What's new

Conflict of intrest at the Highest Office??

AZ1

SENIOR MEMBER
Jul 25, 2017
7,330
-2
7,172
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
This government has given ABSOLUTE immunity to Governor SBP, Chairman CPEC (Pizza Waly), Chairman Ravi River Front Authority and to many more, why they are so special??
Oppositon should take this matter to court? who is stopping them? why things ran only on media.and never see the day light in court?
 

S.Y.A

SENIOR MEMBER
Mar 21, 2008
2,965
2
3,303
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Oppositon should take this matter to court? who is stopping them? why things ran only on media.and never see the day light in court?
its not because what the president did was not wrong, but simply because the opposition has similar skeletons in their respective closets. iss hamam main sab nanagay hain.
 

khail007

SENIOR MEMBER
Mar 25, 2008
3,838
1
4,294
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Arab Emirates
What is the significance of such an oath in the Presidency, PM house, Senate, and Parliament? All who were holding the offices/seats in the past since the last 30 years did set the exemplary characters? If not all most of the politicos are of the same corrupt/thief category, apart from their political affiliations.

It is clear that the pain inflicted is just as the corrupts/absconders/thieves of PML (Narendra Modi) group is not in power to launder Pakistan's money and accumulate the wealth in Europe/West.

IMO you should invest your energies in some positive activities, which elevate the prosperity of the people of Pakistan rather than advocating the corrupt/thieves which is also contrary to your 'oath' as being a Muslim. Such advocacy will not earn you even a simple good deed.
 

ejaz007

SENIOR MEMBER
Jul 25, 2007
6,441
1
2,938
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
President Alvi blesses family business: A potential conflict of interest?







Dr Awab Alvi during the MoU signing between Alvi Dental and Bringing Smiles USA. Photo: Awab Alvi Twitter
Dr Awab Alvi during the MoU signing between Alvi Dental and Bringing Smiles USA. Photo: Awab Alvi Twitter
The president’s son, Dr Awab Alvi, recently took to Twitter to announce that his family business, Alvi Dental, has signed a memorandum of understanding (MoU) with Bringing Smiles USA.
Alvi wrote that under the agreement the two companies will be opening up a chain of dental practices to bring affordable care to Pakistan.


President Dr Arif Alvi also congratulated his son on Twitter, for bringing in foreign investment and wished him success.


The image of the MoU signing showed the president in attendance, which divided netizens with some asking if this was a direct conflict of interest? Was the president using his official position to benefit his family business? While others argued that this was merely a familial obligation.
Alvi Dental is a private dental business run by the president’s son, from which Dr Arif Alvi resigned, states his son, after he was appointed president in 2018.
However, the website of the practice still lists the president as a dentist and part of “Our Team”, even providing an option to 'schedule an appointment'.
President Alvi blesses family business: A potential conflict of interest?



President Alvi blesses family business: A potential conflict of interest?

Geo.tv asks legal experts to weigh in on the president blessing his family business with his words and his presence as a public office holder:
'Offense under NAB law and violation of oath'

This is an egregious violation of basic principles of conflict of interest. Moreover, the use of Governor House and the presence of the President is illegal use of state resources and an offence under the National Accountability Bureau Ordinance, 1999, Section 9 (a) (iv).

It is also a violation of the president’s oath, which states that: “I will not allow my personal interest to influence my official conduct or my official decisions.”

A senior lawyer based in Karachi, who asked not to be named.
President Alvi blesses family business: A potential conflict of interest?

'The president must clarify'

The president is mandated by the Constitution to abide by his oath in the Third Schedule: “that I will not allow my personal interest to influence my official conduct or my official decisions.”

This ceremony involves a private business, but is marked with the federation’s seal (through Governor Sindh), and with the president in attendance.

Pakistan has a history of family members benefiting from their closeness to the presidency, from field marshal Ayub onwards. As someone who protested against that regime, Mr. Alvi is well-aware of this trend, and promised to fight it. He must clarify how this is not a clear conflict of interest.

Asad Rahim Khan is a lawyer based in Lahore.

'Will need to dig deeper to determine conflict of interest'

As per this Constitution one of the conditions of the President's office is that he / she shall not hold any office of profit in the service of Pakistan or occupy any position carrying the right to remuneration for the rendering of services. Whilst strictly speaking it does not violate the said condition, there is a possibility of there being a conflict of interest if he is using his position to benefit either himself or his family.

What financial benefit he is directly deriving from his family business will not be important as long as he has not used his office to derive the said benefit.

Thus, in my opinion to see what the conflict is, we would have to dig deeper into the influence, if any, exercised and the benefits derived therefrom.

Maria Farooq is a lawyer based in Lahore.
'Poor judgment not conflict of interest'
Strictly legally speaking, this does not appear to be a conflict of interest.
Article 43(1) of the Constitution prohibits the President from holding any office of profit in the service of Pakistan or occupy any other position carrying the right to remuneration for the rendering of services. Furthermore the Presidential oath states that the President will not allow his personal interest to influence his official conduct or official decisions.
Since here, it is the President’s son and not the President himself who is entering into an MoU, it cannot strictly be called a conflict of interest. That said, the fact that the President chose to officially publicise the event on Twitter and that it happened at the Governor House does reflect poor judgment, if not illegality. Optically, it would have been better for the President to have distanced himself from this transaction.
Hira Jaleel is a lawyer based in Lahore.

 

baqai

SENIOR MEMBER
Sep 28, 2006
2,458
1
3,264
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
only the venue selection? what a chotium sulphate statement, doubt it will ever be accepted by any decent compliance department, so much COI going on here, sheesh man. From his presence being there, to his tweet as President of Pakistan to the fact that he brought politics into the matter (by congratulating for bringing foreign investment)
 

Mentee

ELITE MEMBER
Feb 3, 2016
9,822
2
22,336
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
only the venue selection? what a chotium sulphate statement, doubt it will ever be accepted by any decent compliance department, so much COI going on here, sheesh man. From his presence being there, to his tweet as President of Pakistan to the fact that he brought politics into the matter (by congratulating for bringing foreign investment)
office m aik din khaana ghr sy ya pay cheque sy mangvana paray to shaid ghashi k doray parnay lgy
 

muhammadhafeezmalik

FULL MEMBER
Jan 21, 2015
1,620
-6
1,426
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
What is the significance of such an oath in the Presidency, PM house, Senate, and Parliament? All who were holding the offices/seats in the past since the last 30 years did set the exemplary characters? If not all most of the politicos are of the same corrupt/thief category, apart from their political affiliations.

It is clear that the pain inflicted is just as the corrupts/absconders/thieves of PML (Narendra Modi) group is not in power to launder Pakistan's money and accumulate the wealth in Europe/West.

IMO you should invest your energies in some positive activities, which elevate the prosperity of the people of Pakistan rather than advocating the corrupt/thieves which is also contrary to your 'oath' as being a Muslim. Such advocacy will not earn you even a simple good deed.
Why just politicians are being questioned for not keeping their oath , why not to question those who violated their oaths in uniform??
 

baqai

SENIOR MEMBER
Sep 28, 2006
2,458
1
3,264
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
office m aik din khaana ghr sy ya pay cheque sy mangvana paray to shaid ghashi k doray parnay lgy
he was faculty member of KMDC (Karachi Medical Dental College), ask anyone who has been associated with that place about how many times he used to come there and how many lectures he took.
 

El Sidd

ELITE MEMBER
Apr 5, 2017
62,531
5
50,220
Country
Pakistan
Location
Canada
All ordinances passed by this president must be investigated.

This man gave an interview to a female media person looking her in the eye and stating everyone and everything has a price.

#tlpimpeachespresident
 

khail007

SENIOR MEMBER
Mar 25, 2008
3,838
1
4,294
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Arab Emirates
Why just politicians are being questioned for not keeping their oath , why not to question those who violated their oaths in uniform??
The onus of keeping the oath preliminary to politicians and then to armed forces.
Just an example, if the politicos tried to change the constitution with an amendment that conflicts with the basic pillars of Isalm, what is your opinion, are the men in uniform's to allow this where their own oath forces them to guard the ideology of Pakistan?
 

muhammadhafeezmalik

FULL MEMBER
Jan 21, 2015
1,620
-6
1,426
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
The onus of keeping the oath preliminary to politicians and then to armed forces.
Just an example, if the politicos tried to change the constitution with an amendment that conflicts with the basic pillars of Isalm, what is your opinion, are the men in uniform's to allow this where their own oath forces them to guard the ideology of Pakistan?
This is not their job, these PURJOSH SARFROSH can go to the Supreme Court or Shariat Court to nullified these amendments.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)


Top Bottom