What's new

Congratulations liberals, for another self-goal in forcing Bloomsbury on Delhi riots book

Joe Shearer

PROFESSIONAL
Apr 19, 2009
24,277
144
40,230
Country
India
Location
India
There is no proof, Yogi killed any minority.
Did I say that he went out with a chopper and hacked down women and children?

His was the larger responsibility of the person empowered to protect all law-abiding members of society, who selectively withdraws that protection from individual members in consonance with his personal beliefs, and thereby becomes a traitor to the constitution that he has pledged to obey.
 

rishav

FULL MEMBER
Jul 23, 2016
951
-3
737
Country
India
Location
India
What is your objection to "Secular" and "Socialist" ? Do you not want a progressive society ?
The definition of progressive is not clear here . I don't consider amending the constitution by imposing an emergency , a process which otherwise requires a special majority support of the parliament as progressive . What I wan't doesn't matter . Besides I am not a fan of socialism , I consider it unnatural and certainly not progressive .
 

PakSword

MODERATOR
Dec 6, 2015
17,887
55
33,919
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Arab Emirates
Liberals should be liberal enough to accept majority's rule. Currently in India, BJP is ruling and they won majority of the seats in the parliament. Liberals should accept them with open heart.
 

Sam.

SENIOR MEMBER
Mar 1, 2013
2,947
-4
3,381
Country
India
Location
India
The definition of progressive is not clear here . I don't consider amending the constitution by imposing an emergency , a process which otherwise requires a special majority support of the parliament as progressive . What I wan't doesn't matter . Besides I am not a fan of socialism , I consider it unnatural and certainly not progressive .
They have no respect for the law but only what they think is right should be the law. Understand that!
 

xeuss

SENIOR MEMBER
Aug 22, 2019
3,697
6
7,797
Country
India
Location
United States
Liberals should be liberal enough to accept majority's rule. Currently in India, BJP is ruling and they won majority of the seats in the parliament. Liberals should accept them with open heart.
The BJP is ruling. No one, least of all liberals, is preventing this process.

The issue here is the publication of a book that seeks to falsely blame the victims for the crimes committed by perpetrators. The "liberals" used democratic tools of petition and persuasion to convince the publisher to withdraw publication of the book.

Do you suggest that because BJP won the majority of the seats in a general election, that other legal means of democratic expression should not be utilized?
 

The BrOkEn HeArT

SENIOR MEMBER
Mar 17, 2015
2,794
-46
3,005
Country
India
Location
India
Not at all.
For me, the Supreme Court has been cowed down by the intimidatory tactics of the ruling party. They are in bondage, and not independent agents.
I don't think so! Supreme Court is always an independent institution.
This is just desperation that you see everyone cowed down to ruling party.
RaGa says the same and he is the most desperate man in congress, he is running a clear propaganda against BJP which you can see with naked eyes.
 
Last edited:

The BrOkEn HeArT

SENIOR MEMBER
Mar 17, 2015
2,794
-46
3,005
Country
India
Location
India
Did I say that he went out with a chopper and hacked down women and children?

His was the larger responsibility of the person empowered to protect all law-abiding members of society, who selectively withdraws that protection from individual members in consonance with his personal beliefs, and thereby becomes a traitor to the constitution that he has pledged to obey.
How many Hindu-Muslims riots happened in Yogi govt? I didn't find much.
if he had any intention to kill minority, then riots are easy option. Lynching is a different issue, it is done by individual sect, not by govt order, many factors has involved in it, like smuggling, stealing, faith....!
 

PakSword

MODERATOR
Dec 6, 2015
17,887
55
33,919
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Arab Emirates
The BJP is ruling. No one, least of all liberals, is preventing this process.

The issue here is the publication of a book that seeks to falsely blame the victims for the crimes committed by perpetrators. The "liberals" used democratic tools of petition and persuasion to convince the publisher to withdraw publication of the book.

Do you suggest that because BJP won the majority of the seats in a general election, that other legal means of democratic expression should not be utilized?
I am not against any legal steps taken against facism. However, you need to understand that sane people are very few. At least we across the border, and many in other countries think so. We judge you through your media. It depicts the true picture of your society.

And to be honest, you can do nothing. I remember a recent case in which killers were acquitted by your courts despite clear footage of the lynching available, and no one except very few raised their voice.

A mosque has been given to the non-Muslims despite court's fully knowing that there is no evidence to support the Hindu claims. The people you call liberals celebrated the move. Even congress supported building of the mandir.

Either your liberals are very few, or they aren't liberals at all. I am sure that going against this book has other motives. People who didn't even know about this book will now buy and read it. This is how they play with you guys and how they have been playing with you for over 70 years.

The people who call themselves liberal even on this forum are supporters of Hindutva and Hindu lynching mobs. They want to present a good picture of your society, however, they fail to convince people because nowadays the news of supression are pouring like raindrops.
 

xeuss

SENIOR MEMBER
Aug 22, 2019
3,697
6
7,797
Country
India
Location
United States
I am not against any legal steps taken against facism. However, you need to understand that sane people are very few. At least we across the border, and many in other countries think so. We judge you through your media. It depicts the true picture of your society.

And to be honest, you can do nothing. I remember a recent case in which killers were acquitted by your courts despite clear footage of the lynching available, and no one except very few raised their voice.

A mosque has been given to the non-Muslims despite court's fully knowing that there is no evidence to support the Hindu claims. The people you call liberals celebrated the move. Even congress supported building of the mandir.

Either your liberals are very few, or they aren't liberals at all. I am sure that going against this book has other motives. People who didn't even know about this book will now buy and read it. This is how they play with you guys and how they have been playing with you for over 70 years.

The people who call themselves liberal even on this forum are supporters of Hindutva and Hindu lynching mobs. They want to present a good picture of your society, however, they fail to convince people because nowadays the news of supression are pouring like raindrops.
Some context should be provided here. The book was simply a print publication of a collection of fictional articles that existed on the SaffronNazi websites OpIndia and the RSS rag Organiser. It is nothing new. However, what is does, is provide the mainstreaming of Goebbelsian propaganda in India.

Your comments on the state of the liberals in India is well deserved. There were several people who protested the publication of this book. Not all of them fall under the criteria you have covered.
 

PakSword

MODERATOR
Dec 6, 2015
17,887
55
33,919
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Arab Emirates
However, what is does, is provide the mainstreaming of Goebbelsian propaganda in India.
It is bound to happen, if not today then tomorrow for sure. There's no turning back from where your society has reached. This fascism wil only increase.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Top Bottom