that it can only understand pain like it felt pain in Mumbai, back in 2008.
it must suffer, but in the mainland and not in Kashmir, where more deaths only trigger a patriotic wave of opinion.
 

SaadH

FULL MEMBER
Apr 22, 2021
1,496
0
1,993
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
Yes, the battle has to be taken to the Indian cities and a page has to be taken out their playbook, i.e. hitting them where it hurts the most, foreign cricket tours, IPL, financial center, tech centers in the south.
 

surya kiran

SENIOR MEMBER
Feb 23, 2012
4,779
-3
5,403
Country
India
Location
India
The Tamils initially started their liberation movement in South of India in Tamil Nadu. After some time RAW infiltrated them and convinced the leadership that if they launch their movement in Sri Lanka then there is a bigger opportunity for them to achieve independence there. So in this way the Indians got the Tamil burden off their backs and handed the present to Sri Lanka.

We should do the same with TTP and convince them that there is more opportunity to work in occupied Kashmir after the fall of Kabul. The Afghan Taliban would also by sympathetic to such a development.

Yesterday's bomb blast in Anarkali, Lahore by Baloch Nationalists is a wake up reminder to us that India has not stopped support to the insurgents in Pakistan.

We can kill two birds with one stone by opening up the way for TTP to operate in occupied Kashmir.

Might also motivate the ISIS-K in the same way to make a Khilafat in occupied Kashmir.

This is called intellectual masturbation. Bachon. Dekho, ye roz raat ko karna chahiye...din mein nahin. The part without the intellectual, I mean. Its more fun.

@Imran Khan kuch beer pilao bachon ko. Kya akele akele peethe ho.

Btw, how is @niaz saab. Hope he is doing well in this pandemic.
 

khansaheeb

ELITE MEMBER
Dec 14, 2008
12,849
-7
14,843
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Kingdom
Launching insurgency in Kashmir is fruitless and there is no tactical upside to it. The Indian army is large enough to deal with it and they have endless recruit options. It will be like a drop into the ocean. The indians can redeploy from an endless pool of 1.4bil...

The best thing to do with them is re-integrate them into the armed forces and besides there is no insurgency solution to India but they must be rolled over in an offensive all out war.. There is no rush
That's what the Russians thought when they attacked Chechnya that numbers and size will lead to victory, but as history has shown time and time again it is the strength of belief and fearlessness that leads to victory.
 

Titanium100

SENIOR MEMBER
Mar 1, 2019
6,828
-9
5,653
Country
Denmark
Location
Denmark
That's what the Russians thought when they attacked Chechnya that numbers and size will lead to victory, but as history has shown time and time again it is the strength of belief and fearlessness that leads to victory.

Some small insurgency can't be chellenge to India or Pakistan both as you can see they are unsuccessful only if a major civil war breaks out inside interior of India that is a different case but a small limited insurgency is not a chellenge besides war is not based on fearlessness but military tactics and brains hence smaller insurgencies in Balochiestan, KPK, Tamil Nadu, 7 sister states and Kashmir has proven to be unsuccessful because of endless pool of redeployment opportunities for both countries.. besides Chechnya is not a chellenge for Russia they number only like 1 million.. It is like a drop in the ocean another example is Turkey and YPG they caused just small annoyance on a very low treeshold
 
Last edited:

Mr.Green

FULL MEMBER
Dec 19, 2014
329
2
261
Country
Pakistan
Location
New Zealand
Launching insurgency in Kashmir is fruitless and there is no tactical upside to it. The Indian army is large enough to deal with it and they have endless recruit options. It will be like a drop into the ocean. The indians can redeploy from an endless pool of 1.4bil...

The best thing to do with them is re-integrate them into the armed forces and besides there is no insurgency solution to India but they must be rolled over in an offensive all out war.. There is no rush
You can consider practically re-integrated with the army if they agree to Kashmir Jihad,
 

STREANH

FULL MEMBER
Aug 12, 2021
332
0
486
Country
India
Location
Kuwait
OP wants his country to work with terrorists who massacred school children in his own country. He doesn't even try to learn from history or previous mistakes.

Moreover TTP is more of an ethno-nationalist militant organisation. They don't give a damn about Kashmir.
 

Saudang

FULL MEMBER
Sep 21, 2020
551
-14
498
Country
India
Location
India
insurgencies are wars of attrition and only work if the enemy is short of manpower, or making the conflict politically unfeasible, like Vietnam.
neither of these apply to Gangaland, who have no shortage of recruitments, and the war is a vote winner over there.
so any one talking about an insurgency is an idiot.
the problem with dealing with that state on our east is that it can only understand pain like it felt pain in Mumbai, back in 2008.
it must suffer, but in the mainland and not in Kashmir, where more deaths only trigger a patriotic wave of opinion.
The bigger question will be whether Pakistan can endure the same pain they had to go through post 2008 Mumbai attack. If you think you can, you are most welcomed to try another hit at India
 

Sudarshan

FULL MEMBER
Jul 26, 2021
1,791
-8
1,718
Country
India
Location
Nepal
OP wants his country to work with terrorists who massacred school children in his own country. He doesn't even try to learn from history or previous mistakes.

Moreover TTP is more of an ethno-nationalist militant organisation. They don't give a damn about Kashmir.
They have used the word Falasteen (Palestine) and Kashmir in one of their propoganda videos
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Top Bottom